Wal-Mart signifies all that is wrong in America

Vance

New Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2004
Messages
4,265
Reaction score
1
Magatsu's note: This editorial is f**kin' excellent. Here it is:


Bentonville, Ark., is home to Wal-Mart Corp. Wal-Mart, referred to by some as the ''Beast of Bentonville,'' is ubiquitous. We all shop there, even liberal employment lawyers who cannot say anything of a salutary nature about the place. Wal-Mart pays substandard wages, aggressively opposes union organizing efforts, prevents most of its employees from working full time and enforces tough labor policies in its stores. It dominates and saturates markets and unflinchingly squeezes out competitors. And, as a series of nationwide raids by federal agents suggests, it may have something of an illegal immigrant problem, as about 250 who worked cleaning Wal-Mart stores were seized.

Despite all of this, Wal-Mart is your headquarters for good old-fashioned Americana, served up in oversized plastic containers. It is the last retail stop on a long train ride to the end of what used to be known as the American dream. Its bright corridors are crammed with merchandise churned out in the sweatshops of Central America or Southeast Asia. While in a Wal-Mart, one encounters little yellow ''happy-face'' signs, busily engaged in ''price rollbacks.'' It is a multibillion dollar enterprise that, manifesting no sense of irony, fancies itself to be a champion of ''Christian values.''

At the same time, it censors artistic material, refuses to sell certain music CDs and bans ''risque'' magazines like Maxim, FHM and Stuff, apparently believing that pictures of pretty girls pose a grave danger to the purity of our souls.

Having said this, I still find myself shopping there on occasion. A few months ago, I was walking through a Wal-Mart store on Route 309, on my way back to Bethlehem after a day in court in Philadelphia. What I saw there could conceivably, depending upon the eyes of the beholder, be viewed as an affront to one's sensibilities. It was an enlarged color photograph of President George W. Bush standing on that aircraft carrier in the Pacific Ocean off San Diego. It was taken on May 1, and it depicted Mr. Bush dressed in a flight suit, holding a jet pilot's flight helmet. On that day, he announced an end to major hostilities in Iraq. It has become an officially famous picture. At the time, I was reminded of Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart's concurring opinion on the definition of obscenity in Jacobellis v. Ohio: ''I know it when I see it.''

After selling this photo of the President, Wal-Mart then decided to cover up the covers of certain terribly naughty women's magazines like Elle, Cosmopolitan, and Vogue, because of racy or suggestive images allegedly appearing on their covers. It would be fascinating to interview the Wal-Mart magazine censor to find out what sort of pictures would have to grace the cover of a magazine to warrant a plain brown cardboard cover. I wanted to place a plain brown wrapper over that aircraft carrier photograph of President Bush, but obviously that would not have pleased Wal-Mart's security officers.

Incredibly, Wal-Mart's pseudo-Christian, true-blue, patriotic-American, moralizing-crusader mindset blends well with its vigorous gun and ammunition sales and gun magazines, not to mention its glossy photographs of presidents striking faux warrior poses.

Wal-Mart likes to show off its smiling employees in advertisements. Meanwhile, it continues creating harsh working environments. Behind those smiles, we can see a company pursuing a policy of intolerance and censorship, listening too closely to certain elements of the religious right, such as the Rev. Donald Wildmon's Mississippi-based American Family Association.Wildmon's minions are gravely concerned about sexy pictures, naughty words and any form of misbehaving. Wal-Mart, which is far too solicitous of the opinions of people like Wildmon, is making sure that when little Billy waits in its checkout lines with Mommy, he won't have to see Sarah Jessica Parker's cleavage.

Just when I thought that Wal-Mart's ambitious journey into the heart of censorship darkness couldn't get any more intriguing, I learned that Playboy magazine is planning to do a photo shoot entitled ''The Women of Wal-Mart.'' The boys in Bentonville are going to be utterly horrified by such sinfulness on the part of their female employees who participate in Playboy's endeavor. Someone at Playboy must have a good sense of humor; but I hope the magazine pays these women well. They are going to need the money. Their futures at Wal-Mart, to put it delicately, might be somewhat in doubt. Self-expression, fully clad or not, doesn't play well in the face of corporate heavy-handedness.

