I put this in a new thread because it's a different subject.
Who decided on the punishment for the original sin? It was the god, but I don't see anything specific in Genesis 3 about all species getting diseases. What I see is the god cursing the ground to make it not grow a lot of plants, making Adam need to work the ground.
If diseases come from the original sin, explain how bacteria, viruses, defective versions of genes, protists, fungi and prions that cause diseases were created by Adam and Eve eating the forbidden fruit of a tree that the omniscientist god planted in the garden in the first place, knowing full well what would result from that. If only humans sinned, why are there diseases that affect other animals and plants? Bacteria can even be inflected by viruses. Some of them could jump to humans, but plenty can't. I've not heard of anyone getting distemper from their pets or black rot from plants.
Do not use free will because being omniscientist means knowing everything, including what choices people will use their free will to make.
If the disease causing things were created in this 'curse' then how come we can compare their genes and find how they're related? And what about other little things that don't cause disease? And what about the ones that are helpful sometimes and sometimes cause disease?
For example, Escherichia coli helps digestion in the intestines, but if it gets out of there, it makes you sick. Does this mean that the E. coli didn't exist before the original sin, making it harder for people to digest things? Adding it where it is helpful seems like an odd punishment.
There's also cyanobacteria that can make cyanotoxins, but are important suppliers of oxygen. Not having that before the 'curse' would mean much less oxygen generation capacity.
Saying all diseases would include diseases of other species, so how does bitting a fruit make all kinds of organisms get infected? That's a lot of hocus pocus and the one character in the position to do that much abracadabra in the Adam & Eve story is the god. So if the god inflected all of his own creation for the misbehavior of only two members, it's not so surprising that people say that this god hates his own creation.
sculleywr said:All disease, not just mental illness, ties into the original sin. It is a result of Adam's sin, as is the sin nature of man. It is not a result of the sin nature, it is in the same package as the sin nature. saying that would be like saying that the motherboard's functioning is a result of the monitor turning on. Now, the people who say that mental illness is a punishment for your own sin, or a sin in itself, are, sadly, a dangerous minority of Christians.
Who decided on the punishment for the original sin? It was the god, but I don't see anything specific in Genesis 3 about all species getting diseases. What I see is the god cursing the ground to make it not grow a lot of plants, making Adam need to work the ground.
If diseases come from the original sin, explain how bacteria, viruses, defective versions of genes, protists, fungi and prions that cause diseases were created by Adam and Eve eating the forbidden fruit of a tree that the omniscientist god planted in the garden in the first place, knowing full well what would result from that. If only humans sinned, why are there diseases that affect other animals and plants? Bacteria can even be inflected by viruses. Some of them could jump to humans, but plenty can't. I've not heard of anyone getting distemper from their pets or black rot from plants.
Do not use free will because being omniscientist means knowing everything, including what choices people will use their free will to make.
If the disease causing things were created in this 'curse' then how come we can compare their genes and find how they're related? And what about other little things that don't cause disease? And what about the ones that are helpful sometimes and sometimes cause disease?
For example, Escherichia coli helps digestion in the intestines, but if it gets out of there, it makes you sick. Does this mean that the E. coli didn't exist before the original sin, making it harder for people to digest things? Adding it where it is helpful seems like an odd punishment.
There's also cyanobacteria that can make cyanotoxins, but are important suppliers of oxygen. Not having that before the 'curse' would mean much less oxygen generation capacity.
Saying all diseases would include diseases of other species, so how does bitting a fruit make all kinds of organisms get infected? That's a lot of hocus pocus and the one character in the position to do that much abracadabra in the Adam & Eve story is the god. So if the god inflected all of his own creation for the misbehavior of only two members, it's not so surprising that people say that this god hates his own creation.
