Minn. Judge Rules Teen Must See Cancer Doctor

chemotherapy is not the only option there. there are several other ways to do it - Asian medicine, for example. If I want to go Korea for alternative medicine to treat this cancer for my child, should the authority and doctor charge me with child neglect and medical neglect?

No, it´s not neglect if you decide for want your child to have treatment in Korea, not America but what mother did is not same.

She search the herbal via internet herself without medicial helps which is irresponsible of her.
 
Update

Here is the latest, copied from KSTP-TV website:

KSTP.com - 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS
Updated: 05/25/2009 5:14 PM KSTP.com
By: Nicole Muehlhausen, Web Producer

Daniel Hauser being evaluated at Twin Cities hospital


NEW ULM, Minn. (AP) - A woman and her 13-year-old son who were on the run from court-ordered cancer treatment for the boy are back in Minnesota, the Brown County Sheriff's Office said Monday.

"Daniel Hauser and his mother have been returned to Minnesota," according to a news release. It did not reveal any additional details, but said there would be a news conference Monday evening. Authorities were not taking phone calls before the scheduled news conference.

Daniel Hauser was having his Hodgkin's lymphoma evaluated by a doctor at a hospital in the Twin Cities on Monday, according to Tom Hagen, an attorney at the law office representing Daniel's parents, Colleen and Anthony Hauser.

Hagen also said Colleen Hauser was not in police custody.

Hagen said Calvin Johnson, his associate who is representing the parents, is out of town and unavailable for comment, but Johnson authorized Hagen to release those details. Hagen said he couldn't share any additional information.

A message left for Daniel's court-appointed attorney was not immediately returned.

Daniel has Hodgkin's lymphoma, a disease which doctor's say has a 90 percent chance of being cured in children if treated with chemotherapy and radiation. Without those treatments, he has a 5 percent chance of survival.

Daniel underwent one round of chemotherapy in February, but stopped after that single treatment, citing religious beliefs. The family opted instead for natural healing practices inspired by American Indians.

A judge ruled that the parents medically neglected Daniel and ordered them to get him an updated chest X-ray as well as select an oncologist for a re-evaluation. After the X-ray showed a tumor in Daniel's chest has grown, the mother and son left town.

The FBI said the pair flew from Minnesota to Los Angeles last Tuesday on Sun Country Airlines. Authorities said they were focusing their search in southern California and northern Mexico, after the pair was spotted in southern California on Tuesday. Investigators suspected they might have been heading to one of a number of alternative cancer clinics in northern Mexico.

The American Cancer Society estimates there are 35 to 50 clinics in Mexican border towns that attract cancer patients looking for alternatives to traditional U.S. treatment methods. Many of these clinics have offices in the San Diego area that serve as contact points for U.S. patients, who are then referred to clinics in Mexico.

Dr. Bruce Bostrom, the pediatric oncologist at Children's Hospitals and Clinics of Minnesota who diagnosed Daniel's cancer in January, said he was happy to hear of the boy's return.

"I'm delighted," Bostrom said. "I've been so worried that he was going to die in Mexico. I've been praying for his safe return, so I think my prayers will be answered."

Bostrom was not working Monday and didn't know if Daniel had gone to Children's Hospitals to be examined.

On Thursday, Anthony Hauser appeared before reporters asking his wife to call him and to come home. "If you're out there, please bring Danny home so we can decide as a family what Danny's treatment should be," he said.

The FBI's affidavit in support of an arrest warrant for Colleen alleges she fled the state to avoid being prosecuted on two state counts of depriving another of custodial or parental rights in Brown County. The "parental rights" refer to those of Brown County family services, which was granted custody of Daniel to get him to a pediatric oncologist.

At a news conference Thursday, Brown County Sheriff Rich Hoffmann vowed to arrange a safe return for Colleen Hauser without an enforcement action if she shows "a good faith effort to come back."


(Copyright 2009 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)
 
Thanks for the update, kid. I'll be anxious to hear the outcomes of the exam, etc.
 
Hmmm...that's good that they were returned back to the US and that he is in the hospital now.

The mother need to wake up and get what his son REALLY needs.
 
:hug: I'm sorry for your losses deafskeptic, but am glad your mother is continuing to do well. I hope that remains the case for a long time to come.

