Help save Scranton State School for the Deaf Petition

Miss-Delectable

New Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2004
Messages
17,158
Reaction score
7
Scranton State School for the Deaf in jeopardy

Scranton State School for the Deaf in jeopardy | News | thetimes-tribune.com - The Times-Tribune

The Scranton State School for the Deaf, the only state-owned school of its kind, may close at the end of this school year unless it finds a new source of money.

Funding for the school is eliminated in Gov. Ed Rendell’s proposed 2009-10 budget, released Wednesday.

Instead, plans are in the works for the Northeastern Educational Intermediate Unit to partner with the nonprofit Western Pennsylvania School for the Deaf to provide services — likely at the 10-acre campus in the city’s Green Ridge section, said Donald E. Rhoten, superintendent of the Pittsburgh school.

Meanwhile, area legislators said they are determined to keep the school open.

Dr. Fred Rosetti, the intermediate unit’s executive director, said he is working with the Pennsylvania Department of Education to ensure that the more than 100 students at the school will have adequate services for the 2009-10 school year. He said some kind of residential and day service for deaf students would likely still be provided in Scranton.

The School for the Deaf was budgeted to receive $8.2 million in the 2008-09 budget, but Mr. Rendell pared that sum in the fall during a first round of budget cuts.

State Education Secretary Gerald L. Zahorchak, Ed.D., said the cost of the school was too much for the state. About $5 million of special-education funding is included in the 2009-10 budget to assist in the transition.

“We think there is a better way, a more optimal way,” he said at a budget briefing Wednesday in Harrisburg. Dr. Zahorchak added that the cost per student was about $80,000.

At the school’s campus, the news hit like a bolt out of the blue.

Superintendent Monita Hara, Ed.D., did not learn what Mr. Rendell planned to propose until Tuesday at 8 p.m., when she participated in a teleconference call with Dr. Zahorchak.

He informed her that representatives of the department and the governor’s office would be at the school Wednesday to meet with management, staff and students.

“Basically, it’s like a bomb being dropped,” said Margaret Matisko, president of the board of trustees, who spoke with Dr. Zahorchak late Tuesday. “When we brought the news forward (Wednesday morning), everybody was surprised and disappointed.”

Founded in 1880 as a class for eight deaf children, the school started in the basement of a church in downtown Scranton. Through the efforts of Jacob M. Koehler, a deaf man from the area, a coal company donated the land where the school now stands.

By authority of a 1913 state legislative act, the school became property of the state and was renamed Pennsylvania State Oral School for the Deaf. In 1976, the school’s name was changed to its current designation, the Scranton State School for the Deaf.

The school employs 75 faculty and staff members and serves 107 students from birth to 21 years of age. Dr. Hara said about half of the students, who come from 53 of the state’s 67 counties, are enrolled in the residential program — they come to the campus on Monday morning and return home Friday evening.

“It’s most definitely a shock,” said Dr. Hara, who spent most of the day in meetings. “The students were highly emotional hearing this news. They are like brothers and sisters to each other. The older ones look out for the younger ones, and they care about each other.”

She said parents were supposed to be informed about the elimination of state funding in a letter from the department.

“The parents many times have fought to get their children in here,” she said. “It’s just sad to me that now they have to fight to let them stay here.”

Dr. Hara said she had no details about the proposed partnership between the Western Pennsylvania School for the Deaf and intermediate unit.

Mr. Rhoten, who is deaf, said through an interpreter that he is hopeful the relationship between the Western Pennsylvania School for the Deaf and the intermediate unit will include the continued employment of some of the faculty and staff employed at the school.

The Pittsburgh school is one of four charter schools for the deaf and blind in the state, and unlike the Scranton school, is not owned by the state, Mr. Rhoten said. The school is funded by students’ home districts, the state and by donations, he added.

“We’re interested in serving kids, that’s our commitment,” Mr. Rhoten said. “We want to minimize the negative impact this may have on the community.”

