You are require to use HDMI to upscale the DVD into 720p to 1080i, even rarely are 1080p except if you get PS3.
I have HDTV 1080p with HDMI won't work CC
Component video work CC for only 480i but 480p or high is not working, i need 1080i or 1080p with CC
I have same problem as you did.
There's nothing to do about want CC on DVD movies via component cable or HDMI then you have wait until someone invent new CC decode for component and HDMI cable.
Just struck with subtitles on DVD.
Shit, I read manuel said component for only 480i or 480p at Samsung DVD-HD1080P7 but only HDMI for 480i to 1080p not support CC
I will exhcnage Samsung DVD-HD870 support 480/720/1080i without HDMI,
Yup, new tech is getting more complicated.
Also, you aren't alone but other ADers got same problem.
I'm going to look SOOO carefully on back of DVD if support subtitle, not CC only.
480p is better than 480i, of course.
I read infomation all webiste
I am wrong not HDMI or Component
ONLY 480i will work CC
480p, 720p, 1080i and 1080p will not work CC
That's sounds correct to me. Analog CC only works at 480i or lower. In fact analog CC will only work in interlaced mode. I have never seen a DVD player that actually outputs CC in 480p or higher. Anything higher than 480p would have to be digital CC. If you have seen one, please let me know the brand and model number of DVD player.
Thanks,
Peter
This has been my experience as well. It's very frustrating. I like captions better than subtitles and I want captions on DVDs that get upscaled to near HD quality.
This has been my experience as well. It's very frustrating. I like captions better than subtitles and I want captions on DVDs that get upscaled to near HD quality.
Banjo, what about Digital Closed Captioning, like I see on my HD-DVR for HD channels? Why can't DVDs and HD-DVDs use that?
Digital CC is alot better than analog CC but won't work for 480p or up.
You can get ATSC channels from antenna, all are local channel but haven't broadcating the ATSC for network like Nick, MTV, TNT, Spike, G4, Logo or Fuel TV because all of them are in NTSC. Also other option is getting HD receiver from Directv or Dish to catch ATSC channels.
Banjo, what about Digital Closed Captioning, like I see on my HD-DVR for HD channels? Why can't DVDs and HD-DVDs use that?
That's sounds correct to me. Analog CC only works at 480i or lower. In fact analog CC will only work in interlaced mode. I have never seen a DVD player that actually outputs CC in 480p or higher. Anything higher than 480p would have to be digital CC. If you have seen one, please let me know the brand and model number of DVD player.
Thanks,
Peter
let you know, lot of problem
ATSC Bulti-in CC
CC for 480i to 1080i, work
DVR Bulti-in CC
CC for 480i to 1080i, work
B U T
Player version:
DVD / HD-DVD / Blu-Ray will work only 480i alone
Windows XP Media Center Edtion and Vista Utlmate & Home Premium version:
They will work DVD / HD-DVD / Blu-Ray up to 1080p !!!! but lousy CC, I need Fucation CC (size, color, fonts, etc..) but not perfect 21 line
Any you have DVD / HD-DVD / Blu-Ray Player BULTI-IN CC to 1080i/p same like DVR set-box??
between Out CC or In CC
DVR, Set-box, ASTC HDTV, Media Center Edtion are IN CC
DVD / HD-DVD / Blu-Ray are OUT CC only, I need IN CC