I felt the same way after my mother was diagnosed. I was in denial for awhile and kept telling her to attend a support group for cancer survivors. Her response was "I have a terminal illness and am dying! Don't you understand that?!" I gave her a hug and apologized for what I said. It was then that the reality of her diagnosis really sunk in. I continued praying every day and if truth be told, my prayers were answered in two ways: 1. My mother survived 5 months which is the longest period of time someone with pancreatic cancer can survive following diagnosis and 2. My mother passed away in her sleep which is how she always wanted to leave this world. She also passed away exactly 7 days after she told me "Lord, I can't do this anymore. I want to go Home."

My mother died a week before Christmas in 2004 and I still miss her terribly to this day. I'll never forget how she told me that all she wanted was to live long enough to see one more Christmas which was her favorite holiday.

May my dear mother rest in peace.

I'm sorry about your mom. :hug: I'm sorry she didn't live to see Christmas.

I never knew my grandmother Price as she died 7 years before I was born but I would imagine it was an enormous loss for my mother as she was 25 years old when my grandmother died. Her dad died when she was six. Granddaddy Price wasn't my mother's father - he was her stepfather.

I remember when my great aunt died, it came as a relief for everyone as she had suffered from the breast cancer and she wasn't in pain anymore now that she was dead.
 
I'm sorry about your mom. :hug: I'm sorry she didn't live to see Christmas.

I never knew my grandmother Price as she died 7 years before I was born but I would imagine it was an enormous loss for my mother as she was 25 years old when my grandmother died. Her dad died when she was six. Granddaddy Price wasn't my mother's father - he was her stepfather.

I remember when my great aunt died, it came as a relief for everyone as she had suffered from the breast cancer and she wasn't in pain anymore now that she was dead.

I was 28 when I lost my father, 30 when I lost one of my sisters and 34 when I lost my mother. I consider myself fortunate (if you could say that) because I wasn't a child, a teenager or in my early 20s.

As for my father, I could care less about the fact that he died given the several different ways he abused me. When he passed away, I felt absolutely no grief and do not feel any sadness to this day. If truth be told, I'm glad he's gone and out of my life so he can never hurt me again.

When it comes to my sister and mother, I cry for them often and miss them a great deal. My sister and I didn't always get along, but I still loved her more than ever and when she passed away at a young age due to a heart attack, I was devastated.

That does not compare though to the loss of my dear mother. I saw her suffer from stage 4 pancreatic cancer for 5 months and it was not a pretty sight to see. I am thankful for the fact that she was able to enjoy 24 hours being free of pain due to the extremely high doses of Morphine she was given. She passed away exactly an hour after I saw her at the hospital and from what my mother told me (according to her doctors), if I had not called 911 the evening she was vomiting blood, she would have died later that night. Just thinking about that makes me think of the emotional pain I could have experienced. If I would have found my mother the next day in her apartment (she lived in my apartment complex at the time), I would have had a nervous breakdown. Having said that, I will never forget the conversation we had on the phone via relay before she died. Her exact words were "My doctors told me that you saved my life. If you had not called 911, I wouldn't have survived. I want you to know how much I love you. I never told you that when you were growing up, but I do."

One thing I am so thankful for is the fact that my mother died knowing that I would be able to hear again. Despite the great deal of pain she was in, she always asked me how my cochlear implant evaluation was going. She also told me it was her dream for me to be able to hear again and to enjoy one of the things I loved most -- music. Thanks to her, I kept my large music collection. After I lost my hearing, I planned to sell everything because all it did was remind me of what I I no longer had. She always said that there would come a day when medical technology would restore my hearing. She was right. Now that I have CIs, I'm able to enjoy the music collection I've had since I was 5 years old.

Oops. I didn't mean to write a dissertation. Sorry about that. :giggle:
 
Lawyer: Mom prepared to allow son to undergo chemotherapy
Mother will accept whatever treatment court orders, lawyer says

Boy in legal custody of court, but will remain with mom if she cooperates

13-year-old needs chemotherapy, doctors and court say

Treatment's side effects concerned the boy's parents


NEW ULM, Minnesota (CNN) -- A 13-year-old cancer patient and his mother who last week fled their rural home in Sleepy Eye, Minnesota, rather than undergo chemotherapy returned voluntarily Monday and will accept whatever course of treatment a court may order, their lawyer said.

Lawyer: Mom prepared to allow son to undergo chemotherapy - CNN.com
Doctors say Daniel Hauser's lymphoma responded well to a first round of chemotherapy in February.

1 of 2 Colleen Hauser is prepared to allow her son Daniel to undergo chemotherapy, defense lawyer Jennifer Keller said.

