Lesbian Community Assesses Health Issues
SAN FRANCISCO - Accustomed to neglect from much of the medical establishment, the lesbian community is assigning itself the task of assessing — often bluntly — its members' distinctive array of health problems.
Even without a specific crisis as grave as the AIDS (news - web sites) epidemic, the diagnosis is sobering: Compared to heterosexual women, lesbians appear to have higher rates of smoking, obesity and alcohol use. Often lacking health insurance or wary of unsympathetic doctors, they also may be less likely to undergo routine medical exams that could identify cancer and other problems at early stages.
Complicating all these factors, researchers say, is a glaring shortage of comprehensive data, resulting from the fact that most health surveys — as well as death certificates — don't account for sexual orientation.
"We don't know the mortality rates, we don't know the suicide rates," said Dr. Patricia Robertson of the University of California, San Francisco, School of Medicine. "Lesbians are invisible."
Robertson is co-director of UCSF's Lesbian Health Research Center, founded in 1999 to fill the perceived void in the study of lesbians' medical problems.
Other relatively new organizations have undertaken similar efforts, including the San Francisco-based Lesbian Health Fund and the Washington-based Mautner Project, which focuses on lesbians with cancer. A national conference on lesbian health was held in Chicago last month.
Several researchers said in interviews that they were derided by some colleagues for entering the field and still encounter skepticism, both within the medical profession and among Bush administration officials who influence priorities for federal health grants.
"Only just recently has there been a feeling that lesbian health is a legitimate specialty — but you still face inequities in funding," said Dixie Horning, executive director of UCSF's National Center for Excellence in Women's Health.
Robertson, in a pattern she says is common among lesbian researchers, performs most of her research and advocacy work on a volunteer basis while earning a living as an obstetrician. The general attitude — at the research center and among its allies — is that important research might not get done unless lesbians do it themselves.
One challenge, for all those concerned with lesbian health, is that the problems they confront are more subtle than those facing gay men.
"In the gay men's community, most of the issues relate to sexually transmitted disease — it's absolutely clear what kind of health risk it poses," said Susan Cochran, an epidemiologist at UCLA.
For the activist researchers, and groups like the Mautner Project, their work involves a balancing act — conveying concern without fueling negative stereotypes. Many lesbians are in excellent health and, particularly if affluent or well-insured, readily find doctors they like.
"What we want to do is make sure we're all living as healthily as possible," said Cheryl Pearson-Fields of the Mautner Project. "You're focusing on the things that lead to negative health outcomes, and the message can seem very negative."
She said smoking and substance abuse, to the extent they are more prevalent among lesbians, may be linked to the stress of feeling targeted by prejudice.
Changing the attitudes of lesbians themselves is another challenge. Cochran said many get checkups far less frequently than heterosexual women who see doctors for contraceptive advice, prenatal care and postnatal care.
"Most women are brought into a health-care setting on a regular basis," Cochran said. "Men go in when something goes wrong, and in some ways lesbians are like that."
When a lesbian does make an initial visit to a gynecologist, the doctor often assumes the patient is heterosexual and asks what birth control method she uses.
"That puts you off right to begin with," said Dr. Marion Kavanaugh-Lynch, vice president of the Lesbian Health Fund. "It shouldn't be up to a patient to correct an assumption — the assumption shouldn't be made in the first place."
Such encounters compel lesbians to decide on the spot whether to disclose their sexual orientation. "Every time you face that situation, you ask yourself, 'How will this person react?'" Kavanaugh-Lynch said.
Dr. Lisa Pratt, medical director at the Lyon-Martin women's clinic in San Francisco, said some lesbians balk at confiding in a doctor even if candor might aid a diagnosis.
"There's a vulnerability disclosing information to someone you don't really know," she said. "Too often, the patriarchal white-coated physician doesn't engender that trust."
The Gay and Lesbian Medical Association has compiled a national database of physicians who depict themselves as sensitive to the health concerns of gays and lesbians. "The number is awfully small in some states," Kavanaugh-Lynch said.
Advocacy groups are working with hospitals and medical schools to provide training on how to deal empathetically with lesbian health issues.
Because many lesbians get examined less frequently than other women — and because of the relatively high smoking, drinking and obesity rates — there is widespread suspicion that they get breast and cervical cancer more often or start treatment later. They also are less likely to bear children before age 30, missing out on the breast-feeding that reduces risk of breast cancer.
"We don't know a whole lot more than that," said Kavanaugh-Lynch, a breast-cancer specialist. "It's going to be at least a decade before the research is clear."
Short term, researchers and activists seek to encourage a self-help mentality. They say some lesbians hesitate to enter weight-loss or quit-smoking programs at which heterosexual women predominate, and some have been conditioned to be disinterested in fitness.
"So many lesbians get the message from their families, 'You don't really matter because you're not going to give us grandchildren. We're not going to bother to ask you about your health,'" Robertson said.
In some cases, a tendency toward obesity may be linked to a rejection of the sleek, sexy images of women abounding in the mass media.
"Many lesbians choose to push that image aside," Horning said. "They want to look like they want to look, do what they want to do and not fit Madison Avenue's stereotype."
Obesity, diabetes and cardiovascular problems are widespread among black lesbians, "but we're not seen as a group that needs to be taken seriously," said Brenda Crawford, who coordinates health-awareness programs for minorities in Oakland.
Nationally, lesbian researchers are asking federal agencies to ensure that sexual orientation is included more often among questions asked in major health studies.
"We've gotten sick of having to give talks without data," Robertson said. "There's so much that needs to be done, and not enough funding. Our community is not being respected in terms of studying health."