Source: http://www.mcall.com/news/opinion/o...0,1966314.column?coll=all-newsopinionoped-col


I personally hate Wal-Mart... Well, not only that reason but Wal-Mart supported the children labor in China. No, I am not kidding. I found out that more and more people start to stop shopping at Walmart and shop at Target and other local stores included family-business stores. That's really good news.
 
Walmart has always been my favorite store. It's the only place where I can get affordable stuff.
 
VamPyroX said:
Walmart has always been my favorite store. It's the only place where I can get affordable stuff.


:werd: me too. Wal-Mart is better than Kmart that is for sure. :thumb:
 
Excellent editorial piece there.

I have always avoided shopping at Walmart because I never felt comfortable with their principles and values. Even if it is cheaper, I would rather pay a little more with my social consicence at ease.
 
I'm hypocritical. I don't want to shop there, but the wife insists on it.

Remember, it's all about the prices and image. If that was to change in any way, WalMart would lose their competitive advantage. If we shop with our dollars elsewhere, WalMart will lose. The problem is that no one else will shop elsewhere for the prices they get.

Nothing you can do about it -- except vote with your wallet.
 
bbnt said:
I refuse to shop at Walmart

I refuse to shop at Wal-mart as well. Wal-mart has a reputation of building big stores in any given area, lowering cost than the local competition. Doing that, most times drives the competition away or out of business. When that does happen, prices in Wal-mart begin to climb back up. I have seen Wal-mart pop up around Charlotte like wild fire. And the stores are getting bigger to the point it will or is a one stop shop. If there is no competition to Wal-mart, they can charge any price they want for products that are not exactly of good quality. I am willing to pay more for the american made product, in support for American jobs. I better stop typing while I can before it becomes a mess.
 
i do not like wal-fart :barf: on rare occasions i get dragged there :roll:

i dont like their business practices :thumbd: and besides their products are not very good IMHO
 
I would rather go to Target or Costco than to go to Walfart, but I do admit going to Walfart sometimes just cos you cannot beat the prices there.
 
Magatsu said:
Wal-Mart pays substandard wages, aggressively opposes union organizing efforts, prevents most of its employees from working full time and enforces tough labor policies in its stores.


I have to disagree with Walmart prevents most of its employees from working full time. I speak from my own experiences. I do work full time at Wal-Mart for little over than a year now from cashier to cash office as accounting. Yes there are many part time employees, cuz they chooses to work part time, and it's hard to go from part-time to full-time and also it's because of their performance. So the way the boss at Walmart oversee the employees's performance. I worked very hard and I got the wages nearly 10 bucks an hour, which isn't that bad compared to Target pay low from my old job. I know I've went to some old walmarts, some of them sucks. The new Wal-Mart Supercenters are clearly what I like, just remember not all Wal-mart stores are the same, they all are differently. "Wal-Mart pays substandard wages" which isn't true now, they are increaseing to have a competive pay against other stores, I got a raise twice within 4 month and ask why, cuz of competive pay... "aggressively opposes union organizing efforts" it's true because Wal-mart oversee each employees as individual's performance, experiences, etc. I do see some positive and negatives about any companies having a union organizing.. any feedback on that one?

Magatsu said:
Wal-Mart likes to show off its smiling employees in advertisements. Meanwhile, it continues creating harsh working environments.
1/2 true, 1/2 false: what kind of harsh working environments? can anyone prove me that? I'd like to see some discussion about that.

