Poll: Americans Overwhelming Opposed to Closing Gitmo

I was personally at Gitmo during my service in the United States Navy. As I understand it this is a strategic location. It is also the location where many of the Navy go for what is called reftra (short for Refresher training). I have been out of the service for several decades and don't know if it is still used for that but the location I still believe is strategic and for that reason alone we should stay there.
 
because he is the presdent of the country and he have the right to do whatever he want to do for this country and all he want is peace and americans people should feel the time way about this desions to open the posion back up.

by apologizing to everybody great prez, cant have peace without war

"the goddess of peace rest gently in the arms of the ready god of war"
 
Update:

Official: White House Considering Illinois Prison to House Detainees

A White House official says the Obama administration is eyeing an Illinois prison to house some Gitmo detainees.

The Obama administration may buy a near-empty prison in rural northwestern Illinois to house detainees from Guantanamo Bay along with federal inmates, a White House official told Fox News.

The maximum-security Thomson Correctional Facility, about 150 miles west of Chicago, was one of several evaluated by the Federal Bureau of Prisons, and emerged as a leading option to house the detainees.

The administration official, who spoke to Fox News anonymously, noted that no decision has been made.

President Obama wants alleged terrorism suspects from the controversial military-run detention center in Cuba to be transferred to U.S. soil so they can be prosecuted for their suspected crimes.

Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn has been hinting at a possible new use for Thomson, and he issued a statement saying he would hold a news conference Sunday to outline those plans.

Quinn's spokeswoman Marlena Jentz did not return a phone message from the AP Saturday.

But the move has already met some resistance both in Illinois and Washington.

U.S. Rep. Mark Kirk, a Northbrook Republican running for Obama's old Senate seat, circulated a letter among elected officials asking them to write to Obama opposing the plan, saying bringing Guantanamo prisoners to the state would make it a target for terrorist attacks.

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell told "Fox News Sunday" that he expects Illinois residents and lawmakers to object and that he and his colleagues will seek to block funding at the federal level.

"Hopefully the Senate and the House will speak on this issue," McConnell said.

Thomson was built by the state in 2001 with 1,600 cells, but budget problems prevented it from fully opening, and it now houses about 200 minimum-security inmates.

It is unclear how many Guantanamo detainees — many held without charges since the beginning of the war in Afghanistan — would be transferred to Illinois or when. Obama initially planned to close the Guantanamo Bay prison by Jan. 22, but the administration is no longer expected to meet that deadline.

If the Federal Bureau of Prisons buys the facility, it would be run primarily as a federal prison, but a portion would be leased to the Defense Department to house a limited number of Guantanamo detainees, the White House official said. Perimeter security at the site would be increased to surpass that at the nation's only Supermax prison, in Florence, Colo., the official said.

Illinois Sen. Dick Durbin, the Senate's second-highest-ranking Democrat, said in a statement Saturday he would support the plan. He said the prison would house fewer than 100 Guantanamo detainees and would have a "significant positive impact on the local economy" by generating more than 3,000 jobs.

Thomson Village President Jerry Hebeler said the move would generate desperately needed revenue for the town of about 500 residents near the Mississippi River.

"It's been sitting there for eight to nine years and our town is like a ghost town," Hebeler said of the prison, adding that a tavern recently closed and a planned housing development fell through. "Everybody moved or got different jobs."

But Kirk and other lawmakers opposed the idea of terrorism suspects being brought to Illinois.

U.S. Rep. Don Manzullo, whose district includes Thomson, said he adamantly opposed the proposal and that he has consistently joined with a majority of his colleagues "in fighting efforts to bring these terrorists onto our shores ... where they could one day be released into our communities."

Guantanamo Bay "is set up to house these dangerous terrorists, and they should stay there," said Manzullo, an Egan Republican who serves on the House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on Terrorism, Nonproliferation and Trade.

Illinois Rep. Jan Schakowsky, a Democrat, said Kirk and other Republicans were "pandering to irrational fears" and that closing the Guantanamo Bay facility would strengthen national security because al-Qaida used it as a recruiting tool.

Phone and e-mail messages left with Jim O'Connor, a spokesman for Illinois Sen. Roland Burris, were not immediately returned.

Thomson is not the only U.S. town that had hoped to lure Guantanamo detainees. Officials in Marion, Ill., Hardin, Mont., and Florence, Colo., also have said they would welcome the jobs that would be generated.
Official: White House Considering Illinois Prison to House Detainees - FOXNews.com
 
I'm always amazed when self-proclaimed patriotic, religious people approve of torture.

Newly Released Detainee Statements Provide More Evidence Of CIA Torture Program | American Civil Liberties Union

And it potentially threatens our national security. Not only that it gives a green light to find a way to prosecute these CIA members. When it comes to our national security, creating discomfort to get the needed information isn't for the weak minded and emotionally laden people. I rather see that my family and the people around me be safe and secure. Information extraction is a necessary component to our security and survival. Asking pretty please won't work. Amazing how some are willing to dismantle our national security and make it more vulnerable than ever. tsk...
 
And it potentially threatens our national security. Not only that it gives a green light to find a way to prosecute these CIA members. When it comes to our national security, creating discomfort to get the needed information isn't for the weak minded and emotionally laden people. I rather see that my family and the people around me be safe and secure. Information extraction is a necessary component to our security and survival. Asking pretty please won't work. Amazing how some are willing to dismantle our national security and make it more vulnerable than ever. tsk...

whatever it takes, right?
 
And those that we did release? Many of them continued with their terrorist activities or re-joined a known terrorist group. Maybe it would've been better to just shoot them while we had the chance instead of taking them in as prisoners after a raid or firefight.
 
And those that we did release? Many of them continued with their terrorist activities or re-joined a known terrorist group. Maybe it would've been better to just shoot them while we had the chance instead of taking them in as prisoners after a raid or firefight.

many? do you have source to back that statement?
 
Comon....

The Brits were heavily criticized for their questionable "shoot-to-kill" policy during the IRA campaign... if we extracted that policy, then the whole world will come down on us.
 
Comon....

The Brits were heavily criticized for their questionable "shoot-to-kill" policy during the IRA campaign... if we extracted that policy, then the whole world will come down on us.

and the subway shooting.
 
Back
Top