N.C.: Program Pays $1/Day to Girls For Not Getting Pregnant

rockin'robin

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Messages
24,418
Reaction score
551
A dollar a day keeps the babies away.

That's the incentive behind College Bound Sisters, a program at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro that aims to keep 12- to 18-year-old girls in school and baby-free.

Girls in the program attend 90-minute meetings every week at which they receive lessons in abstinence and the use of contraceptives — and they receive $7 every week they do not get pregnant. The money is deposited into a fund that's collectible when they enroll in college.

But not everyone thinks paying kids to stay childless is the right way to lower the teen pregnancy rate. They say the program sends mixed messages, specifically to parents, that incentivizing good behavior is the way to go.

"It makes me a bit uneasy," said Bill Albert, chief program officer at the National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy. "I do have mixed feelings. It's hard to pay people to do something that we think they should be doing regardless. It would be like if you didn't want young people to experiment with marijuana, you'd pay them not to do it."

Despite what he called his "gut-level queasiness" about paying girls not to get pregnant, Albert acknowledged that creative ways are needed to address the "very challenging social issue" of teen pregnancy.

The nation's teen birth rate, after declining for 14 consecutive years, has increased over the last two years and now stands at 7.2 pregnancies per 1,000 teenage girls, Albert said. Furthermore, he said, three out of 10 young women become pregnant by age 20, and costs associated with teen pregnancies exceed $9 billion annually.

With those figures in mind, paying girls $365 a year to stay childless seems like a "modest investment" — especially if the program works, Albert said.

With those figures in mind, paying girls $365 a year to stay childless seems like a "modest investment" — especially if the program works, Albert said.

Dr. Hazel Brown, co-director of the program, said six girls of the 125 who have been enrolled for six months or longer have gotten pregnant or otherwise dropped out since it began in 1997. Funded by a grant from the state's Department of Health and Human Services, Brown said it costs about $75,000 a year to operate the program.

"We talk about abstinence, but it's not a requirement," Brown told FOXNews.com. "We teach decision-making, being responsible and avoiding pregnancy. The meetings are very interactive."

Enrollment in the program — which meets separately twice a week for two groups, ages 12-14 and 15-18 — is at capacity with 24 young women. To participate, girls must have never been pregnant, be enrolled in school, have a desire to attend college and have had a sister who gave birth before age 18.

Recent graduates have left the program with up to $3,000 saved up for college, including four young women who are set to begin their higher education in the fall.

Brown said the program is successful, and said its critics should consider the "cost of a teen getting pregnant," Brown said.

"When you can prevent one of those, you've more than paid for a program like this," she said. "We want to give them something to work toward. And without exception, our girls have come from homes that did not have someone with a college education …

"If somebody believes in you, there's
no end to what a lot of people can accomplish."

North Carolina Program Pays Girls a Dollar a Day Not to Get Pregnant - Local News | News Articles | National News | US News - FOXNews.com
 
I think it is excellent idea, still far cheaper than dealing with teen pregnancies and ruined long term career objective.
 
Until someone comes along and offers them something they think is more valuable to have sex.:roll:

I find the whole concept a bit disturbing.
 
Until someone comes along and offers them something they think is more valuable to have sex.:roll:

I find the whole concept a bit disturbing.

Pay me $1 per day for not flirt you.
 
Oh, I have been flirt on her big time.... :naughty:

Oh is that what you call doing this ->
flash.gif
<- PowerON shown is anatomically correct








:P
 
Paying them $1 a day not to get pregnant is fine, but the problem is that they pay them over ten times to get pregnant. It is sad that we have reached the point where we have to pay people to do the right thing.

Becoming pregnant at an inappropriate age/time leads to the greatest amount of responsibility most people will ever have.

If the fear of that doesn't do it, I tend to think $1 a day isn't going to do it. We are not talking about people with a firm grasp of risk/reward.

How about we just teach people about risk/reward? I think we tend to forget that most people we look down upon probably did not receive the best kind of support and/or live in the best social environments.
 
Sounds like a form of bribery to me.
 
Jill, I agree! I don't like that idea.

I don't think that would work...

I personally think teens need to know sex education, to learn how to control themselves without being hungry for sex, both boys & girls need to learn how to respect when someone said no. Notably, I think teens need to know being unvrigin do not make you so cool, either.