"My understanding is that Colleen intends to abide by whatever orders the court makes and that she wants to put her best case forward for her son to have a chance at alternative treatment," Keller told CNN. "But if the court overrules that, she will abide by the orders of the court. We were very clear on that. That certainly is my advice."

The case raises questions about individuals' rights in deciding medical care for their children when their decisions go against the advice of medical professionals.

Monday's homecoming came a day after Keller, an Orange County, California, attorney representing the pair, called the Brown County Sheriff's Office and told authorities that Colleen Hauser wanted to bring her son home. Watch spokesman describe family's emotions »

"I think they wanted to come back home. They wanted to get together with their family and they were ready to be home," Brown County Sheriff Rich Hoffmann told reporters. "It all turned out for the good."

Keller said she met Sunday with Hauser and her son in her office in Irvine after talking with them a couple of days earlier by telephone.

"He did not appear in pain. He was tired and anxious to get home," Keller said. "He didn't appear to be in any acute distress. He misses his home, he misses his family and he wanted to see his dad."

Don't Miss
Dad appeals for wife, son's return
Mother, son missing in forced chemotherapy case
Late last week, authorities said they thought the mother and son were near Los Angeles, California, and may have been planning to travel to Mexico for a holistic treatment.

Daniel and Colleen Hauser had last been reported seen in Minnesota on May 18, a day after a doctor said the boy's Hodgkin's lymphoma was worsening. The family rejected standard treatment, opting instead for a holistic medical treatment based on Native American healing practices called Nemenhah.

Asked where the boy and his mother had been during their week on the run, the lawyer said, "I didn't ask. My only goal was to help her get Danny back to Minnesota."

Keller said it is her understanding that legal custody has been taken by the court, but that there were no plans to remove Daniel from his mother's care "as long as she was cooperative with the court."

Colleen Hauser and her son arrived in Minnesota at 3 a.m. on a chartered flight paid for by Asgaard Media of Corona, California, Hoffmann said. The company describes itself on its Web site as "founded and advised by a group of forward-thinking, positive-minded individuals wanting to make a difference not only in their environment but in both the world of entertainment and the world around them."

No one from the company responded immediately to an e-mail seeking comment, and the company's telephone answering machine was full.

Upon arrival in Minnesota, Daniel was taken to a hospital, where his medical condition was evaluated, said the sheriff. He said he could not comment on the findings.

Keller, who did not charge for her services, said the charter flight was arranged so the boy's return would not become a media event.

"We wanted him to be able to come back quietly, not have cameras in his face, not have people shouting questions at him, allow him to get back to the farm and his father and his siblings and some sense of a normal life," she said.

"He's a nice boy but he's been through a lot. He really deserves a chance at this point to get some rest and peace and quiet."

Brown County District Judge John R. Rodenberg issued an arrest warrant for Colleen Hauser last Tuesday, when she and her son failed to show up for a court hearing. Rodenberg, who said the boy's "best interests" require he receive conventional medical care, issued a contempt order for the mother and ordered Daniel placed in the custody of the Brown County Family Services agency.

But Hoffmann said Monday that the court, noting the return was voluntary, quashed the warrant for the mother's arrest. A federal fugitive warrant will also be dropped, he said.

In February, the boy's cancer responded to an initial round of chemotherapy. But the treatment's side effects concerned the boy's parents, who opted not to pursue further chemotherapy and solicited other medical opinions.


Daniel's symptoms of persistent cough, fatigue and swollen lymph nodes were diagnosed in January as Hodgkin's lymphoma. Court documents show doctors estimated the boy's chance of five-year remission with more chemotherapy, and possibly radiation, at 80 to 95 percent.

Philip Elbert, Daniel's court-appointed attorney, said he considers his client to have a "diminished capacity" because of his age and the illness, and said he believes Daniel should be treated by a cancer specialist.
 
It sounds like the mother is finally giving in but I hope it isn't too late for the boy. Only time will tell.
 
At this point in time the boy has a good chance of survival given that he will now be going under chemotherapy treatment until his mother makes a case to allow him to use hollistic treatments (which thus far have not shown any significance in treating cancer), and the fact that the mother was gathering information from random sites all over the internet rather than consulting with holistic doctors that are certified by the AMA. I don't think the mother understood the enormity of the task she was undertaking. The father may have realized it after the media frenzy, and thus pleaded for them to return home.
 
