Japan:Lawyers ask ministry to OK sign language

Miss-Delectable

New Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2004
Messages
17,160
Reaction score
7
http://www.asahi.com/english/Herald-asahi/TKY200504210115.html

The Japan Federation of Bar Associations is taking issue with the way children with severe hearing loss are being taught in schools.

It says they are being forced to practice spoken Japanese rather than using sign language-their preferred method of communication.

On April 13, the federation submitted a report to the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology calling for it to legally recognize sign language, and thus approve it as a teaching tool.

In Japan, children with impaired hearing are generally educated without the benefit of instructors using sign language.

Students are urged to stretch their limited hearing, read lips, and are given voice training. Oral speech is the norm at schools for deaf students.

The ministry acknowledged the need for improvement but downplayed the concerns of sign-language advocates.

``Sign language is not necessarily banned at schools for the hearing impaired; yet, we don't think the current situation is what's best for the children, either,'' said a ministry official. ``We will study the report and endeavor to make the field of deaf education a specialized area.''

That's not good enough for Midori Okamoto, 47, head of the Japan Deaf Children and Parents Association.

``There are plenty of (deaf) schools out there that scold children if they dare move their hands,'' Okamoto said. ``The report reflects our petition in full. We hope it will be used to help reform education for deaf students in Japan.''

In 2003, the association appealed to the federation for help, saying students' right to ``to be educated in their mother tongue'' was being breached.

The result was the recent report. It charges that deaf schools ``prioritize speaking like a hearing person, and consider sign language as something that hinders students from acquiring (spoken) Japanese.''

The policy has caused much grief to children with hearing loss, as well as to their parents.

Lawyers cited Finland as a model country where the right of deaf people to use sign language is enshrined in the Constitution.

In reality, many faculty members at schools for deaf students in Japan do not know sign language. Teachers have expressed concern at not being able to communicate properly with their students through sign language.

The report suggests that the ministry of education consider hiring more instructors with severe hearing loss.

Touching on a ministry plan to unify schools for children with impaired vision or hearing and other disabilities, the report said: ``A strong community of sign users is essential for sign language to flourish.''

It recommends special consideration be given to schools for deaf students.

*muttering angrily* Unbelievable! How archaic is it to force deaf kids to talk even if some of them cannot talk!!
 
Its the deaf/hard of hearing person's choice to use sign language or oral, I hate it when people force them to do what hearing people do.
 
Sad.....some hearing people are just so audist about speech! I know that there are some languages which are wicked wicked hard if not impossible for dhh to speak b/c they are dependant on sounds...Chinese is one....it depends on tone so much.... a word said one way can mean something totally different from a word said in another tone. But hey, at least there are people speaking out against oralist regimes and stuff.
 
Lawyers cited Finland as a model country where the right of deaf people to use sign language is enshrined in the Constitution.

:applause:

Hm maybe I should move to Finland after all.... for my future deaf children's education...

'Gatsu-- check this out! There may be hope for you in Japan!! Japan sure has came a long way, I remembered meeting several Japanese deaf students who observed my deaf/mainstreamed high school because they are interested in transfering to American Deaf Universities (Gally, CSUN, etc) because apparently in Japan there is a law that barred Deaf students to continue their education to universities. The jobs expected of them is menial jobs so many Japanese deaf students migrate to US for a college education and a better attitude toward Deaf people.
 
Miss-Delectable said:
Lawyers cited Finland as a model country where the right of deaf people to use sign language is enshrined in the Constitution.
Yep. I read the article about that sometimes ago and several scandinavian deafies praised about their services & laws for deafies. Well, that's Scandinavia for you.

gnarlydorkette said:
'Gatsu-- check this out! There may be hope for you in Japan!! Japan sure has came a long way, I remembered meeting several Japanese deaf students who observed my deaf/mainstreamed high school because they are interested in transfering to American Deaf Universities (Gally, CSUN, etc) because apparently in Japan there is a law that barred Deaf students to continue their education to universities. The jobs expected of them is menial jobs so many Japanese deaf students migrate to US for a college education and a better attitude toward Deaf people.
:D I sent this article to Nas through email recently. It is truly good news that Japan has made some progress for deafies.
 
so many Japanese deaf students migrate to US for a college education and a better attitude toward Deaf people.
Yeah, migration will increase the Deaf population tremendously!
 
*sigh* it appears that the Japanese community still have no respect and experience with the deaf community. using sound and spoken language without visual signs still will not help the deaf person speak...no matter how hard you try to make the deaf person speak, without sign language nor cued speech, it's still going to be difficult and stressful for deaf people trying to communicate. Teaching them to lip read without visual signs isn't going to help either...visual signs ALWAYS must go first in order for them to catch up faster. If I never was taught with sign language nor cued speech, there would be no way that I could finish education at the age of 18, lip read, and even write properly like anyone else. So now it seems that most japanese deaf kids are way behind than most deaf kids with sign language/cued speech.

and I thought the Japanese are supposed to be smarter than most of the western people. :roll: but I guess not always...since they are too ignorant about the deaf culture and just want them to act like hearies, even though it'll never happen that way.
 
Steel, I can see what you mean. Actually japaneses are very smart people, believe it or not. But unfortunately that they have too much pride and they tend to stake the honor over anything else. I don't believe that is due to their intelligence level but it is their culture. They were 'trained' to believe that being deaf is inferior. So if they have deaf child(ren)... deaf child(ren)'s family will be ashamed by society.

Pride and Honor is their strength and weakness.
 
Back
Top