___
On the Net:
Lesbian Health Research Center: http://www.lesbianhealthinfo.org
SAN FRANCISCO - Accustomed to neglect from much of the medical establishment, the lesbian community is assigning itself the task of assessing — often bluntly — its members' distinctive array of health problems.
Even without a specific crisis as grave as the AIDS (news - web sites) epidemic, the diagnosis is sobering: Compared to heterosexual women, lesbians appear to have higher rates of smoking, obesity and alcohol use. Often lacking health insurance or wary of unsympathetic doctors, they also may be less likely to undergo routine medical exams that could identify cancer and other problems at early stages.
Complicating all these factors, researchers say, is a glaring shortage of comprehensive data, resulting from the fact that most health surveys — as well as death certificates — don't account for sexual orientation.
"We don't know the mortality rates, we don't know the suicide rates," said Dr. Patricia Robertson of the University of California, San Francisco, School of Medicine. "Lesbians are invisible."
Robertson is co-director of UCSF's Lesbian Health Research Center, founded in 1999 to fill the perceived void in the study of lesbians' medical problems.
Other relatively new organizations have undertaken similar efforts, including the San Francisco-based Lesbian Health Fund and the Washington-based Mautner Project, which focuses on lesbians with cancer. A national conference on lesbian health was held in Chicago last month.
Several researchers said in interviews that they were derided by some colleagues for entering the field and still encounter skepticism, both within the medical profession and among Bush administration officials who influence priorities for federal health grants.
"Only just recently has there been a feeling that lesbian health is a legitimate specialty — but you still face inequities in funding," said Dixie Horning, executive director of UCSF's National Center for Excellence in Women's Health.
Robertson, in a pattern she says is common among lesbian researchers, performs most of her research and advocacy work on a volunteer basis while earning a living as an obstetrician. The general attitude — at the research center and among its allies — is that important research might not get done unless lesbians do it themselves.
One challenge, for all those concerned with lesbian health, is that the problems they confront are more subtle than those facing gay men.
"In the gay men's community, most of the issues relate to sexually transmitted disease — it's absolutely clear what kind of health risk it poses," said Susan Cochran, an epidemiologist at UCLA.
For the activist researchers, and groups like the Mautner Project, their work involves a balancing act — conveying concern without fueling negative stereotypes. Many lesbians are in excellent health and, particularly if affluent or well-insured, readily find doctors they like.
"What we want to do is make sure we're all living as healthily as possible," said Cheryl Pearson-Fields of the Mautner Project. "You're focusing on the things that lead to negative health outcomes, and the message can seem very negative."
She said smoking and substance abuse, to the extent they are more prevalent among lesbians, may be linked to the stress of feeling targeted by prejudice.
Changing the attitudes of lesbians themselves is another challenge. Cochran said many get checkups far less frequently than heterosexual women who see doctors for contraceptive advice, prenatal care and postnatal care.
"Most women are brought into a health-care setting on a regular basis," Cochran said. "Men go in when something goes wrong, and in some ways lesbians are like that."
When a lesbian does make an initial visit to a gynecologist, the doctor often assumes the patient is heterosexual and asks what birth control method she uses.
"That puts you off right to begin with," said Dr. Marion Kavanaugh-Lynch, vice president of the Lesbian Health Fund. "It shouldn't be up to a patient to correct an assumption — the assumption shouldn't be made in the first place."
Such encounters compel lesbians to decide on the spot whether to disclose their sexual orientation. "Every time you face that situation, you ask yourself, 'How will this person react?'" Kavanaugh-Lynch said.
Dr. Lisa Pratt, medical director at the Lyon-Martin women's clinic in San Francisco, said some lesbians balk at confiding in a doctor even if candor might aid a diagnosis.
"There's a vulnerability disclosing information to someone you don't really know," she said. "Too often, the patriarchal white-coated physician doesn't engender that trust."
The Gay and Lesbian Medical Association has compiled a national database of physicians who depict themselves as sensitive to the health concerns of gays and lesbians. "The number is awfully small in some states," Kavanaugh-Lynch said.
Advocacy groups are working with hospitals and medical schools to provide training on how to deal empathetically with lesbian health issues.
Because many lesbians get examined less frequently than other women — and because of the relatively high smoking, drinking and obesity rates — there is widespread suspicion that they get breast and cervical cancer more often or start treatment later. They also are less likely to bear children before age 30, missing out on the breast-feeding that reduces risk of breast cancer.
"We don't know a whole lot more than that," said Kavanaugh-Lynch, a breast-cancer specialist. "It's going to be at least a decade before the research is clear."
Short term, researchers and activists seek to encourage a self-help mentality. They say some lesbians hesitate to enter weight-loss or quit-smoking programs at which heterosexual women predominate, and some have been conditioned to be disinterested in fitness.
"So many lesbians get the message from their families, 'You don't really matter because you're not going to give us grandchildren. We're not going to bother to ask you about your health,'" Robertson said.
In some cases, a tendency toward obesity may be linked to a rejection of the sleek, sexy images of women abounding in the mass media.
"Many lesbians choose to push that image aside," Horning said. "They want to look like they want to look, do what they want to do and not fit Madison Avenue's stereotype."
Obesity, diabetes and cardiovascular problems are widespread among black lesbians, "but we're not seen as a group that needs to be taken seriously," said Brenda Crawford, who coordinates health-awareness programs for minorities in Oakland.
Nationally, lesbian researchers are asking federal agencies to ensure that sexual orientation is included more often among questions asked in major health studies.
"We've gotten sick of having to give talks without data," Robertson said. "There's so much that needs to be done, and not enough funding. Our community is not being respected in terms of studying health."
___
On the Net:
Lesbian Health Research Center: http://www.lesbianhealthinfo.org
