They Really Are Watching You

Vance

New Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2004
Messages
4,265
Reaction score
1
They Really Are Watching You
Ready for your own all-new, sinister ID card, courtesy of Homeland Security? Shudder



Well, now we've done it.

Congress just passed it and Dubya has promised to sign it and the Homeland Security Department is giddier than Mel Gibson in a nail factory over it and marketers nationwide are salivating at the groin at the prospect of it, and the next big step toward America becoming an even more delightfully paranoid and draconian Big Brother wonderland has now officially been taken.

It's called Real ID. It is, in short, a new and genetically mutated type of driver's license for all Americans, replacing your current license and replacing your Social Security card and replacing your sense of well being and privacy and humanity and part of a new, uniform, deeply sinister, national uniform card system whereby every person living and breathing in these paranoid and tense times shall henceforth be much more traceable and watchable given how we will all soon be required by law to carry this super-deluxe computerized ID card with us at all times, packed as it will be with more personal, digitized info about you than even your mother knows.

Real ID is coming very soon. The legislation was passed with little outcry and zero debate by both House and Senate just last week because lawmakers snuck it into a massive $82 billion military spending bill, and therefore no one was really paying much attention and this is the way you get thorny disturbing culturally demeaning bills to pass without resistance from smart people who should know better.

The new law will, according to the Wired News story linked above, require everyone to hand over not one, not two, but fully four types of documentation to renew their driver's license, such as a photo ID, a birth certificate, proof that their Social Security number is legit and something that validates their home address, like a phone bill. DMV employees will then have to verify the documents against giant teeming federal databases and store the documents and a digital photo of you in a database. Isn't that fun? Doesn't that sound gratifying?

What's more, the card's design plan includes multiple openings for the Homeland Security Department to add on whatever features they deem necessary, with or without your knowledge, consent or who the hell cares what you think because we do what we want now please shut the hell up and quit asking questions.

Computer (RFID) microchip? Likely. Digital fingerprint? Sure. Political affiliation? You bet. Web-site-visit log and religious affiliation and recent sperm count and arrest record and drug addictions and medical history and blood type and gender orientation and parent's/children's home address and number of personal blog posts calling Dr. Phil a "slug-licking ego-bitch charlatan" and your recent purchase history on shotathome.com? One guess.

Make no mistake: Real ID, in short, takes us one happy step closer to a total surveillance state, where everyone is stamped and everyone is watchable and everyone is traceable and unless you live way, way off the grid out in the increasingly nonexistent hinterlands, you cannot escape the spazzy and twitchy and paranoid eye of Homeland Security.

Remember the scenes in that surprisingly not-awful Tom Cruise flick "Minority Report" with the ubiquitous eye scanners, installed all over the near-future city? And as poor Tommy ran around like a maniac, little scanner machines installed by the gummint would read the eye pattern of every citizen as they walked around and the system could track anyone at any time no matter where they might wander and all the info was dumped into a huge database that was studied and cross-checked and manipulated by the CIA and FBI and Banana Republic?

Real ID feels much like that, only not nearly as cool.

Real ID is, as you might expect, giving civil liberties groups and immigrant-support groups the hives. State governors across the nation are none too happy, either, as implementation of the new law will cost each state hundreds of millions of dollars, but, of course, the bill provides zero federal funds to help. Such is the BushCo way.

This is the funny thing. This is the sad thing. This is the terrifying thing. We have suffered one major debilitating act of terrorism in this nation and we have recoiled so violently, so rabidly, so desperately that we are still more than willing to give up whatever freedoms necessary in a vain and silly attempt to control chaos and plug every hole, when of course the nation is basically one giant hole to begin with.

Of course, any good conspiracy theorist worth his secret underground bootleg Area 51 videos will tell you this sort of citizen-surveillance thing has been going on for years, decades, from spy satellites to GPS to all manner of phone tracking and e-mail snooping and behavior watching and this Real ID thing only takes it a little more public, national, makes it part of the cultural lexicon because we have finally weakened so much we just don't seem to give a damn what they do to us anymore.

