Benham brothers lose HGTV show after 'anti-gay' remarks

sara1981

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2004
Messages
7,870
Reaction score
71
Benham brothers lose HGTV show after 'anti-gay' remarks
Benham brothers lose HGTV show after 'anti-gay' remarks - CNN.com

Twin brothers David and Jason Benham have lost their opportunity to host their own HGTV show.

The brothers ran afoul of the network after the site Right Wing Watch published a post about the pair, labeling David Benham as an "anti-gay, anti-choice extremist" for reportedly leading a prayer rally in 2012 outside of the Democratic National Convention held in Charlotte, North Carolina.

The site posted a recording of Benham talking to a talk show host about "homosexuality and its agenda that is attacking the nation" and "demonic ideologies" taking hold in colleges and public schools.

Benham also discusses the fight for North Carolina's Amendment One, which involved a ban on same-sex marriage and civil unions in the state constitution.

The Benham brothers were the planned stars of the HGTV show "Flip It Forward," set to premiere in October, in which they would have helped families purchase homes they otherwise could not afford.

An April press release described the planned show this way: "After a decade of flipping houses for profit, brothers David Benham and Jason Benham now help families buy the homes they never thought they could afford. In each episode, the guys help a deserving family find a fixer-upper and transform it into their forever home -- with a healthy dose of sibling rivalry between the brothers along the way."

But after the post went public, HGTV tweeted, "HGTV has decided not to move forward with the Benham Brothers' series."

Thursday night, Jason Benham told CNN's "Erin Burnett OutFront" that HGTV had vetted the pair.

"When they -- a year and a half ago -- saw some of the footage where my brother was saying the things he was saying, they spoke with us.

"They got to know us a little better and then they made a judgment call, recognizing that David and I have no hate in our heart for anyone.

"We've been running a successful real estate company for the last 11 years and we help all people. There is no discrimination," said Jason Benham.

His comments were echoed by his brother.

"We love all people. I love homosexuals. I love Islam, Muslims, and my brother and I would never discriminate. Never have we -- never would we," said David Benham.

"Never have I ever spoken against homosexuals, as individuals, and gone against them. I speak about an agenda. And that's really what the point of this is -- is that there is an agenda that is seeking to silence the voices of men and women of faith," he added.

The brothers believe HGTV was bullied into its decision because of the media firestorm.

"It was too much for them to bear and they had to make a business decision," David Benham said.
 
I can't even comment on this stuff because I get so angry.... walk away Mew... walk away....

7k0xk1ma2borj9ugqq8zetuq1.1000x691x1.jpg
 
What a shame that HGTV caved in to pressure to cancel a positive-focused family housing program. :(
 
What a shame that HGTV caved in to pressure to cancel a positive-focused family housing program. :(

How are their remarks "positive-focused?"
They were just stupid enough to have big mouths, so live and learn, I guess.
 
How are their remarks "positive-focused?"
They were just stupid enough to have big mouths, so live and learn, I guess.
About the program: "...brothers David Benham and Jason Benham now help families buy the homes they never thought they could afford. In each episode, the guys help a deserving family find a fixer-upper and transform it into their forever home…."

That sounded positive to me.

As far as their personal lives, is it stupid to exercise one's First Amendment rights?
 
About the program: "...brothers David Benham and Jason Benham now help families buy the homes they never thought they could afford. In each episode, the guys help a deserving family find a fixer-upper and transform it into their forever home…."

That sounded positive to me.

As far as their personal lives, is it stupid to exercise one's First Amendment rights?

It would be stupid to yell "FIRE!!!" in a crowded movie theater, first amendment rights notwithstanding.
They SHOULD have known there would be consequences.
 
About the program: "...brothers David Benham and Jason Benham now help families buy the homes they never thought they could afford. In each episode, the guys help a deserving family find a fixer-upper and transform it into their forever home…."

That sounded positive to me.

As far as their personal lives, is it stupid to exercise one's First Amendment rights?


So was This Old House before the lawsuits..

The right only protects a person from the government.

We've been through this with Duck, Sterling and a bunch of other issues already.

Bottom line is stupidity has consequences, that's it.

EDIT: I'm sure a, "like minded" network will pick up the show. I wouldn't worry about it.
 
So was This Old House before the lawsuits..

The right only protects a person from the government.

We've been through this with Duck, Sterling and a bunch of other issues already.

Bottom line is stupidity has consequences, that's it.

EDIT: I'm sure a, "like minded" network will pick up the show. I wouldn't worry about it.
How do you define "stupidity" in speech?
 
Are all HGTV programs under these same restrictions on speech?
 
It's not a speech issue. It's a contract issue. They would have been agents working for a principle(HGTV), I believe. The show never aired so anything up to that point, I also believe, would be contingent.

I'm not sure if they knew before the article. At least, there is no proof that they knew, yet.
 
It's not a speech issue. It's a contract issue. They would have been agents working for a principle(HGTV), I believe. The show never aired so anything up to that point, I also believe, would be contingent.

I'm not sure if they knew before the article. At least, there is no proof that they knew, yet.
So what are you saying was the reason for the cancellation? What contract clause to all programs is a consequence for "stupidity?"
 
Stupidity is speech would be someone speaking unfavorably about their boss. Yes, I think that would be stupid.
I would like to see the wording of that clause. Also, is that what the brothers did? (BTW, some of the references in that link were by their father, not them.) And, is it retroactive?
 
I would like to see the wording of that clause. Also, is that what the brothers did? (BTW, some of the references in that link were by their father, not them.) And, is it retroactive?

The clause was an example. I don't know if they did. I also don't know if they didn't. I do know it would probably offend the sponsors as we have seen in the Sterling case, no doubt.

Was it their father on the recording? As far as I know, they are not denying their beliefs.

Obviously, it's retroactive.
 
Didn't a certain network try to do the same thing to Duck Dynasty?

I am sure HGTV probably isn't prepared for the consequences of cancelling this program. A mass boycott is being planned.

Are people free to not support totalitarian tactics as displayed by this network?
 
Back
Top