How can teacher call my son a FUTURE KILLER?

Miss-Delectable

New Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2004
Messages
17,160
Reaction score
7
The Electric New Paper, Singapore - The Electric New Paper News

FIRST, he was shocked when his 12-year-old hearing-impaired son came home with a swollen cheek.

Next, he was aghast when the boy told him about the slapping punishment that his teacher at the Singapore School for the Deaf (SSD) meted out to him and nine other boys.

Then, Mr Buang Kalil, 57, was outraged when the same teacher sent him a letter to explain why his son, Maswan, was punished.

The letter, he felt, insulted his son further by saying the boy was 'capable of unimaginable deviant behaviour', and has 'a strong potential for killing or being killed'.

Mr Buang, a security guard, has since gone to the National Council of Social Service (NCSS), the Singapore Association for the Deaf (SADeaf), his Member of Parliament and the police over his son's slapping.

As a result, all three staff members have left the school.

He said he was 'provoked' by the letter from teacher Ranjani Fernando, which accused Maswan of being a troublemaker since age 9.

Maswan is the second of three children. His older brother and younger sister are both normal.

A second parent, whose 15-year-old son was slapped, said he did not notice any marks on his son's face or even know about the slapping incident until he was told by another parent more than two weeks later.

But Mr Buang's wife, Madam Nursyuhadah Teresita Abdullah, 42, a housewife, said she saw her son's red and swollen left cheek when he came home at 6pm on the last day of camp.

The next morning, he told his parents everything after they continued to question him. She used her handphone camera to take a photo of her son's face.

Over the next two days, the couple sent an MMS to the boy's form teacher, called NCSS to lodge a complaint, and went to see his MP together with his son.

Mr Buang said: 'We just wanted an answer and something to be done. Because the social worker didn't call us, the teacher didn't call, the principal was on a course and didn't know what was happening.'

A week later, the couple received the letter from Ms Fernando.

That same day, Maswan showed his mum a sex education book which was given at the camp. In the jotter book were colour photocopies of graphic illustrations on sex education, including a cartoon of a naked man and woman having sex which showed part of the man's genitals.

She said: 'I was so angry, my hand started shaking. The pictures are so gross, so inappropriate.

'He's too young, it's not the right time for him to learn all these. If I had known they'll teach him this in the camp, I would never have let him go.'

TRAUMATISED

Social worker Jessica Cheah confirmed that the book was given to all 27 boys and girls who went to the camp, all of whom were age 12 and above.

But she and Ms Fernando defended the book's contents.

Since the incident, Mr Buang has decided not to let his son go to school for the past two weeks. Also, they said their son was traumatised and has been undergoing counselling once a week.

Said Mr Buang: 'We are doing this as a lesson to other parents. They shouldn't be afraid to report such things. We don't want other children to go through such incidents.'

'I wasn;t allowed to say goodbye to kids'

SOCIAL worker Jessica Cheah said her dismissal was a shock.

Ms Cheah, 28, was in charge of the school camp, where the slapping took place.

School principal Hanisnah Kasmuri, who was not at the camp as she was away on a course, was also asked to leave.

Ms Cheah said the Singapore Association for the Deaf told her last Tuesday to resign by the next day or be terminated.

'I was shocked. They told me I didn't carry out my professional duties and they have to terminate me with immediate effect.

'I was not allowed to say goodbye to the kids.'

She resigned the next day.

Ms Cheah said she found out that others had been fired only when Ms Fernando came to say goodbye.

An acting principal has been put in place at the school.

But some 40 signatures have been gathered in a petition to reinstate Madam Hanisnah, who has been with the school for 21 years, as principal.

Mr Buang, who signed it, said: 'The principal was away and didn't know anything about what happened at the camp.


'I support the principal because she made many improvements.'

There was also concern that the PSLE is just two weeks away.
 
This is not good.. i am glad to hear 2 are fired for that.. but principal.. why they let go of the principal when she didnt know what happeened? i dont think its her fault?? sigh..
 
I Asked Boys To Slap Harder

The Electric New Paper, Singapore - The Electric New Paper News

SHE is the teacher at the centre of the controversy.
The one who ordered 10 hearing-impaired boys to slap one another as punishment during a school camp, which led to a police report, an investigation and subsequently several sackings, including her own.

But Ms Ranjani Fernando, 55, maintained she did not think the punishment was a big deal, and remains puzzled that the matter got blown up.

'I think it's a misunderstanding. I don't know how it became so big. I'm absolutely puzzled,' said Ms Fernando, who was the English coordinator and discipline mistress at the Singapore School for the Deaf (SSD).

Ms Fernando, who declined to be photographed, said she was not sorry for handing out this punishment because the boys committed what she felt was a very serious offence. The boys had left the school without permission and refused to obey a teacher when he told them to come back.

The only thing she regrets: Asking them to slap faces. She feels she should have asked the boys to hit each other on the buttocks instead.

Each boy received at least nine slaps - one from each of his peers.


She said that when some of the boys slapped each other too lightly, she told them: 'Hey, slap harder than that.'

But Ms Fernando said she repeatedly told the boys to avoid the jawline and the ear to prevent serious injuries.

It happened on 2 Sep, after a group of boys ate a tin of biscuits without permission on the last day of the three-day school camp.

Two of the boys were told to buy a replacement during lunch-time. But eight other boys chose to tag along without telling the teachers.

A male teacher had to run after them, but the boys wouldn't return at once.

Ms Fernando claimed they also littered on the public road.

That's why they were punished.

She claimed that this was a 'hardcore group' of boys who have discipline problems. And that after the punishment, the boys were better behaved.

She added that she checked on all the boys before they left at 4pm, and only one, Maswan Buang, 12, had slight red marks on his cheek.