Area legislators said they were opposed to the school’s closure.

In a statement, Sen. Robert Mellow, D-22, said he was outraged by the decision and was offended the state made no effort to discuss the plans with school officials or legislators prior to Tuesday night.

Mr. Mellow also said he was offended that the education department bypassed school officials and sent an “overnight letter” to parents Tuesday informing them of the closure.

Rep. Ken Smith, D-112, said he was informed of the intent to close the school by two Department of Education officials who were waiting in his Harrisburg office when he arrived Wednesday.

He vowed to resist any attempt to shut down the facility, asking how the state could put a price-tag “on those who are in most need among us.”

Ms. Matisko said she has promised students the board will do everything it can to keep them together and would have preferred that there was a plan in place to do that before the governor made his announcement.

“It may not be called Scranton State School for the Deaf, but there will be a program,” she said. “The word used was ‘hopeful.’ All of us are hopeful that will occur.”
 
School for Deaf closing

School for Deaf closing | Wilkes-Barre News | The Times Leader

The state has notified the Scranton School for the Deaf that it will close as of July 1, board members said Wednesday.

Funding for the 129-year-old school was not include in the state budget proposal announced Wednesday by Gov. Ed Rendell revealed his $29 billion budget proposal for 2009-10.

Marge Davison Matisko, chairwoman of the schools Board of Trustees, and Mahmoud Fahmy, trustee, saidthe decision was announced late Tuesday night and meetings were held Wednesday with state officials, administrative staff and board members.

The current enrollment is 91 students.

“I am angry; I feel betrayed,” Fahmy said.

State Senate Democratic Leader Robert J. Mellow questioned the decision to shut down the school and vowed to fight the plan.

“The school is important to our children, who come from 53 different school districts -- and important to northeastern Pennsylvania’s community and economy,” Mellow said. “While I realize that difficult cuts will need to be made as part of the budget process, it makes no sense to close this school.”

Rendell spokesman Chuck Ardo said the decision was made after great deliberation and with concern for the students and employees.

“We don’t believe that the state should be in the business of directly operating schools,” Ardo said. “We have had conversations with the Western Pennsylvania School for the Deaf as well as the Northeast Intermediate Unit 19 about providing services for these students. We believe that can be done in a much more cost effective way.”

Mike Race, communications director for the state Department of Education, said meetings were held Wednesday with school staff to discuss the closure. Mike Walsh, deputy secretary for administration, and Beth Olanoff, policy director, were in Scranton Wednesday to deliver the news to the school’s superintendent, Monita Hara, according to Race.

Race said some students could receive help for services they need and some might enroll in the western Pennsylvania school.

“We realize these are students with special needs,” Race said. “We know they need special accommodations. We believe they can receive all they need in one of these other settings.”

The annual cost per student at the school is $80,000, Race said. The school has an $8 million annual budget and employs 77 full-time workers. It’s the only state-operated school in Pennsylvania and the majority of students reside in northeast Pennsylvania.

The school opened in 1880 and operates on 10 acres in Scranton’s Green Ridge section.

According to its Web site, it started off as a class for eight deaf children in the basement of a Baptist church in downtown Scranton.

Fahmy said he and other trustees asked for time to raise funds to lessen the impact on the state budget, but that idea was dismissed by the administration.

“The answer we received was ‘we are not in the business of conducting schools like this any more,’” Fahmy said. “They should have given us some time to develop a strategy to alleviate the funding problem, but the state was not interested.”

Fahmy said the school has had many graduates who have gone on to college and have achieved great success.

“Can you imagine if you are a parent of a deaf child and now that child is to be mainstreamed into a classroom?” Fahmy asked. “Public schools are not equipped to handle them; they will not receive as good an education.”
 