I meant, all responality (sp) is the key if it's about sex, education, and pregancy issues...

Again, I strongly disagree about pay a dollar (or few) for not having a sex. It's, no offense, just dumb. IMO... =/
 
said six girls of the 125 who have been enrolled for six months or longer have gotten pregnant or otherwise dropped out since it began in 1997.

Hmm..6 out 125 didn't "make it" over the course of 12 years. I'd say that's a pretty good return in investment. It'd be more disturbing to see teens get pregnant, have abortions and kill little human beings, ruined lives or at least make it difficult to proceed and have good opportunities, and so on. There's a support mechanism there. There is an incentive. There are role models within the group and program they can look up to and so on. It's certainly better than for the govt to pay billions of dollars for welfare support and such, the killing of babies, or face the prospect of being "punished" (according to one famous and well known person) if one decides to have a baby.
 
Above attitude is exactly why teen pregnancies and STDs are on the rise.
 
Hmm..6 out 125 didn't "make it" over the course of 12 years. I'd say that's a pretty good return in investment. It'd be more disturbing to see teens get pregnant, have abortions and kill little human beings, ruined lives or at least make it difficult to proceed and have good opportunities, and so on. There's a support mechanism there. There is an incentive. There are role models within the group and program they can look up to and so on. It's certainly better than for the govt to pay billions of dollars for welfare support and such, the killing of babies, or face the prospect of being "punished" (according to one famous and well known person) if one decides to have a baby.

So we should "pay" people not to make mistakes? Nice...
 
So we should "pay" people not to make mistakes? Nice...

Kind of reminds me of a t-shirt my son used to have that said, "Give me a dollar and I'll go away." Just pay 'em off....much easier that making the effort to teach them what they need to know.:roll: Or setting a good example.
 
Kind of reminds me of a t-shirt my son used to have that said, "Give me a dollar and I'll go away." Just pay 'em off....much easier that making the effort to teach them what they need to know.:roll: Or setting a good example.

As a teacher, I was taught the importance of intrinsic motivation and this situation is definitely gonna ruin it.
 
Okay, let's see...

Good Girl: Good morning!
Bad Girl: Good morning!
Teacher: Good morning, girls. Miss Angel, are you pregnant?
Good Girl: No, sir.
Teacher: Good. Here's a dollar. How about you, Mis Devil?
Bad Girl: Uh, nope. ...Sir.
Good Girl: OMG! You lied! I saw you have a sex with my boyfriend. Now you have my man's baby!! *sobs sobs*
Teacher: Oh, my! Sorry, honey. You can't have a dollar.
Bad Girl: But, but, but she got a lot of dollars!! I only have a few. Not fair!!! *cries hardly*
Teacher: Oh, dear!


Okay... that's a bad idea. :roll:
 
Above attitude is exactly why teen pregnancies and STDs are on the rise.


Good grief!

That is like telling someone "An apple a day will keep the doctor away"

and not teaching them about the preventions.... like hand washing... turning your head to sneeze on your shoulder... throw the tissue away when you use them. Anyhoo.. get my drift???

Can not give a dollar a day.. and expect someone not to do so. Education about prevention is the key!

This is absolutely ridiculous! "Dollar a day, keeps the babies/STD away"

That was the first thing came to mind when I read this thread.
 
Okay, let's see...

Good Girl: Good morning!
Bad Girl: Good morning!
Teacher: Good morning, girls. Miss Angel, are you pregnant?
Good Girl: No, sir.
Teacher: Good. Here's a dollar. How about you, Mis Devil?
Bad Girl: Uh, nope. ...Sir.
Good Girl: OMG! You lied! I saw you have a sex with my boyfriend. Now you have my man's baby!! *sobs sobs*
Teacher: Oh, my! Sorry, honey. You can't have a dollar.
Bad Girl: But, but, but she got a lot of dollars!! I only have a few. Not fair!!! *cries hardly*
Teacher: Oh, dear!


Okay... that's a bad idea. :roll:
Have you ever been to one of those sessions before under that program to make that kind of assessment on how it takes place? Honestly?
 
So we should "pay" people not to make mistakes? Nice...

Er, Shel, it's also called "welfare" in a lot of instances. We're paying them for their mistakes! But the difference here is that we're paying a magnitude of order higher (or more) in cost over the course of many years.
 
Back
Top