What are parents' rights regarding a child's medical treatment?
(CNN) -- Perhaps no one is watching the Daniel Hauser case in Minnesota more closely than Theresa and Greg Maxin in Ohio. Seven years ago, the Maxins found themselves fighting to keep their own son from having chemotherapy. But the two families' stories ended quite differently.

Like Daniel, Noah Maxin had a blood cancer doctors said would almost surely kill him if he didn't have chemotherapy. Like the Hausers, the Maxins rejected the doctor's recommendations in favor of supplements and other alternative treatments to boost his immune system. Both cases wound up in courtrooms.

But the similarities end there. A Minnesota court ordered Colleen and Anthony Hauser to have their son undergo chemotherapy and possibly radiation. The Maxins, however, won their case, and for a time gave Noah, who was then 7 years old, only alternative treatments.

"Our heart goes out to the Hausers," says Theresa Maxin. "They obviously weren't heard by their medical team. We felt the same way."

While the Hauser case is an example of the court going against parents' wishes, there are several cases, like the Maxins, where courts have allowed families to reject a doctor's recommendations for life-saving treatment.

"Parents really do have a lot of rights," says Gregory Beck, the Ohio lawyer who represented the Maxins. "But they have to be willing to advocate for them and provide strong alternatives." VideoWatch more on parental rights »

In a situation where the child's life is not in danger, parents have quite a bit of leeway, says George Annas, chairman of the Department of Health Law, Bioethics, and Human Rights at the Boston University School of Public Health.

"Even with a cleft palate, if the parents don't want their child to have the surgery to correct it, most courts would side with the parents, and let the child make the decision when he becomes an adult," Annas says.

Even when a child is in imminent danger of dying, parents have the latitude to reject potentially life-saving treatments if they're experimental, or if the parents can show an alternative treatment would work just as well, says Art Caplan, director of the Center for Bioethics at the University of Pennsylvania.

Children can, on occasion, also have their wishes heard. Teenagers who are found to be "mature minors" have sometimes been allowed by courts to reject life-saving treatments, Annas says.

"Mature minors" are usually at least 15 years old and "can understand the nature and consequences of their decisions," says Annas.

Courts have also sided with families in life-or-death situations when the parents find a licensed physician willing to administer the alternative medicine they're seeking.

This was the case with the Maxins, who found a doctor specializing in holistic medicine to oversee Noah's treatment with supplements and a special diet -- and no chemotherapy.

"The Maxins are warm, engaging, intelligent people, and very well-read on the issues. They exhaustively researched everything," says Beck.

The Maxins say they agreed to an initial round of chemotherapy for Noah only because they felt "threatened" and pressured by time constraints.

The day he was diagnosed, the Maxins say a social worker came into Noah's hospital room and said they would begin the process of giving him chemotherapy immediately. "I told her we believe in holistic and alternative therapies, and we wanted to take him out of the hospital," Theresa Maxin says. "But she told us there would be legal implications if we tried to do that. We felt like we'd been put in a corner, like we'd been boxed in."

A mother who successfully fought to keep her child from having chemotherapy says many other parents she knows have also felt rushed to make decisions.

In 2005, a Virginia court allowed Rose and Jay Cherrix to stop using chemotherapy on their son, Abraham, who had Hodgkin's lymphoma. He'd already had three months of chemotherapy when the Cherrixes decided they wanted to try alternative treatments instead. The court agreed as long as an oncologist supervised his care.

Cherrix, who turns 19 next month, took vitamins and supplements, followed a special diet, and in addition had several rounds of radiation. After his court case, the Virginia Legislature passed a law allowing teens over age 14 to have a hand in making their own medical decisions.

Rose Cherrix says she's spoken to Colleen Hauser and other parents who want to defy doctors' orders. Her advice: Don't feel coerced into making a quick decision. "There's always the pressure that you have to do something right now, and that's not true," she said.


The Maxins' lawyer agrees. "No one would have gone to jail if they'd taken Noah out of the hospital to see someone else. You don't have a whole lot of time, but you do have some time," Beck says.

Four years after the court case, Abraham Cherrix says he is now in good health.

As for Noah Maxin, after his leukemia diagnosis, he underwent alternative treatments and chemotherapy simultaneously for one month. The cancer went into remission, and his parents won the right to take him off chemotherapy in October 2002. For the next five months, he used only alternative treatments.

When the leukemia returned in March, his parents chose to put him back on chemotherapy. He went into remission again, and was healthy for three years.

In April, 2006, the cancer came back. Noah received aggressive chemotherapy and died 14 months later at age 11.