PA Dept. of Education Addresses Parents on Closing of School for the Deaf

PA Dept. of Education Addresses Parents on Closing of School for the Deaf : WFMZ-TV 69News

Governor Ed Rendell unveiled his 2009-2010 spending plan this week. The $29-billion dollar slate included many funding cuts, including closing the doors to the Scranton State School for the Deaf - a school that serves a some kids from the Lehigh Valley - and their parents say they are devastated. WFMZ's Stephanie Esposito reports.
>> On Wednesday Governor Ed Rendell proposed closing the doors of the Scranton State School of the deaf in an effort to cut the state budget.

>>PHONE: Its an expensive school to run. it costs 8 million dollars a year for an enrollment of about 100 students.

>>REPORTER: The department of education runs the school...and invited parents to a series of meetings this weekend....Last night at the first meeting, parents say the Department of Education tried to keep out the school's teachers.
When we got to the meeting today the State Dept of education asked us to leave. But parents here care enough about whats going on to follow us out and tell us their stories.

>>I thought, oh no. We're going to have to start all over again. We've already looked at all the other options and none of them worked.

>>REPORTER: Dana Schwenk's 17 year old son is a student at Scranton. He says their family actually had to split up and buy a home closer to the school in order to get their son in. It was a move of love and desperation after years of schools Schwenk says didn't help his son.

>>He's not cooperating because he's not getting what he needed. Where at Scranton there has never been a behavioral issue.

>>PHONE : We think the services and quality education at the school that the kids deserve can be delivered through other means.

>>REPORTER: Schwenk says the school is a second home and the teachers like second parents to his son. 16:03 It's the best thing for him.

>>PHONE: We have every intention to make sure these children like every other child in the commonwealth gets a quality education.

>>REPORTER: Still parent's say they're committed to campaigning to keep Scranton State School for the Deaf open.

>>There are real people behind this financial decision.
 
Governor's Plan to Close School for the Deaf Draws Heat from Local Parents

Governor's Plan to Close School for the Deaf Draws Heat from Local Parents : WFMZ-TV 69News

Another one of Governor Rendell's budget proposals is drawing heat from a Lehigh County couple. Gene and Julie Zapotocky's son, Nicholas, attends the Scranton State School for the Deaf. Problem is the school is set to close at the end of this school year as part of the governor's budget plan. The Zapotockys say public school doesn't provide Nicholas with the education he needs. ''When he went up there he just seemed to start to blossom. He was in his element. It was familiar to him. He was getting the education he needed in sign language which is his primary language.''

The Zapotockys say they've already started a campaign to keep the school open... writing to lawmakers and the governor... and... calling school administrators.
 
What a jerk! Hearing people like him do not understand the implications of closing a school like that...
 
God, people like him irritate me! What a selfish, unthinking nitwit!
 
I got this from my friend. So, I'd share it with you all.

Because Pennsylvania is broke, the governor has slated Scranton State School for the Deaf for closure at the end of the school year.

Yet, there is a twist. The Pennsylvania Department of Education contacted Western Pennsylvania School for the Deaf on the possibility of stepping into the picture to save Deaf Education in the Scranton area.
WPSD Superintendent Don Rhoten said: WPSD has been approached about the possibility of partnering with the Northern Educational Intermediate Unit, IU 19 about continuing both academic and residential services for
deaf children in Scranton. We are in the early stages of planning this effort and more information will be made public when appropriate. I speak for everyone at WPSD in expressing sadness over the possible demise of another school for the deaf.

DeafDigest hopes the Scranton school will continue as is with the assistance of the WPSD. So, as Rhoten advises, just stay tuned. Already public uproar is at a boiling level.

That's sad to hear that Scranton school (and all deaf schools for the deaf) will be closed. I don't think they should not close.
:(
And of course, I will sign the petition, Miss-Delectable. :)
 
Yes! It needs to stay open. People do not realize how these children blossom and grow going to schools where their needs are met 100% of the time.
 
Mod's Note:

Both threads has been merged since it consist the same issue for Scranton State School for the Deaf.
 