Magatsu said:
I personally hate Wal-Mart... Well, not only that reason but Wal-Mart supported the children labor in China. No, I am not kidding. I found out that more and more people start to stop shopping at Walmart and shop at Target and other local stores included family-business stores. That's really good news.
I don't blame people for not wanting to shop at Wal-Mart. I used to have a negatives thoughts about Wal-mart, but after working for Wal-Mart, which I needed a job for a living, I changed my view about Wal-Mart, if you have come into my store where I work, you would like the environment, friendly one. the sources link you gave us to look at, I couldn't open but I can see the link show opinion so it's not based on fact, it's based on opinion, I'd like to see informaiton based on facts.. you mentioned that people stopped shopping at walmart and shop more at Target and other local stores? well not mine... before I worked at Wal-mart, I worked at superTarget, it was very busy working there until I quit for some reasons, then want to go back, they start to cut many employees' hours except my mom cuz she worked very hard there so they rather keep my mom's hours on what she want but not other employees cuz of their performance. Anyway after Target refuse to hire me back cuz of hiring freeze, so I went ahead with Wal-Mart since they're opening new store so it was borned a new store and now SuperTarget blamed Wal-Mart for stealing their customers, well I dont blame customers to shop at our store cuz of lower prices. My mom do found many stuffs and food she wanted and like from Wal-Mart unlike SuperTarget don't have some... I know this may seem like i'm negative on Target but they are excellent store too but it's just a competive store though... if you want to argue with my opinion, feel free to find a cat to catch my tongue... ;)
 
Why need Walmart furniture when you can buy IKEA? Why buy Walmart food when you can get healthier food selections at local farmer's markets? I'm out of time to go on, but you get the idea! ;)
 
Dennis said:
Nothing you can do about it -- except vote with your wallet.
Funny, that's exactly what my mom said to me several years ago. But yeah, you nailed it very good. I surely am not going to support children labor in China by not buying anything at Wal-mart. There are few more reasons why I refused to buy but that's major reason why I refused.
 
nozobo, well why should I support the children labor in China? How does Wal-mart sell these stuffs so cheap? That's how. If not children labor, then they pay incredibly lowest wage (25 - 75 cents per hour) for these overtime workers (12 - 16 hours) in China. That's biggest reason why I stand up and pee upon their stores (literally).

Dennis' comment nailed it perfectly... Wal-Mart is owned or funded by Religious Right (Religious Right and Children Labor & lowest wage.. hmmm) and I don't want to pay anything to support their politicial activities. By vote against them with my wallet. That's two reasons why I refused to buy anything, there is few more but I will not mention anything about these at this moment. However more informations for you to check out about Wal-Mart and their unethics:

http://www.ufcw.org/press_room/fact_sheets_and_backgrounder/walmart/sweat_shops.cfm

In his autobiography, Made in America: My Story founding Wal-Mart President, Sam Walton, proselytized "Buy American." USA Today, August 14, 2001, reported that, "Wal-Mart has more than 1,107 international operations." The newspaper also reports that, "Bangladesh workers earn as little as nine cents an hour making shirts for Wal-Mart.
Nine cents an hour. How ethic is that?

http://www.1worldcommunication.org/Walmart.htm

http://www.flagstaffactivist.org/campaigns/walmyths.html

Myth:
Wal-Mart creates "hundreds" of new jobs for communities.

Fact:
Studies show that for every two jobs created by a Wal-Mart store, the community loses three. Jobs that are retained by a community are merely shifted from local businesses to the giant retailer. In a 1994 report, the Congressional Research Service warned Congress that communities need to evaluate the significance of any job gains at big-box stores against any loss of jobs due to reduced business at competing retailers. The report also pointed out that these so-called new jobs "provide significantly lower wages then jobs in many industries, and are often only part-time positions, seasonal opportunities, or subject to extensive turnover." The Real Story is that when Wal-Mart moves into the neighborhood, it devours local businesses and lowers community living standards. (Magatsu's comment: Thus proved my economy professor's lectures, thank you Dr. Lasscuet)



Myth:
Wal-Mart's presence in a community generates tax revenues.

Fact:
Studies conducted by small towns on the impact of proposed Wal-Mart stores have shown that tax revenue reductions are more likely to occur after a Wal-Mart moves into an area.

