Movie BLINDNESS

i dont know, i know they were boycotting and passing out fliers today.

I thought that may have been the case. As an organization, I don't blame the NFB for taking action. I can still remember the boycotting they did over "Mr. Magoo." Now THAT was an offensive movie.
 
Aleser,

Same here. I'm also a member of the NFB. Do you know if they are taking any legal action against the director of this movie? (I haven't read the "Braille Monitor" lately to know for myself.)

from what I gather, no. I believe it was only a matter of protesting the film (and the re-enforced stereotypes of blindness many people may walk away from it with)
 
thats what we are worried about with this one. like i said, if you watch it, cool. none of my business, but it reinforces the stereotypes.
 
from what I gather, no. I believe it was only a matter of protesting the film (and the re-enforced stereotypes of blindness many people may walk away from it with)

I hope they do take legal action for the very reasons you've mentioned. It's about time Hollywood stop reinforcing negative stereotypes about the blind and the disabled in general.
 
I cannot speak for the film, as I have not seen it (and will not! see it) but, as for the book it's from, let me quote..

"The shouting had died down, now a confusion of sounds was coming from the hallway, these were the blind, driven like sheep, bumping into each other, crammed together in the doorways, some lost their sense of direction and ended up in other wards, but the majority, stumbling along, huddled into groups or dispersed one by one, desperately waving their hands in the air like people drowning, burst into the ward in a whirlwind, as if being pushed from the outside by a bulldozer."

"Then the inexorable rise in the number of cases of blindness led some influential members of the Government, fearful that the official initiative would not suffice for the task in hand, and that it might result in heavy political costs, to defend the idea that it was up to families to keep their blind indoors, never allowing them to go out on the street, so as not to worsen the already difficult traffic situation or to offend the sensibility of persons who still had their eyesight and who, indifferent to more or less reassuring opinions, believed that the white disease was spreading by visual contact, like the evil eye."

"No one's nerves could withstand it. The worst thing is that whole families, especially the smaller ones, rapidly became families of blind people, leaving no one who could guide and look after them, nor protect sighted neighbours from them, and it was clear that these blind people, however caring a father, mother or child they might be, could not take care of each other, otherwise they would meet the same fate as the blind people in the painting, walking together, falling together and dying together."


This is NOT how a civilized society sees blindness. This is not an acceptable portrayal of disability in a civilized world. This takes us three thousand steps back.
 
I cannot speak for the film, as I have not seen it (and will not! see it) but, as for the book it's from, let me quote..

"The shouting had died down, now a confusion of sounds was coming from the hallway, these were the blind, driven like sheep, bumping into each other, crammed together in the doorways, some lost their sense of direction and ended up in other wards, but the majority, stumbling along, huddled into groups or dispersed one by one, desperately waving their hands in the air like people drowning, burst into the ward in a whirlwind, as if being pushed from the outside by a bulldozer."

"Then the inexorable rise in the number of cases of blindness led some influential members of the Government, fearful that the official initiative would not suffice for the task in hand, and that it might result in heavy political costs, to defend the idea that it was up to families to keep their blind indoors, never allowing them to go out on the street, so as not to worsen the already difficult traffic situation or to offend the sensibility of persons who still had their eyesight and who, indifferent to more or less reassuring opinions, believed that the white disease was spreading by visual contact, like the evil eye."

"No one's nerves could withstand it. The worst thing is that whole families, especially the smaller ones, rapidly became families of blind people, leaving no one who could guide and look after them, nor protect sighted neighbours from them, and it was clear that these blind people, however caring a father, mother or child they might be, could not take care of each other, otherwise they would meet the same fate as the blind people in the painting, walking together, falling together and dying together."


This is NOT how a civilized society sees blindness. This is not an acceptable portrayal of disability in a civilized world. This takes us three thousand steps back.

I must say I *am* greatly offended by the citation above. And you're right Aleser -- this makes all of the equality we've fought for so much more difficult to maintain. One thing is for sure...I won't be reading the book anytime soon -- and if the book is indicative of the movie, I won't be seeing that either.
 
