Netanyahu Rejects Obama Call for '67 Borders

Status
Not open for further replies.

Reba

Retired Terp
Premium Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2004
Messages
54,899
Reaction score
1,518
Should be an interesting meeting between Netanyahu and Obama this week.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu swiftly rejected President Obama's call Thursday for Israel to pull back to the borders that existed before the 1967 Six-Day War, calling those lines militarily "indefensible."

Obama, in a sweeping address tackling the uprisings in the Middle East and the stalled peace process, stunned Washington and Jerusalem by endorsing Palestinians' demand for their own state based on the pre-1967 borders. The break with longstanding U.S. policy appeared to immediately aggravate the Israelis, who want the borders of any future Palestinian state determined through negotiations.

In a statement released late Thursday, Netanyahu said such a withdrawal would jeopardize Israel's security and leave major West Bank settlements outside Israeli borders.

"Israel appreciates President Obama's commitment to peace," the statement said. "Israel believes that for peace to endure between Israelis and Palestinians, the viability of a Palestinian state cannot come at the expense of the viability of the one and only Jewish state. That is why Prime Minister Netanyahu expects to hear a reaffirmation from President Obama of U.S. commitments made to Israel in 2004. ... Among other things, those commitments relate to Israel not having to withdraw to the 1967 lines."

The U.S. had previously endorsed the concept of a Palestinian state, but not the demand for permanent pre-1967 borders, with mutually agreed land swaps. The declaration comes ahead of a meeting in Washington between Obama and Netanyahu.

"The status quo is unsustainable," Obama said. "A lasting peace will involve two states for two peoples."

Though the shift will likely create tension as the president meets with Netanyahu and heads next to address Israel advocacy group AIPAC this weekend, Obama sought to assure that the United States' commitment to Israeli security is "unshakable."

He said Israeli's right to defend itself will remain paramount, and suggested the recent unity agreement between Fatah and Hamas, which the U.S. deems a terrorist group, is problematic for negotiations. Though Israel occupied East Jerusalem, along with the West Bank and Gaza Strip, in the 1967 Six Day War, Obama said Thursday that the "future of Jerusalem" remains to be worked out, as does the fate of Palestinian refugees.

He also publicly rejected attempts by the Palestinians to gain recognition for their own state before the United Nations. "Symbolic actions to isolate Israel at the United Nations in September won't create an independent state," Obama said....

Read more: Netanyahu Rejects Obama Call for Palestinian State Based on 1967 Borders - FoxNews.com
 
I'll wait for the reports subsequent to the meeting.
 
Obama may pout again.....take his ball and leave the room. He did it once.
 
You don't eat pigs, we don't eat pigs, it seems it's been that way forever. So if you don't eat pigs, and we don't eat pigs, why not, not eat pigs together?
 
They've had their meeting:

Netanyahu Rejects Obama Statehood Demand After Oval Office Meeting

Published May 20, 2011 | FoxNews.com

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, in front of President Obama and the media, explicitly rejected the president's call for a Palestinian state based on the pre-1967 borders.

Sitting beside Obama following a private Oval Office meeting, the visiting prime minister said Friday that he values the president's efforts to advance the peace process and intends to work with him. But he said the president's call for Israel to pull back to the borders that existed before the Six-Day War is not tenable.

"We can't go back to those indefensible lines. ... I discussed this with the president," Netanyahu said.

The meeting marked an especially tense moment for the two heads of state. The U.S.-Israeli relationship has endured several tests since Obama took office, and the president's endorsement of a key Palestinian statehood demand in his major address on Middle East policy Thursday was no exception.

Netanyahu on Friday echoed concerns of other Israelis that a full return to the 1967 borders could leave Israel vulnerable and would not result in a lasting peace.

"We both agree that a peace based on illusions will crash against the rocks of Middle Eastern reality. ... For there to be peace, the Palestinians will have to accept some basic realities -- the first is that while Israel is prepared to make generous compromises for peace it cannot go back to the 1967 lines, because these lines are indefensible" Netanyahu said. He said the two leaders still agree on the "overall direction" for peace in the region.

Obama, speaking to reporters, did not mention his border demand but stood by his Middle East speech. Obama said Friday that differences remain between the United States and Israel over the Middle East peace process, but that their relationship is "sound and will continue" and differences will be worked out "between friends."

Showing some common ground, both leaders stressed that Hamas, a U.S.-designated terror group which recently announced a unity agreement with Fatah, is not a reliable partner in peace talks.

The U.S. had previously endorsed the concept of a Palestinian state, but not the demand for permanent pre-1967 borders, with mutually agreed land swaps.