A Maryland study showed that in the years following the arrival of Wal-Mart, "town tax receipts from personal property and ordinary business corporation taxes grew but at a declining rate." The study said that "the expected growth in income taxes may have been offset by low-wage jobs offered by the large retailer and by the loss of employment in competing businesses. . . ."


Myth:
Wal-Mart's workers receive good health benefits.

Fact:
Wal-Mart's Health Coverage Leaves Most Workers Uncovered.

Huge employee premium payments and big deductibles keep participation in Wal-Mart's health plan to 38% of employees. That's 6 out of every 10 employees--more than 425,000 Wal-Mart employees, most of them women, who have no company provided health coverage. Nationally, more than 60% of workers are covered by company paid health plans. There's more: Wal-Mart workers pay insurance premiums that cover close to half of Wal-Mart's health plan expenses. The national average shows that employee premiums cover just over 25% of health plan expenses incurred by companies nationwide. The Real Story is that Wal-Mart freely acknowledges shifting its health care costs to taxpayers and responsible employers. A company spokesperson said, "[Wal-Mart employees] who choose not to participate in [Wal-Mart's health plan] usually get their health-care benefits from a spouse or the state or federal government." Wal-Mart is the biggest beneficiary of its health plan because the company shifts $1 billion in health care costs to the government and responsible employers.


Myth:
Wal-Mart has "always low prices, always."

Fact:
The local newspaper in Carroll County, Arkansas conducted a test of Wal-Mart's low price claim. Surveying a list of 19 common household items at six Wal-Mart stores over a one month period, the newspaper staff found that Wal-Mart was cheapest on only two of the items . The lowest register receipt for all 19 items was $12.91. The highest total for all items came from Wal-Mart at $15.86. The Real Story is the high cost of Wal-Mart's prices: lower wages, more imports, lost U.S. jobs, lower community living standards.


Myth:
Wal-Mart "Buys American" and Wal-Mart "Brings it Home to the USA."

Fact:
Two 1998 studies that surveyed clothing on Wal-Mart store racks and shelves found 80% and sometimes more thatn 9o% of the apparel items were produced overseas, many in countries where sweatshops and child labor are prevelant.

"The truth is," says the National Labor Committee, "Wal-Mart has moved far more production offshore than the industry average." There's more: Commenting on Wal-Mart's "Buy Mexican" program, an expert on economic nationalism said Wal-Mart is ". . .shamelessly manipulating nationalist sentiments in both countries. . . . For all its public nationalism, Wal-mart is reinvesting its all-American dollars overseas."

http://www.flagstaffactivist.org/fan/walfacts.phtml

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/walmart/ (Excellent facts and such on Wal-Mart by PBS. Yes, PBS. Both Pro and Con. There is lot to read).

New Report Details Wal-Mart's Labor Abuses and Hidden Costs

Walmart's slave labor force revealed to be made up of illegal immigrants

AFL-CIO Study Documents Wal-Mart's Race to the Bottom on Health Coverage


nozobo, there are many more... I think that's good enough for you.. well, for now. There are two excellent books that cover Wal-Mart and their Malpractices. I cannot remember the titles, I will have to ask few friends of mine to find out.
 
bwinkler said:
I refuse to shop at Wal-mart as well. Wal-mart has a reputation of building big stores in any given area, lowering cost than the local competition. Doing that, most times drives the competition away or out of business. When that does happen, prices in Wal-mart begin to climb back up. I have seen Wal-mart pop up around Charlotte like wild fire. And the stores are getting bigger to the point it will or is a one stop shop. If there is no competition to Wal-mart, they can charge any price they want for products that are not exactly of good quality. I am willing to pay more for the american made product, in support for American jobs. I better stop typing while I can before it becomes a mess.
You made a very good point :thumb:
 
Fly Free said:
their products are not very good IMHO

What products are you referring to?

I meant, Wal-Mart don't make their own products. I'm just curious what products you were referring to.
 
Back
Top