If You Were Drafted...

B

Beowulf

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
Joined
May 26, 2004
Messages
12,467
Reaction score
528
I got a question to ask, since I am very curious about opinions in this great forum...

If you were drafted into the military, and at some point in time, say, at a peaceful protest somewhere in the USA, you were ordered to open fire on the protesters, would you do it?
 
Beowulf said:
I got a question to ask, since I am very curious about opinions in this great forum...

If you were drafted into the military, and at some point in time, say, at a peaceful protest somewhere in the USA, you were ordered to open fire on the protesters, would you do it?
Click to expand...

If I was an American, and in the military... I wouldn't follow the orders, and I'll rather be shot or go to the jail.
 
I would be more than happy to serve our country no matter but just depend what kind of war is that .... for example iraq war i wouldn't support these war ... if it is germany back in WWII i would go to war to stop that idoit hilter for being murder on allot of peoples ... know what i mean ??? if they order me to go war by draft if i see that point of view war what kind are we in ... for example iraq war then i will tell them to put me in jail that's it cuz i am not support war in iraq without the evidence supportives ..
 
That's a sticky situation...


The protesters shouldn't be there in the first place. If I was attending a protest and the police showed up, I'd quickly leave. Secondly, there are a lot of protests that can be done peacefully. Most police don't do anything unless they are threatened. Secondly, the police won't be forced to fire on protesters with real bullets but with rubber bullets or pepper bullets.
 
Let me make this non-sticky a situation as possible...
If you as a soldier came to a COMPLETELY PEACEFUL PROTEST, and were ordered to fire upon the protesters, would you?
 
I'd MOVE my ass over to Canada before they ever try to scrape the bottom of the barrel and draft the Deafies.
 
Beowulf said:
Let me make this non-sticky a situation as possible...
If you as a soldier came to a COMPLETELY PEACEFUL PROTEST, and were ordered to fire upon the protesters, would you?
Click to expand...


OK if my Canadian quest fails and I get my sorry-ass drafted.... I'd throw the M-16 away and tell the commander to go fuck himself. I'd rather take a court-martial over killing some innoncent person.

Doesn't that remind of the Kent State Massacre in 1970, eh?
 
That is courage.
I asked for patience because I knew you were capable of it.
 
Last edited:
Beowulf said:
If you were drafted into the military, and . . . at a peaceful protest somewhere in the USA, you were ordered to open fire on the protesters, would you do it?
Click to expand...
First of all, draftees are enlisted into the regular Army. The National Guard is responsible for keeping order within the borders of each state.

Secondly, if it is truly a "peaceful" protest and no one is threatened, then the order to fire upon the protestors is unlawful. It is the duty of each member of the armed services to not obey an unlawful order.
 
I would never shoot innocents. I'd rather go to prison with a clear conscience than be free with a guilty one. Hey Banjo, wanna be cellmates? :beer:
 
Liza said:
I would never shoot innocents. I'd rather go to prison with a clear conscience than be free with a guilty one. Hey Banjo, wanna be cellmates? :beer:
Click to expand...

Sure, why not? :-D

I don't know if they'll allow coed prisons, lol.
 
Beowulf said:
I got a question to ask, since I am very curious about opinions in this great forum...

If you were drafted into the military, and at some point in time, say, at a peaceful protest somewhere in the USA, you were ordered to open fire on the protesters, would you do it?
Click to expand...

I guess it all depends on what they were protesting, and how much i hate the protesters, if the conditions were right, yes i would fire upon them, women and childeren too!
 
if i was chosen to be drafted I wud rather die than goin ahead with stupid draft :roll:
 
Megladon said:
I guess it all depends on what they were protesting, and how much i hate the protesters, if the conditions were right, yes i would fire upon them, women and childeren too!
Click to expand...

What kind of conditions, and what would you shoot them for?
 
Megladon said:
I guess it all depends on what they were protesting, and how much i hate the protesters, if the conditions were right, yes i would fire upon them, women and childeren too!
Click to expand...

Color me frightened :)

Personally, I don't think I could. Unless they did some kind of heinous crime, ya know.
 
Now time for the sablescort's History 101 lesson:

The Kent State Massacre of 1970:

http://www.nyu.edu/library/bobst/collections/exhibits/arch/1970/1970-2.html

Kent.gif


President Richard Nixon's announcement of the U.S. invasion of Cambodia and the need to draft more soldiers for an expansion of the Vietnam War effort provoked massive protests on campuses throughout the country. At Kent State University in Ohio, demonstrators occupied buildings and destroyed the ROTC offices. In response, the governor of Ohio dispatched hundreds of National Guardsmen to the campus. On May 4, the guardsmen open fire on a crowd of protesters, killing four student and wounding nine others.
Click to expand...
 
Well, these days, I'd shoot em cos most probably my gun will spit out dem hard neoprene bullets and just knock em silly/into the middle of next week or something. :)
 
You'd do anything to get laid, heh, ya wargasm bird ya?
 
Well, Beowulf, I guess I gotta come back here to fill in the blanks, huh? Stuff ya can't perceive between the lines, eh? S'matter of fact, I don't think I will cos you've already shown your'e not very perceptive. Have a good night, hear? :fu:
 
Back
Top