The immediate concern among pro-Israel lawmakers and advocates was that Obama's policy shift will give Palestinians a new starting point in negotiations, rather than something to work toward over the course of talks.

Josh Block, former spokesman for The American Israel Public Affairs Committee, told FoxNews.com that Obama "repeats the error" made when his White House pressed the Israelis on settlement construction, granting the Palestinians more leverage in talks.

The talks have since stalled and Obama's Middle East envoy has resigned. Block said Obama's new position will not help matters.

"This strategic error is manifold, and undermines, not advances, the prospects for peace talks," he said in an email.

White House Press Secretary Jay Carney acknowledged the position does create a starting point for talks, but claimed the two sides would still have plenty to negotiate when it comes to land swaps and security arrangements.

Obama is set to address the AIPAC conference on Sunday. Other Jewish advocacy groups said Obama's position merely puts the U.S. on record in support of a plan that had a good chance of being the basis for a compromise anyway.

"There will be the naysayers who can find something to protest from this address, including what is widely accepted wisdom -- that a final resolution will ultimately be based on 1967 lines with mutually agreed swaps," The National Jewish Democratic Council said.

Despite the shift, the president sought to assure that the United States' commitment to Israeli security is "unshakable."

He said Thursday and Friday that Israel's right to defend itself will remain paramount, and suggested the recent unity agreement between Fatah and Hamas, which the U.S. deems a terrorist group, is problematic for negotiations. Though Israel occupied East Jerusalem, along with the West Bank and Gaza Strip, in the 1967 Six-Day War, Obama said Thursday that the "future of Jerusalem" remains to be worked out, as does the fate of Palestinian refugees.

He also publicly rejected attempts by the Palestinians to gain recognition for their own state before the United Nations. "Symbolic actions to isolate Israel at the United Nations in September won't create an independent state," Obama said.

Netanyahu is laying down demands of his own. He said in a speech to his parliament before traveling to Washington that he's opposed to talks with the new Palestinian alliance which includes Hamas. He also urged the Palestinians to drop their claim to East Jerusalem.

Read more: Netanyahu Rejects Obama Statehood Demand After Oval Office Meeting - FoxNews.com
 
Body language.
 

Attachments

  • netanyahu_obama_052011.jpg
    netanyahu_obama_052011.jpg
    14.8 KB · Views: 14
Netanyahu's speech to Congress:

23/05/2011

Speech by PM Netanyahu, AIPAC 2011
Address by PM Netanyahu at the AIPAC Policy Conference 2011

My friends, before I talk about things about Israel, I want to say something
about the scenes on television that I saw today and you have been seeing as
well. When tragedy strikes America, Israel -- Israel feels an immediate
identification. And tragedy has struck America. In recent days floods and
tornadoes have claimed the lives of hundreds of Americans, including today
in Joplin, Missouri. All I can say is, America, we're with you on this day,
on every day.

And that's very evident from the things I just heard from my two close
friends. Speaker of the House John Boehner, Senate Majority Leader Harry
Reid, you lead the many friends who are here today, the distinguished
senators and congressmen and congresswomen of the United States of America.

I want to greet AIPAC President Lee Rosenberg. Rosy, I learned the other day
that if I take you on, it's not going to be in basketball. It will be in
soccer. And Executive Director Howard Kohr -- Howard, you I'm not going to
take on in anything.

I want to welcome here also the representatives of the government of Israel,
members of Knesset, U.S. Ambassador to Israel Jim Cunningham,
Ambassador-designate Dan Shapiro, my beloved wife and the mother of our two
boys, Sara and finally, our terrific ambassador to the United States, a man
who knows a few things about the U.S.-Israel alliance, Michael Oren.

To all our supporters in this great hall and to the millions of supporters
across this great land, the people of Israel thank you. Thank you for your
staunch commitment to Israel's security. Thank you for defending Israel's
right to defend itself. Thank you for standing by Israel as it seeks a
secure peace.

Now, I heard tonight from all the speakers something that you know -- that
Israel is America's indispensable ally. You understand that Israel and
America stand shoulder to shoulder fighting common enemies, protecting
common interests. You know that Israeli innovators help power computers,
fight disease, conserve water, clean the planet. Your support for Israel
flows from the heart.

You see, it's not just what Israel does. It's what Israel is. Now, let me
explain that. Yesterday I had a great day. They let me out. Sara and I
could actually go for a walk. And I have to congratulate the American
security services. They're a little more generous than ours.