Don't think it's all that bad? Think BushCo's flying monkeys in the CIA and FBI and Homeland Security really have your best interests at heart and are genuinely trying to protect you from scary swarthy furriners who want to sneak into our country and poison our Cheerios and paint our flag orange and cover our wimmin in burlap? Have at it. The GOP would love to have you. Oh, and while you're at it, enjoy that tiny grain-of-rice-size bar-coded implant RFID microchip the FDA just approved, which they can permanently slip under your skin in under 20 minutes, with nary a peep.

This is what's happening now. With Real ID (and who knows what else), the government is cracking down and creating a new and improved and far more devious and exploitable system to monitor its citizens because, well, because we let them. Because millions of us have been pummeled so successfully by the fear-mongering Right. Because we have never been so lax, so blinded by warmongering and dread, so numbed to what might become of us.

Ah, but maybe I'm wrong. Maybe this is just rampant paranoia talking and it's just a silly piece of harmless legislation and Real ID is overall a genuinely good and useful idea that will ultimately make us safer and more secure. You think?

Because hasn't BushCo proven to be reliable and honest and just reeking with integrity about privacy and security issues so far? Hasn't the USA Patriot Act been just a wondrous boon to police and CIA and our sense that we are trusted and cared for by our government? Aren't we all feeling just so much safer with this most secretive, least accountable administration at the helm?

After all, why not trust the government on this? Why not put our faith in the goodly Homeland Security Department? Maybe Real ID really is patriotic and constructive and it will be a smooth and secure and completely inviolable system, one that protects citizens while giving them a new sense of freedom to move about the country with carefree flag-waving ease, safe in the knowledge that their big, snarling gummint is watching over them like a protective mother bear -- as opposed to, say, a female praying mantis, who greedily screws her lover, and then, of course, eats him alive.

Source: http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/gate/archive/2005/05/18/notes051805.DTL&nl=fix


Era of George Orwell's 1984.
 
Wow, Real ID is worse than I thought. Thank to this blog. Here it is:


Meet new Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security, Michael Chertoff. He may be a competent and very nice fellow, I don't know much about him. But if the Real ID Act passes in the Senate as it did in the House last week, he could literally get away with murder.

First, what the Real ID Act isn't: it is not a law requiring all Americans to get a "national ID card".

What it is: a law requiring state IDs to conform to national standards so they can be used with all interactions with the federal government. I say sure, great idea - not that it will, but this has the potential to make government more efficient. On a personal level, I'd rather keep track of just my driver's license than a driver's license and Social Security card. If you don't want one, get rid of your driver's license. Problem solved.

But here's what else it is: a get out of jail free card for the Secretary of DHS.

SEC. 102. WAIVER OF LAWS NECESSARY FOR
IMPROVEMENT OF BARRIERS AT BORDERS.
Section 102(c) of the Illegal Immigration Reform and
Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 (8 U.S.C. 1103
note) is amended to read as follows:
'(c) Waiver-
'(1) IN GENERAL- Notwithstanding any other provision
of law, the Secretary of Homeland Security shall have the
authority to waive, and shall waive, all laws such Secretary,
in such Secretary's sole discretion, determines necessary to
ensure expeditious construction of the barriers and roads
under this section.
'(2) NO JUDICIAL REVIEW- Notwithstanding any other
provision of law (statutory or nonstatutory), no court shall
have jurisdiction--
'(A) to hear any cause or claim arising from any action
undertaken, or any decision made, by the Secretary of
Homeland Security pursuant to paragraph (1); or
' (B) to order compensatory, declaratory, injunctive,
equitable, or any other relief for damage alleged to arise
from any such action or decision.'.


Breaking the legalese down,
The Secretary of Homeland Security shall ignore all laws which, in his sole judgment may slow up the construction of barriers and roads at the border. No one can challenge his judgments in court in any way whatsoever. He can do anything he wants to get those barriers and roads up and you have no rights. He is completely and legally above the law.

