Eli vs Peyton

lumbingmi

lumbingmi

Active Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2006
Messages
4,370
Reaction score
6
Last night, Colts vs Giants was fanastic game. Peyton came out as winner but Eli had better QB rating. Eli is not in Peyton's caliber yet but as he gets more experience, he may pass his big brother.

Peyton s very good player but he's like Dan Marino in our generation where he always chokes in big games. Eli need to work on his accuracy and avoid big turnovers.

However, Colts is still my pick for AFC rep. in superbowl vs. Washington Redskins.
 
So, you think Peyton is better than Vince Young, Michael Vick or Matt Leinhart?
 
Texan Guy said:
So, you think Peyton is better than Vince Young, Michael Vick or Matt Leinhart?
Click to expand...

Of course.

Vince Young - he will be bust until he CAN read NFL defense

Michael Vick - overrated QB. He may have a chance if he learn how to be steve young.

Matt Leinhart - It is still too early. so at this point, yea peyton is 100 times better than him.

Btw, I feel sorry for D. Carr. I am sure he wish he had reggie bush.
 
OFC little Horse is best than young and others... just look at his stats from college days to now... im sure yall know who the Little Horse is....
 
Eli is quite impressive but overall, his bro Peyton fares by far better. Only Peyton had 8 years of exp on his belt so wait few more years to see how Eli fares.

Just look at Peyton's incredible career stats (almost unreal) and is the reason why he's the highest paid qb. No mystery here that he is the best qb.

Yes, Colts' offense linemen has done oft great job for their line protection that he has/had an advantage so often.

I don't know how good Giant's offense linemen are so anybody tell me how good are they? I know they have good rushers. We lost a great rusher, sigh. That means it adds bit more pressure on Peyton this fall for sure.
 
One more game for Peyton to go. He need to beat PATS to silence all critics or he will be remember forever as big choker like D. Marino.
 
All Peyton need to win Super Bowl then he will be greatest QB in NFL history (Tom Brady edged Peyton by 3-0 SB titles and 2 SB MVP, hee hee)....if no title or title, Peyton will earn Hall Of Fame without question.

Eli? Give him better offense team...Giants, do draft offesive players this year.
 
MaxUFC said:
I would give Vince and Matt few years to see if they can lead their teams....Vince was better over Matt.
Click to expand...

Wait until NFL league figure out Vince Young. He is in similar boat with M. Vick. Ron Mexico set the league on fire in his rookie year then have been soso ever since.

M. Lienhart is next Mark Burnell which bode well for Matt. Only if Cardinals get decent offense lineman (they should draft J. Thomas from Wisconsin in upcoming draft).
 
MaxUFC said:
All Peyton need to win Super Bowl then he will be greatest QB in NFL history (Tom Brady edged Peyton by 3-0 SB titles and 2 SB MVP, hee hee)....if no title or title, Peyton will earn Hall Of Fame without question.

Eli? Give him better offense team...Giants, do draft offesive players this year.
Click to expand...

Dan Marino got in HOF, so i dont see why Peyton could not get in either. Marino was profilic passer in NFL history yet he cannot win any big games.

If I have to pick one QB on my football team, I will pick Manning no question. Manning can carry team on his shoulder but his team often failed him especially on D side. Brady is good QB but he is very fortunately to be on very good team that has a brilliant coach and excellent D. Imagine if Brady is on Colts, would he have 3 SB and 2 MVP?? that is debateable. Still, I will pick Manning over Brady because of Manning's ability to control the flow of the game.

More I see abt ELI , he 's overrated QB. He basically thrived on his last name alone. Most QB improve or shine in their 3rd year in NFL. Eli is quite opposite of that as he regressed badly this year. STick fork in him. He's nothing but overhyped QB.
 
KINGOFNOOBS said:
Dan Marino got in HOF, so i dont see why Peyton could not get in either. Marino was profilic passer in NFL history yet he cannot win any big games.

If I have to pick one QB on my football team, I will pick Manning no question. Manning can carry team on his shoulder but his team often failed him especially on D side. Brady is good QB but he is very fortunately to be on very good team that has a brilliant coach and excellent D. Imagine if Brady is on Colts, would he have 3 SB and 2 MVP?? that is debateable. Still, I will pick Manning over Brady because of Manning's ability to control the flow of the game.

More I see abt ELI , he 's overrated QB. He basically thrived on his last name alone. Most QB improve or shine in their 3rd year in NFL. Eli is quite opposite of that as he regressed badly this year. STick fork in him. He's nothing but overhyped QB.
Click to expand...


Imagine : Tom Brady on Colts and Peyton on Patriots. Peyton will win more titles than Brady.

Yes, I will having Peyton over Brady on my team...even no lucky to draft Peyton on my football fantasy teams so far (still going draft him next year if someone take Tomlinson first.).

This sunday night game...everyone is watching Peyton Mannings more than Patriots D, Colts, Brady and Coach Bill. Let see at the end of game!
 
MaxUFC said:
All Peyton need to win Super Bowl then he will be greatest QB in NFL history (Tom Brady edged Peyton by 3-0 SB titles and 2 SB MVP, hee hee)....if no title or title, Peyton will earn Hall Of Fame without question.

Eli? Give him better offense team...Giants, do draft offesive players this year.
Click to expand...

Peyton Manning cemented his place as among the greatest QB ever and indeed can say he's better than Tom Brady now.
 
When Eli gets more experence in the NFL..I'm sure he'd be just as good (if not better) then his brother Peyton. Be watching them more & more through out the years to come. Be cool if both AFC Indianapolis Colts (Peyton) vs. NFC New York Giants (Eli) in a SuperBowl in the near future..
 
Back
Top