PA govt has less debt than we do in WA state and there's no lookout of closing the deaf school here, geez! Even, California too. The govt there seems to be truly greedy!
 
Lawmakers ready to sue to save Scranton State School for the Deaf

Here's an update on this situation --

Lawmakers ready to sue to save Scranton State School for the Deaf

BY SARAH HOFIUS HALL
STAFF WRITER
Published: Saturday, February 14, 2009
Updated: Saturday, February 14, 2009 7:36 AM EST

When the governor proposed terminating funding for the Scranton State School for the Deaf, he did it with little research and no firm transition plan, state legislators say.

The lawmakers are now demanding answers — and say they are willing to take the issue to court, if needed.

“How do you take a special needs child and basically throw them out and say, ‘We don’t have a plan, but we’ll get back to you?’ ” asked Rep. Ken Smith, D-112, Dunmore. “These are the kids who come to the plate with two strikes against them. We have to have an answer for them.”

At a meeting this week, legislators across the region spoke with representatives from the state Department of Education, including Education Secretary Gerald L. Zahorchak, Ed.D., and officials from the School for the Deaf.

Lawmakers said the meeting proved to them what they had guessed — that the state had done little research on the only state-owned school of its kind and how cost-effective an alternative could be.

“This transition will not be smooth,” said Rep. Kevin Murphy, D-113, Scranton, adding that there is no projection of the cost per student for alternativee services. “That question has to be answered.”

Gov. Ed Rendell’s administration says the discussion and debate is all part of the “budget process.”

In Mr. Rendell’s 2009-10 budget released last week, he proposed eliminating all funding for the school, which was $7.35 million for this school year. A plan is now being developed for the Northeastern Educational Intermediate Unit to partner with the nonprofit Western Pennsylvania School for the Deaf to provide services — likely at the 10-acre campus in the city’s Green Ridge section, which currently serves 107 students.

State Sen. Robert Mellow, D-22, the Senate Democratic minority leader, will offer an amendment to a bill that would halt the school’s closing until legislators can review results of a comprehensive study of the school.

If that doesn’t happen, Mr. Mellow said on Friday that he would go to court to “get what we need to make an intelligent decision.

“I would not hesitate for a moment to do that,” Mr. Mellow said. “I will never turn my back on them.”

Mr. Mellow said he is not “fighting closure,” but “fighting process.”

“There may be a better way to educate the children,” he said. “We just can’t spring it on them. If there’s a better way of doing it, you phase it out.”

Legislators have said they did not learn of the plan until the morning of the governor’s budget address, and school officials first learned of the plan the night before.

Michael Race, spokesman for the Department of Education, said many of the concerns of the lawmakers would be addressed over the next few months.

“All the concerns they’re expressing, that’s what the budget process is for,” Mr. Race said.

State officials have said operating the school is too expensive — about $80,000 per student — and that it can be done more efficiently. About $5 million for the transitional costs is included in the state budget.

“We’re confident that none of these kids are going to miss out on an education or not have the services they need,” Mr. Race said. “We have as much concern for these students as the lawmakers do.”

Mr. Smith said regardless of the budget process, more research was needed before the closure was proposed.

“When the governor announces his budget, this is a beginning of a long journey,” Mr. Smith said. “But at the same time, do you realize the emotions you are playing with?

“If these kids aren’t fragile enough, now you just broke them.”

School Superintendent Monita Hara, Ed.D., said she wanted to see a cost analysis to see how the services the school provides could be available at a lesser cost through another provider.

“We, at SSSD, feel that the Pennsylvania Department of Education does not present us as a viable option,” she said. “We could be the flagship school for the state.”

Lawmakers ready to sue to save Scranton State School for the Deaf | News | thetimes-tribune.com - The Times-Tribune
 
YAY!!! I'm very glad that there's an actual uproar about this!
The thing is, the cost of residential schools SEEM expensive, but most of the increased cost is due to things like dorms etc.
 
Back
Top