Defendant Slits Wrists in Front of Judge

rockin'robin

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Messages
24,430
Reaction score
551
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. -- A defendant smuggled a razor-blade into a Duval County courtroom Wednesday and cut his wrist as he stood in front a judge.

Shawn Roberts was appearing at a pretrial hearing on charges he broke into a Channel 4 producer's apartment with a gun and attacked her.

"I think the quote was, 'Judge I think he's bleeding,'" Assistant State Attorney Matt O'Keefe said. "They give him razor-blades to shave in the morning and he had smuggled it into court and was holding it. When he got in front of the judge, he literally began taking a small razor blade and slicing his left wrist with it."

Courthouse guards and paramedics rushed to Courtroom 7. Roberts was not seriously hurt and was not transported to a hospital.

"I would call this a suicide gesture," O'Keefe said. "A suicide act would be someone really attempting to kill themselves."

O'Keefe called it a feeble attempt to convince the judge that he is unfit to stand trial on charges of burglary with battery. If convicted, he faces up to life in prison.

"He has been examined twice by a competent psychiatrist and they've found that very point -- there's nothing wrong with Mr. Roberts," O'Keefe said. "This was simply another attempt by Mr. Roberts to play off on the court that he has issues."

After Roberts was bandaged, he returned to the courtroom and appeared to be confused.

"I don't understand what's going on. I'm going in and out," Roberts said to Judge Mark Mahon.

"Well, I think you're in right now," Mahon said, then told Roberts that he didn't make a good decision when he superficially cut himself.

"You appear to be somewhat savvy with regards to this, although I think you're getting some bad advice from 'lawyers' in jail," Mahon said.

Chief Tara Wildes, who is in charge of the Duval County jail, said Roberts was searched prior to being taken to court and they believe he hid the razor blade in a bandage.

"We can't find where any security procedures were violated," Wildes told Channel 4's Laura Mazzeo. "He was searched at least twice before leaving the jail and probably upon arriving at the courthouse as well ... but you can see, this is a mighty small piece of razor."

Prosecutors said that smuggling a weapon into court will result in additional charges against Roberts.

After the disruption, Mahon ruled that Roberts' previous conviction for raping a 14-year-old girl can be used against him in his trial, scheduled for next month.

Defendant Slits Wrist In Front Of Judge - Jacksonville News Story - WJXT Jacksonville
 
I'm not so sure I agree that this was a suicide attempt.

People who slit their wrist (i.e. cut) don't do so because they want to die. They do it because they are indirectly asking for help.

I have problems with self harm/cutting myself, but I don't do any of these behaviors because I'm suicidal. I do them because they give me a sense of control where I ordinarily have none.

Self harm/cutting also provides a temporary relief from the emotional pain I am experiencing.

Then again, perhaps I am misinterpreting the article. :hmm:
 
I'm not so sure I agree that this was a suicide attempt.

People who slit their wrist (i.e. cut) don't do so because they want to die. They do it because they are indirectly asking for help.

I have problems with self harm/cutting myself, but I don't do any of these behaviors because I'm suicidal. I do them because they give me a sense of control where I ordinarily have none.

Self harm/cutting also provides a temporary relief from the emotional pain I am experiencing.

Then again, perhaps I am misinterpreting the article. :hmm:

I agree with you. I was an "ex-cutter"....13 years ago. I got some help! It's an emotional, overwhelming feeling.

As for this guy who slit his wrists....just a ploy!...he's a career criminal!
 
I agree with you. I was an "ex-cutter"....13 years ago. I got some help! It's an emotional, overwhelming feeling.

As for this guy who slit his wrists....just a ploy!...he's a career criminal!

I agree with you on both counts.

This is off-topic a bit, but I'm currently working with my therapist on behavioral techniques to deal with my self harm/cutting. I've put a few of them into practice, but still need a little work because this is something I've done ever since I was a teenager.

I'm glad you've recovered from your cutting. Good for you! :D
 
I'm not so sure I agree that this was a suicide attempt.

People who slit their wrist (i.e. cut) don't do so because they want to die. They do it because they are indirectly asking for help.

I have problems with self harm/cutting myself, but I don't do any of these behaviors because I'm suicidal. I do them because they give me a sense of control where I ordinarily have none.

Self harm/cutting also provides a temporary relief from the emotional pain I am experiencing.

Then again, perhaps I am misinterpreting the article. :hmm:

I agree with you. I was an "ex-cutter"....13 years ago. I got some help! It's an emotional, overwhelming feeling.

As for this guy who slit his wrists....just a ploy!...he's a career criminal!

I agree that this wasn't a suicide attempt, but I also don't think this guy is a cutter either; meaning I don't think an emotional or psychological urge drove this man to slice his wrist. I believe it was a play for leniency infront of the judge. I also wonder what they could have done to prevent this guy from bringing the sharp into court.

Stupid! :roll:
 
I agree that this wasn't a suicide attempt, but I also don't think this guy is a cutter either; meaning I don't think an emotional or psychological urge drove this man to slice his wrist. I believe it was a play for leniency infront of the judge. I also wonder what they could have done to prevent this guy from bringing the sharp into court.

Stupid! :roll:

That's a good point Ocean and something I didn't consider.

And you're right -- bringing a sharp object into court was a dumb thing to do. :roll:
 
Agreed, OB. This was not a suicide attempt, nor was it even a suicidal gesture. It was not cutting behavior. Cutting behaviors are ritualistic and performed in private. If he were actually making a suicide attempt, he would not have chosen a packed courtroom where help would be immediately available. This was simply an attempt to manipulate the court and convince them that he was not competent to stand trial.
 
I agree.. This was a feeble attempt to manipulate the system.

Be suprised by what people will do in order avoid standing trial or going to prison.
 
He did what he did in a misguided attempt to convince the court that he was not competent to stand trial. If he could plan it out, he is indeed competent. Backfired on him.
 
Agreed, OB. This was not a suicide attempt, nor was it even a suicidal gesture. It was not cutting behavior. Cutting behaviors are ritualistic and performed in private. If he were actually making a suicide attempt, he would not have chosen a packed courtroom where help would be immediately available. This was simply an attempt to manipulate the court and convince them that he was not competent to stand trial.

hah!! for once we agreee on something mark this one in your calendars folks, lol seriously though whoever that guard was that checked for blades and didnt catch it should be fired effective immediatly I was a guard once, he couldve slashed a officers throat or a judge theres no excuse for incompetence
 
Agreed, OB. This was not a suicide attempt, nor was it even a suicidal gesture. It was not cutting behavior. Cutting behaviors are ritualistic and performed in private. If he were actually making a suicide attempt, he would not have chosen a packed courtroom where help would be immediately available. This was simply an attempt to manipulate the court and convince them that he was not competent to stand trial.

hah!! for once we agreee on something mark this one in your calendars folks, lol

It has been duly noted. :lol:
 
I guess that's what you call true "blind justice." :laugh2: :laugh2:

that is wrong man!!!!!!!!! lol!!!!!!!!!!!!!, same point with the guy in this case he slit his wrist and everyone says hes competent so that was pretty pointless to slit your rist or whatever he did
 
that is wrong man!!!!!!!!! lol!!!!!!!!!!!!!, same point with the guy in this case he slit his wrist and everyone says hes competent so that was pretty pointless to slit your rist or whatever he did

:lol:

Like I told you on your profile page, this person is a prime candidate for the Darwin Awards. :roll:
 
Back
Top