She said: 'My thought was, good, his parents will notice and he will have to explain why he was punished.'

She insisted there were no bruises or finger marks at the time.

That's why she was shocked when she received a call from her principal after the camp to say that Maswan's parents had lodged complaints with several authorities. (See report on page 6.)

When school reopened after the holidays on 11 Sep, she said there were no marks on his face.

She said she got a second shock when she saw the boy's picture in Berita Harian last week.

She sent a letter to his parents to explain what had happened - but his parents took offence to what she wrote.

She had expressed concern about the boy's injuries and apologised if he had suffered 'permanent physical hurt'.

She added she regretted asking the boys to hit each other in the face, instead of the buttocks.

But she also wrote that Maswan was 'capable of unimaginable deviant behaviour', and has 'a strong potential for killing or being killed'.

She claimed the boy had committed other offences since he was 9 years old. She wrote: 'Please believe that it is my sincere wish to help your child avoid a life damaging to himself and others.'

Ms Fernando declined to say why she made the accusations and the 'kill or be killed' comment, except that they were based on the boy's case history.

She said that while she understands why the school decided to sack her, she wondered how the boy's injuries became worse after she saw it.

NOT THAT SERIOUS THEN


She said: 'Based on the evidence presented to (the school), probably they were right (to sack me).'

But she insisted the boy's injury did not look serious that day.

'If he had looked like that when he left us, we would have gone home with him to explain what happened and what he did, but there was nothing,' she said.

SSD's parent organisation, the Singapore Association for the Deaf, said the matter has been 'thoroughly investigated' and 'the findings made known to the relevant parties.'

'We wish to put this incident behind us,' it said.
 
Sometimes we cannot interfere with another countries business on how they punish their children. Sometimes they view that punishing their kids is a right way to do it.
 
oh man it remind me!!!! my old teacher did use the thick of math book and hitted my left arm and got scared me.. so is aw the bad bruised on left arm while i was on the bus way home, my mom say hi to me but i walked hurry up to my room, she puzzled.. so i look at my arm again and my mom came in and busted.. she gasp and say who did this????? i got scared and wont tell her for while but finally told her who did.. she blew up big time!!!!! gee.. so she called school tmw morning and i dont go school, she talked to princpal (sp) so we went there and showed him my left arm so my old teacher say didnt do that.. got me upset.. so my friends saw it and told princpal too.. but the princpal dont believe so didnt fire teacher... my mom got upset and pissed off... after that i joined alabama school for the deaf that how...
 
See! You were talking during the class which is a big no no. You went ahead against your teacher request. You got caught and then punished. Cant deny that.
 
See! You were talking during the class which is a big no no. You went ahead against your teacher request. You got caught and then punished. Cant deny that.

no, we havent start class but we talked in classroom n we waited on teacher start it.. hello!
 
tweetybird that teacher is bad believe me
my old teacher put soap on my tongue and it burn my tongue and i wouldn't feel my tongue for few days GRR
 
Epp this reminds me of my 6th grade teacher! Most of my teachers were pretty cool expect for a couple of teachers.
 
are u talk to me??? i was not bad kid... i was very good kid.. i was talked to my friend while in class and got teacher mad... that simple???

I'm hearing and had the same thing happen to me when I was in 7th grade. I laughed at another student in class, and the teacher hit me in the back of the head with her book. It was wrong then, and it's wrong now. My opinion: teachers in the article should not only be fired, they should do jail time for assault!!! If that had been my deaf son, I would be in jail for beating the crap out of the teacher.
 
Maybe you were really bad. What did you do?

Doesn't matter if a child was bad or not, no teacher should hit a child period! If someone laid a hand on my child, that teacher will answer to me.
 
My personal opinion towards incident

Whoa... Ms Delectable, you are real well-informed about my country deaf community. How did you first know about this article? Unless you are Singaporean..lol :whip:

Ok, I am on negative side but would like to conclude in my personal opinion that Ms Ranjani Fernando should not take this kind of punishment to mislead this student's hearing parents. Deaf awareness in Singapore is laggy because of Asian culture and its thinking ways. I am not fully involved in SAD activities but only onlooker..:giggle:

Anything you wish to drop your comment on my post reply, you are most welcome. :fingersx:
 
Sometimes we cannot interfere with another countries business on how they punish their children. Sometimes they view that punishing their kids is a right way to do it.

I agree that we cannot impose our own cultural beliefs on others, especially not so from an ethnocentric perspective. But abuse of children is abouse of children, and when it occurs to the most vunerable simply because they present an easy target, one must speak out against it.
 
See! You were talking during the class which is a big no no. You went ahead against your teacher request. You got caught and then punished. Cant deny that.

The punishment was much harsher than the crime. That would be akin to sentencing someone to death for stealing a gallon of milk!
 
Ahh you didn't mentioned that.

Still and all, don't you realize the "punishment" didn't come close to fitting the "crime"? And by a school staffer in whom care of the child (in this case TweetyBird) was entrusted.

By the way, what country are you from?
 
oh man it remind me!!!! my old teacher did use the thick of math book and hitted my left arm and got scared me.. so is aw the bad bruised on left arm while i was on the bus way home, my mom say hi to me but i walked hurry up to my room, she puzzled.. so i look at my arm again and my mom came in and busted.. she gasp and say who did this????? i got scared and wont tell her for while but finally told her who did.. she blew up big time!!!!! gee.. so she called school tmw morning and i dont go school, she talked to princpal (sp) so we went there and showed him my left arm so my old teacher say didnt do that.. got me upset.. so my friends saw it and told princpal too.. but the princpal dont believe so didnt fire teacher... my mom got upset and pissed off... after that i joined alabama school for the deaf that how...

that not good but you must tell the truth who did hit you need know
 
Back
Top