His parents say they've asked themselves if Noah might have survived if he'd received the chemotherapy doctors recommended from October 2002 until March 2003. "I'll consider that for the rest of my life. There's no way of knowing," Greg Maxin said. "But we made the decisions for our child. At the end of the day, it was us. Not the state or the government, but us."
 
When it comes to certain types of cancers, and later stage cancers, wait and see is not very sound medically. Additionally, the child in this case was receiving radiation. So he was undergoing a combination of holistic and traditional methods, not one or the other.
 
Teen cancer patient responding poorly to chemo, family says
(CNN) -- A 13-year-old Minnesota boy who has cancer has resumed chemotherapy treatments and is not responding well, a family spokesman said Friday.

Danny Hauser started a second round of chemotherapy treatment this week, Jim Navarro said in a statement on the family's Web site, dannyhauser.com.

"The doctor changed the number of chemotherapy drugs in the protocol submitted to the court. Danny is not tolerating the drugs well and has been vomiting all day. He is understandably angry and depressed about being forced to go through the ravages of chemotherapy again."

Daniel underwent his first round of chemotherapy in February, a month after he was diagnosed with Hodgkin's lymphoma. But his parents were concerned about the treatment's side effects, which typically include nausea, and decided to end the chemotherapy regimen and pursue holistic treatments instead.

When Daniel's oncologist learned of the decision to reject standard treatment, which doctors say is associated with a cure rate of as high as 90 percent, he asked a court to intervene to ensure the teen got chemotherapy.

Doctors say that, without it, the disease would likely prove fatal.

But last week, before the court could act, Colleen Hauser packed up her son and flew with him to Southern California, from where they were planning to continue to Mexico to seek alternative alternative medical treatment. She said he would have run on his own had she not helped him flee.

She changed her mind before crossing the border and returned this week with Daniel to Minnesota, where the family agreed to comply with whatever treatment the court ordered.

A medical examination revealed that the boy's tumor had grown since he was diagnosed and the boy's doctor recommended he resume chemotherapy.

After examining the boy on Monday, Dr. Michael Richards estimated the tumor's size at 5.3 inches by 5.1 inches by 6.3 inches, and said it was "protruding outside the chest wall."

He said initiation this week of standard chemotherapy treatment was "imperative."

Richards recommended at least another five cycles of chemotherapy followed by radiation, and added that the "goal will be to include alternative therapies in which the family is interested, as long as there is not data to suggest that a particular danger exists with any alternative medicine."

District Court Judge John Rodenberg originally took custody of the boy away from his parents, but returned him to his family on the condition that they comply with the recommendations of the cancer specialist.

Hodgkin's lymphoma is a cancer that affects the lymphatic system, which is part of the immune system. As the disease progresses, it compromises a body's ability to fight infection.

this situation does not sound good....
 
Why? Because he is vomiting? That is to be expected with chemo. Additionally, because his treatment was delayed, and the tumor grew in the meantime, the chemo now has to be more aggressive than it would have been a few months ago.
 
Okay, I read the current news and done. Geez, I hope everything is okay asap. =/
 
It sounds like the mother is finally giving in but I hope it isn't too late for the boy. Only time will tell.

Jillio´s post

Why? Because he is vomiting? That is to be expected with chemo. Additionally, because his treatment was delayed, and the tumor grew in the meantime, the chemo now has to be more aggressive than it would have been a few months ago.


Yes I am thinking the same.
 
Why? Because he is vomiting? That is to be expected with chemo. Additionally, because his treatment was delayed, and the tumor grew in the meantime, the chemo now has to be more aggressive than it would have been a few months ago.

Exactly. When my mother went through chemo, she would always get sick afterward. Nausea/vomiting are a common side effect.
 
Why? Because he is vomiting? That is to be expected with chemo. Additionally, because his treatment was delayed, and the tumor grew in the meantime, the chemo now has to be more aggressive than it would have been a few months ago.
what do you mean a few months ago? it's only been about a month.

Yes I am thinking the same.

Exactly. When my mother went through chemo, she would always get sick afterward. Nausea/vomiting are a common side effect.

no... it said - he's responding POORLY to chemotherapy and drugs. this is not just about side effect we're talking about.
 
no... it said - he's responding POORLY to chemotherapy and drugs. this is not just about side effect we're talking about.

Should he quit chemo and die prematurely? I hope you never have the experience of knowing someone who is diagnosed with cancer. Treatment options aren't as black and white as you think.
 
Back
Top