This is NOT how a civilized society sees blindness. This is not an acceptable portrayal of disability in a civilized world. This takes us three thousand steps back.

Civilization works when everything is in order. However, when a disaster unravels... it's a different story. The aftermath of Hurricane Katrina is a good example. Anyway, civilized societies have been wrong many, many times in the past. Salem Witch Hunt, Holocaust, Slavery, Female Voters and more.

By nature, mankind is certainly barbaric.

Now, what would make an interesting debate is to see what people think will happen if the entire population of New York City suddenly went blind?
 
thank you. it is.

I was thinking about purchasing this movie on DVD when it came out, but not anymore. Someone (newly blind or congenitally blind) not being able to find the bathroom? C'mon. Talk about ridiculous. Speaking of which, I've had sighted people ask me if my guide dog helps (i.e. guides) me in my own apartment. Again, ridiculous.
 
exactly. when i have to go somewhere i dont say "mom, i need to go..." i get up and go my own darn self. blind people are independent individuals.
 
Are you a part of the blind community? No? Then you cannot say we are not offended.

Put it in a dress and call it a metaphor all you want, prance around it and throw pink paint on it if you will, but using blindness to express the negative is outright wrong.

If it was deafness dramatized and plastered over the screen, how would you feel? If it was a movie showing portrayed-as-pathetic newly deaf people unable to communicate and suddenly developing extreme 'deaf' accents, how would you feel?

If it was race used, if it was any other disability, that group (and any decent society-at-large) would be jumping down that movie's throat. But people don't think it's a mis-representation- they DO think blindness is an expression of horrible things. They DO think blind people are pathetic.

So, do not speak for 'the community' - speak for yourself, as an outsider attempting to speak FOR ME. I speak for myself.

Read my post again. I said it has nothing to do with blind people. It has to do with the virus...you just bought your dress congrats. :roll:
 
Protesting against this movie will only attract more people to see it.
 
I saw and I like it. :D

Well, I would be panick and if everybody are suddenly blind, we would act like retard and don't know what to do. It's old concept when there is one single person become blind, he or she being freak out and don't know what to do however, had an ASSIST. If whole people become blind, we have nobody to help us. Think about it.

However, the ending is just a disappointment that led me to wonder what or how it happen, I yelled. haha
 
This movie is "fiction" right?...

I don't believe this movie is gonna win an "academy award"!....

There will always be people who are/think "backwards"...who "assume" things about people with disabilities....until they meet someone who is blind or deaf, and see their accomplishments, then it would change their perspective.

I've been profound deaf since age 14...and during my young years, it was a "battle".....Now, it's just a "of course, I can"!....and "Why not"?

I don't dwell on "small-minded" people or what they think or assume!...I've out-grown that!
 
Actually, hearing impaired is quite an inaccurate term to use because it doesn't tell anyone how severe your hearing loss is. Just like visual-impaired is inaccurate because it doesn't tell me how blind a person is.

Mild, Moderate, Severe and Profound. That's the four main terms we use to refer to our types of hearing loss.

Thank You for that interest information, Banjo
Severe is one of the deafness not I am not even aware of

Talking about Movie Blindness, Well I would go to see it myself
I remember another movie or was it the book about Blindness
Er Sci fi one, I can’t spell it name but in that one
Huge Alien Plants Blinded everyone with their Seed and this guy was in hospital with both eyes cover up, he could still see while the rest couldn’t

That was not all bad, one of them was blind all her life and she could help the others who was not use to it
This was made in the 70s so this is nothing new

And before anyone start getting at me, I got Usher Syndrome, Night blindness and tunnel vision (RP) and a hearing loss
I still got some eyesight but I could lose it anytime and I am not a BSL signer, I talk

Oh, boy, this will be under Sci Fi Films and I am going to watch it myself when it ever come out
Not enough Sci Fi Films, more Action film (Not bad most of them)
Or people falling in love and lived happily ever (please, not for me, give me comedy or comedy horror movie anytime)

Scifibabe
 
Back
Top