Attention: Deaf Customers of Financial Institutions

DisabRightAdvoc

New Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Disability Rights Advocates is continuing to investigate complaints from deaf customers of financial institutions concerning the widespread industry practice of failing to accept calls made through a relay service.


If you have tried to conduct business with a bank or other financial institution through a relay service and have had your relay call refused, or if the institution hung up on your relay call, we would like to talk to you.


Please email Beau Saccoccia at bsaccoccia@dralegal.org or call 510-665-8644 through the relay service, to share your story. DRA can also be reached via TTY at 510-665-8716.


Any information you share with us will be kept confidential and will help us stop this unlawful practice.
 
I guess the above is only for the United States. My experience using the Relay Service re financial institutions has been positive. I have dealt with 5 different ones -just satisfactorily- yeah even opening brand new accounts.
Perhaps because I live in Canada.

Implanted Advanced Bionics-0Harmony activated Aug/07
 
Over the telephone, I have had to no problem using the relay service to get things taken care of. My problem is the bank "freaking out" when I come in and write a note.
 
bank scam

There was another thread by a relay operator and he said that a lot of places hang up because scamers are using the relay servise for illegal purposes. I get a ton of hangups but so far not with my financial services. Shame the scamers are taking advantage of the relay service.
 
There was another thread by a relay operator and he said that a lot of places hang up because scamers are using the relay servise for illegal purposes. I get a ton of hangups but so far not with my financial services. Shame the scamers are taking advantage of the relay

service.

What device do you use?
 
device

Any device. It is the relay intro that way too often kills the call. Always I will tell the call back and say I am a customer and ignore the intro. Now there is talk about having relay users get medical proof of disability!! The scammers are gonna kill the relay service - not video relay. But if something like i711 will require medical proof then it follows that all relay services will have to do the same
 
Any device. It is the relay intro that way too often kills the call. Always I will tell the call back and say I am a customer and ignore the intro. Now there is talk about having relay users get medical proof of disability!! The scammers are gonna kill the relay service - not video relay. But if something like i711 will require medical proof then it follows that all relay services will have to do the same

Any device, you say? Do you have a videophone? Nevermind, I see you don't have one. Well, this is the crux of the matter as far as institutions are concerned, especially the banks....they are refusing to answer calls from anything but a TTY which is pretty much the dinosaur these days....
 
Last edited:
tty

I don't even have a land line. Let alone a tty. Obviously a video relay is next to impossible to scam with. I am still old school and use text relay. This is where i711 got people to register their name and address. But that hasn't stopped the scammers since you can make up any name and get a throw away phone for a number. Even a google phone number will keep your id hidden. You know the google phone lets you use a voice of your choice ? It can also throw any phone number you want to a called parties caller id. This is getting effing crazy
 
None of the above seem to apply to TTY as you need a phone line. Not much problem with scammers over the last 15 years. I have mentioned before I have Relay service delete all telephone ads/ political messages for all unanswered calls. Oh yeah I have Bell TeleMessage Service which "tapes" all incoming calls. To me worthwhile feature I pay for. The Relay service can easily access them on my behalf

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07
 
None of the above seem to apply to TTY as you need a phone line. Not much problem with scammers over the last 15 years. I have mentioned before I have Relay service delete all telephone ads/ political messages for all unanswered calls. Oh yeah I have Bell TeleMessage Service which "tapes" all incoming calls. To me worthwhile feature I pay for. The Relay service can easily access them on my behalf

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07

The "Scammers" mentioned aren't people who call YOU and leave "scam messages" etc. The "scammers" we refer to frequently in the context of TTY relay calls are Hearing people calling from countries like Nigerian who use the relay operators to conduct scams by contacting businesses via relay operator (the scammers use TTY or TTY software).

If you talk to relay operators, they will say that more than 60% of the calls they take ( in Canada and the USA) from TTY users are actaully "Scammers" - not legitimate Hoh/d/D/SI TTY users who want to place legitimate phone calls.