So we walked along the Potomac and we got to visit Washington's majestic
memorials. I read Jefferson's timeless words, "We hold these truths to be
self-evident, that all men are created equal." I read Lincoln's immortal
address, "government of the people, for the people, by the people."

Now, let me tell you why these words resonate so powerfully with me and with
all Israelis -- because they're rooted in ideas first championed by our
people, the Jewish people, the idea that all men are created in God's image,
that no ruler is above the law, that everyone is entitled to justice. These
are revolutionary Jewish ideas, and they were spoken thousands of years
ago - when vast empires ruled the earth, vast slave empires ruled the world.
And the Jews spoke these truths.

Israel is the cradle of our common civilization. It's the crucible of our
common values. And the modern state of Israel was founded precisely on these
eternal values. And this is why Israel's more than 1 million Muslims enjoy
full democratic rights. This is why the only place in the Middle East where
Christians are completely free to practice their faith is the democratic
state of Israel. And this is why Israel, and only Israel, can be trusted to
ensure the freedom for all faiths in our eternal capital, the united city of
Jerusalem.

My friends, Israel and America have drawn from these deep well springs of
our common values. We forged an enduring friendship not merely between our
governments, but between our peoples. Support for Israel doesn't divide
America. It unites America. It unites the old and the young, liberals and
conservatives, Democrats and Republicans. And, yes, Joe Lieberman, it even
unites independents. I want to take this opportunity to salute one of the
great senators in my lifetime, a man who's given unbelievable service to his
country, America, and has been unbelievably dedicated to Israel and the
Jewish people. Thank you, Joe Lieberman.

You see, this broad support for Israel in the United States is a tremendous
help and gives tremendous strength to my country. And since Harry Truman,
Israel has looked to American presidents to stand by it as we meet the
unfolding challenges of a changing world.

Yesterday President Obama spoke about his ironclad commitment to Israel's
security. He rightly said that our security cooperation is unprecedented. He
spoke of that commitment in front of AIPAC. He spoke about it in two
speeches heard throughout the Arab world. And he has backed those words
with deeds.

I know these are tough economic times. So I want to thank the president and
Congress for providing Israel with vital assistance so that Israel can
defend itself by itself. I want to thank you all for supporting the Iron
Dome missile defense system. A few weeks ago, Hamas terrorists in Gaza
fired eight rockets at our cities, at Ashkelon and Beer Sheva. Now, these
rockets never reached their targets. Iron Dome intercepted them in midair.
For the first time, a missile defense system worked in combat. That's a
precedent in military history. And I want to say thank you, America.

America and Israel are cooperating in many other ways as well. We're
cooperating in science, in technology, in trade, in investment. See, it's
not only American companies that are investing in Israel. It's Israeli
companies investing in America. In the last decade, Israeli companies have
invested more than $50 billion in the United States. One of those companies
is investing just down the road in Richmond. It's a company that is
building a food factory. Now, here's what it means -- more business, more
jobs, and, yes, more hummus.

Well, it's not just food we're bringing to America. Take medicine. Israel
is advancing cure for multiple sclerosis, Alzheimer's, cancer. We've
developed mechanical means to make paraplegics walk again. We've placed a
tiny diagnostic camera inside a pill. I have not swallowed it, but I
understand it's quite effective.

And you've just heard of this miraculous bandage developed by an Israeli
company that has helped save Congresswoman Gabby Giffords' life. And I wish
Gabby, a great friend of Israel, Refuah Shlema, a happy, quick, speedy
recovery.

Israel and America are also cooperating to end the world's worst addiction,
the addiction to oil. This dependence fuels terrorism. It poisons the
planet. So we've launched a 10-year program in Israel to kick the habit, to
find a substitute for gasoline. And if we succeed, we can change the world.
We can change history.

My friends, the American people's support for Israel is reflected in my
invitation to address a joint meeting of Congress tomorrow. Thank you, John
Boehner, for that invitation. I will talk about the great convulsion taking
place in the Middle East, the risks and the opportunities. And I will talk
about the dangers of a nuclear-armed Iran. And I will also outline a vision
for a secure Israeli-Palestinian peace. I intend to speak the unvarnished
truth because now, more than ever, what we need is clarity.

And events in our region are finally opening people's eyes to a simple
truth. Events in the region are opening people's eyes to a simple truth:
The problems of the region are not rooted in Israel. The remarkable scenes
we're witnessing in town squares across the Middle East and North Africa are
occurring for a simple reason: People want freedom. They want progress.
They want a better life.

