Botts, the two men look different to me:
Bill Vicars:
• ASL • American Sign Language
Signing Savy Guy:
Sign for WATER | ASL Sign Language Video Dictionary
As for objections -- I don't know enough ASL yet to have any objections of my own. Give me time. 
In the meantime I'm just relying on other ADer's to tell me where to go to learn how to sign.
