Nation's Report Card Shows Reading Levels of High School Seniors Are Worse Than 20 Ye

Miss-Delectable

New Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2004
Messages
17,160
Reaction score
7
Nation's Report Card Shows Reading Levels of High School Seniors Are Worse Than 20 Years Ago - ParentDish

If there was such a thing as collective parenting for the entire nation, high school seniors across the country would be spending their Thanksgiving breaks holed up in their rooms, grounded and sentenced to literature.

"Don't even think about the car keys, until you've finished 'The Catcher in the Rye,' " would be the collective mantra of Mom and Dad of America.

The National Assessment of Educational Progress, referred to as the Nation's Report Card, tested 52,000 students in reading and 49,000 in math across 1,670 school districts in 2009, according to a release from the National Center for Education Statistics. And though 12th graders have made some improvement in reading, the scores are worse than they were in 1992.

Despite a teen literary devotion to the Harry Potter and Twilight series, only 38 percent of 12th graders are classified as at or above the "proficient" level, the release reports.

Students scored an average of 288 out of 500 points in reading comprehension, two points above the 2005 score, but still below the 1992 average of 292. Thirty-eight percent of 12th grade students were classified as at or above the "proficient" level, while 74 percent were considered at or above "basic," according to the release.

"Today's report suggests that high school seniors' achievement in reading and math isn't rising fast enough to prepare them to succeed in college and careers," U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan says in a separate statement.

President Barack Obama has set a goal that the United States once again will have the highest proportion of college graduates in the world by the end of the decade, Duncan adds in the statement. In a separate survey that accompanied the NAEP test, 86 percent of seniors said they expect to graduate college, Duncan says in the statement.

"They'll only succeed if we challenge and support them to raise their academic performance and offer them the financial support they need to pay for college," she adds.

Duncan says the government is taking steps to meet these goals, which include providing $40 billion over the next decade in grants for disadvantaged students and supporting states as they work together to raise standards to match college and career expectations.

The good news: Math scores rose from 150 to 153 between 2005 and 2009, according to the report.

The scores released Nov. 18 also show that a stubborn achievement gap remains across racial and ethnic groups, according to an article in Salon.com. There was no significant change in the score or gap in reading for black and Hispanic students since 1992. White and Asian students both scored higher than they did in 2005.

Asian students scored an average of 298 points in reading in 2009, higher than any other group. It was the first time since at least 1992 that a minority group outperformed white students on the test, according to Salon.com.
 
I find it amusing that there are parents who worship the mainstream as an idealized placement....if the education in the mainstream is so "good" then how come there's all this criticism about how crappy the education is?
 
If you think about Harry Potter was written at a 4th grade level of reading. Yes they are entertaining for various age groups due to the imagination running wild but as for an academic replacement, no. If we want 12th graders to be proficient we need to be pushing them beyond Harry Potter and Twilight.

When I was in school books like Catcher in the Rye, Of Mice and Men, To Kill a Mockingbird, and various Shakespearean plays were required reading. My dad told me that Moby Dick was required reading where he finished school, he literally spent an entire term reading Moby Dick and had to write a report.

Now I find that 9th graders are re-reading Charles Dickens, Romeo & Juliet all the way up until they graduate. The teachers honestly believe that as long as the students are engrossed in Harry Potter (which is a 4th grade level book series) it is enough for them to be proficient.

Now, lets look at all the Hispanic students whose first language is not English and therefore their English is not proficient enough to do well on these exams.

I think its a combination of a system gone awry, parents not caring, teachers not pushing, and the fact that we have a vastly different student body than we did 20 years ago. Also with standardized testing, teachers are left teaching the test rather than the actual course. It's sad the way our educational system has gone.
 
If you think about Harry Potter was written at a 4th grade level of reading. Yes they are entertaining for various age groups due to the imagination running wild but as for an academic replacement, no. If we want 12th graders to be proficient we need to be pushing them beyond Harry Potter and Twilight.

When I was in school books like Catcher in the Rye, Of Mice and Men, To Kill a Mockingbird, and various Shakespearean plays were required reading. My dad told me that Moby Dick was required reading where he finished school, he literally spent an entire term reading Moby Dick and had to write a report.

Now I find that 9th graders are re-reading Charles Dickens, Romeo & Juliet all the way up until they graduate. The teachers honestly believe that as long as the students are engrossed in Harry Potter (which is a 4th grade level book series) it is enough for them to be proficient.

Now, lets look at all the Hispanic students whose first language is not English and therefore their English is not proficient enough to do well on these exams.

I think its a combination of a system gone awry, parents not caring, teachers not pushing, and the fact that we have a vastly different student body than we did 20 years ago. Also with standardized testing, teachers are left teaching the test rather than the actual course. It's sad the way our educational system has gone.

:gpost: I agree with you 100%. When I was in HS, I spent my entire senior year reading Shakespeare. I hated it completely at the time, but, I'm thankful it now.
 
I find it amusing that there are parents who worship the mainstream as an idealized placement....if the education in the mainstream is so "good" then how come there's all this criticism about how crappy the education is?

The scores and percentages are certainly better than another group I'm thinking of. Perhaps it's those non-US citizens getting the freebie education on our dime is helping pull down those reading comprehensive scores?

:dunno:
 
The scores and percentages are certainly better than another group I'm thinking of. Perhaps it's those non-US citizens getting the freebie education on our dime is helping pull down those reading comprehensive scores?

:dunno:

You've got to be kidding, all over the Internet are teens that can't spell basic words, use the wrong words and haven't a clue about grammar. Don't get me wrong it's not just a US problem, but it is a growing problem.
 
Back
Top