For many of the peoples of the region, the 20th century skipped them by.
And now 21st century technology is telling them what they missed out on.
You remember that desperate food vendor in Tunis? Why did he set himself on
fire? Not because of Israel. He set himself on fire because of decades of
indignity, decades of intolerable corruption.

And the millions who poured into the streets of Tehran, Tunis, Cairo, Sanaa,
Benghazi, Damascus, they're not thinking about Israel. They're thinking of
freedom. They're yearning for opportunity. They're yearning for hope for
themselves and for their children. So it's time to stop blaming Israel for
all the region's problems.

Let me stress one thing. Peace between Israelis and Palestinians is a vital
interest for us. It would be the realization of a powerful and eternal
dream. But it is not a panacea for the endemic problems of the Middle East.
It will not give women in some Arab countries the right to drive a car. It
will not prevent churches from being bombed. It will not keep journalists
out of jail.

What will change this? One word: Democracy - real, genuine democracy. And
by democracy, I don't just mean elections. I mean freedom of speech,
freedom of press, freedom of assembly, the rights for women, for gays, for
minorities, for everyone. What the people of Israel want is for the people
of the Middle East to have what you have in America, what we have in
Israel -- democracy. So it's time to recognize this basic truth. Israel is
not what's wrong with the Middle East. Israel is what's right about the
Middle East.

My friends, we want peace because we know the pain of terror and we know the
agony of war. We want peace because we know the blessings peace could
bring - what it could bring to us and to our Palestinian neighbors. But if
we hope to advance peace with the Palestinians, then it's time that we
admitted another truth. This conflict has raged for nearly a century
because the Palestinians refuse to end it. They refuse to accept the Jewish
state.

Now, this is what this conflict has always been about. There are many
issues linked to this conflict that must be resolved between Israelis and
Palestinians. We can, we must, resolve them. But I repeat: We can only
make peace with the Palestinians if they're prepared to make peace with the
Jewish state.

Tomorrow in Congress, I'll describe what a peace between a Palestinian state
and the Jewish state could look like. But I want to assure you of one
thing. It must leave Israel with security. And therefore, Israel cannot
return to the indefensible 1967 lines.

I'll talk about these and other aspects of peace tomorrow in Congress. But
tonight I want to express Israel's gratitude for all you are doing to help
strengthen Israel and the great alliance that Israel has with America. You
helped maintain our qualitative military edge. You backed sanctions against
Iran. You supported genuine peace. You opposed Hamas. And you've joined
President Obama and me in denouncing Hamas and demanding that it release our
captive soldier, Gilad Shalit. That's another outrageous crime of Hamas.
Just imagine keeping a young soldier locked in a dark dungeon for five years
without even a single visit - not a single visit of the Red Cross. I think
that the entire civilized community should join Israel and the United States
and all of us in a simple demand from Hamas: Release Gilad Shalit.

My friends, I spent my high-school years in Philadelphia. I understand it's
developed quite a bit since then. But during those years, when it was a
sleepier town, I used to go visit the Liberty Bell. Now, as Prime Minister
of Israel, I can walk down the street and see an exact replica of that bell
in Jerusalem's Liberty Park. On both bells is the same inscription. It
comes from the Bible, from the book of Leviticus "Proclaim liberty
throughout the land." My dear friends, this is the essence of the great
alliance between our two nations - two peoples bonded in liberty and seeking
freedom and peace for all. That's what this alliance is all about. And you
are part of it. You maintain it.

I thank you on behalf of the people of Israel and the government of Israel.
Thank you for the American-Israel alliance. Thank you, AIPAC.

Part 1
YouTube - ‪Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu Speaks at Policy Conference 2011 - Part 1‬‏
Part 2
YouTube - ‪Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu Speaks at Policy Conference 2011 - Part 2‬‏
IMRA - Tuesday, May 24, 2011 [With video]Transcript: Speech by PM Netanyahu, AIPAC 2011
 
Israeli Prime Minister Gets 29 Standing Ovations in Congress, Sends Message to White House*
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s speech before a joint meeting of Congress had all trappings of a State of the Union address by a president with sky-high approval ratings.

Speaking to a packed House chamber with Speaker Boehner and Vice President Biden over his shoulders, Netanyahu was repeatedly interrupted by applause – including more than 20 standing ovations....
*UPDATE: President Obama got 25 standing ovations from Congress during his 2011 State of the Union address. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu got 29 today.
Israeli Prime Minister Gets 29 Standing Ovations in Congress, Sends Message to White House* - The Note
 

Attachments

  • Bibi_Obama.jpg
    Bibi_Obama.jpg
    58.5 KB · Views: 9
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top