Said Rep. Earl Blumenauer (D-OR) in the floor debate over the bill,
"If this provision, the waiver of all laws necessary for quote improvements of barriers at the border was to become law, the Secretary of Homeland Security could give a contract to his political cronies that had no safety standards, using 12-year-old illegal immigrants to do the labor, run it through the site of a Native American burial ground, kill bald eagles in the process, and pollute the drinking water of neighboring communities. And under the provisions of this act, no member of Congress, no citizen could do anything about it because you waive all judicial review."
 
Mags, Thanks for the posting....I have mixed reviews of the Real ID and hopefully any debate will remain constructive.

A few years ago, Maryland developed a new Drivers License that was meeting some standards of other states. A lot of the 'Real ID' is just glorified drivers license that makes states fit to one standard.

For example, in Maryland, I need 'x' number documents to get a drivers license..while in Virginia, I needed less...and Virginia is a much stricter states in most cases. I hate to use this as an example, but think of the 9/11 hijackers who were able to get drivers licenses in Virginia and they weren't even legal aliens anymore.

If you recall, some states have debated (and continue to debate) allowing illegal immigrants to obtain legal drivers licenses....
So, if your an illegal immigrant (no matter the country of origin), if Maryland doesn't grant you a license and Florida doesn't..then go to a state that will grant you one. You are now an illegal alien who has just become legal.

The Real ID creates a standard for all states to follow. Also, if you weren't already aware, there are already national databases that have your information in them...Its called NCIC. This system tracks stolen items...from cars to chainsaws to guns. It also has a collection of your criminal history.
If I'm doing an investigation on John Doe for suspected child pornography, I can look at his history and see that he has a conviction in Florida as well as California. It would also allow me to look and see if your California Drivers License is valid should I pull you over in Maryland.

The Real ID is nothing more than the standardization of all states and an ID system. Your state already has the ability (and to some extent already does) with your current drivers license. Where is the outcry about that?

In your post, I'd like to see factual information that the Real ID will:
Computer (RFID) microchip? Likely. Digital fingerprint? Sure. Political affiliation? You bet. Web-site-visit log and religious affiliation and recent sperm count and arrest record and drug addictions and medical history and blood type and gender orientation and parent's/children's home address and number of personal blog posts calling Dr. Phil a "slug-licking ego-bitch charlatan" and your recent purchase history on shotathome.com? One guess.

and the real ID (again, just a standardized form of ID) to:

Don't think it's all that bad? Think BushCo's flying monkeys in the CIA and FBI and Homeland Security really have your best interests at heart and are genuinely trying to protect you from scary swarthy furriners who want to sneak into our country and poison our Cheerios and paint our flag orange and cover our wimmin in burlap? Have at it. The GOP would love to have you. Oh, and while you're at it, enjoy that tiny grain-of-rice-size bar-coded implant RFID microchip the FDA just approved, which they can permanently slip under your skin in under 20 minutes, with nary a peep.

I'm just curious as to how you reach those conclusions without reaching the same conclusion with your current drivers license.

From a 'police' standpoint, a lot of it makes sense. I deal with people all the time that are difficult to ID after they have committed a crime. I stress committed a crime because I DO NOT believe in stopping people for no reason and asking for ID...in fact, as an officer I am not allowed to do this and I'm fine with that.

We arrest a guy for carjacking, and he claims (and his Mexican drivers license backs him up) his name is Jose Mendoza Pena-Hernandez. His fingerprints, however, show him as and illegal alien named Carlos Pena and he is wanted in 3 states for anything from fraud to armed robbery. He was a bad guy that was 1 inch from being cut loose because of his 'official' Mexican drivers license.

While I work for the police, I DO NOT want to live in (are participate in) anything that would lead to a police state.

My belief in the whole 'Real ID' is that it is a total waste of taxpayers money. Come up with a standardized state ID that would require states to follow a certain minimum (name, address, and Date of Birth). Don't force a 'National ID' on the states as I believe the state and its citizens should be master of their domain and not the national goverment. IMO, while the 'Real ID' is good in theory, it will be flushing a lot of money down the toilet.
 
Back
Top