If is for that reason that so many places are hanging up on TTY relay calls whenever it has to do with transactions etc ... and why many places recommend that TTY callers call the businesses TTY line directly.

Of course once you start dealing with a business and they know ( and have noted in their files) that you are a TTY or Relay caller - you won't typically have this happen. It's primarily "first time" calls that one may run into difficulties.

In my case if a business has a TTY line, I always call it directly instead of using Relay (TTY or VCO mode)... calling the TTY line directly makes many places more comfortable - no to mention that most of the time if a TTY user calls the TTY line the call is answered right away - versus being stuck on hold for 5-20mins etc ... a major advantage :)
 
Anij: none of the above has any relevance to me: I am "retired person" with only one phone line. As I have mentioned before-have Bell Canada TeleMessage Service which does cut down lots of "business calls". I assume the Relay service has the incoming caller's number on their screen and can make a "judgement call if perceived to be scammers".Again assume the Relay Service will dial the number you ask for-not just random "scam calls".Seems to me to be the problem for the Relay Service which I assume they deal with quickly! Next I access the Relay Service will check they "deal with scam calls from Nigeria".

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07
 
Anij: none of the above has any relevance to me: I am "retired person" with only one phone line. As I have mentioned before-have Bell Canada TeleMessage Service which does cut down lots of "business calls". I assume the Relay service has the incoming caller's number on their screen and can make a "judgement call if perceived to be scammers".Again assume the Relay Service will dial the number you ask for-not just random "scam calls".Seems to me to be the problem for the Relay Service which I assume they deal with quickly! Next I access the Relay Service will check they "deal with scam calls from Nigeria".

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07
 
Anij: none of the above has any relevance to me: I am "retired person" with only one phone line. As I have mentioned before-have Bell Canada TeleMessage Service which does cut down lots of "business calls". I assume the Relay service has the incoming caller's number on their screen and can make a "judgement call if perceived to be scammers".Again assume the Relay Service will dial the number you ask for-not just random "scam calls".Seems to me to be the problem for the Relay Service which I assume they deal with quickly! Next I access the Relay Service will check they "deal with scam calls from Nigeria".

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07

Huh?
Please re-read my post more carefully - you've missed what I was saying.

The scammers don't call HOMES they call businesses! The issues is that businesses sometimes get so many of these scam calls from relay that businesses won't do any sort of transactions/hold merchandise etc for legitimate callers using relay - because the business has been burned too many times in the past (the scammers use relay as a disguise to commit fraud etc because they can't be tracked)

Re: Relay "editing" scammers - no, relay is NOT permitted to get involved with a call - even if they are absolutely sure that the person calling is a scammer. They aren't permitted legally to "make a judgment call" about incoming callers. The rules governing relay operators states that they are NOT to interfere with a call, insert information etc ... they are ONLY to translate what is said/types to the other party and vise versa. period. Even if they know that the person is doing something illegal etc.

There's actaully in interpreter thread in the "introduce yourself" section that deals with this - with information directly from a poster who is a relay operator - in fact you posted multiple times to the thread ... ??
 
Anij: Scammers from Nigeria-I assume they would access the Relay Service in Nigeria and have them make a long distance call for their TTY phoneline:wave:. Wouldn't the Canadian business immediately figure out something is wrong-- having customers in Nigeria?

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07
 
Last edited:
Anij: Scammers from Nigeria-I assume they would access the Relay in Nigeria and have them make a long distance call from their TTY phone. Would the Canadian business not immediately figure out sometime is wrong-- Not having customers in Nigeria?

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07

Its done through the internet!
 
Anij: Scammers from Nigeria-I assume they would access the Relay in Nigeria and have them make a long distance call from their TTY phone. Would the Canadian business not immediately figure out sometime is wrong-- Not having customers in Nigeria?

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07

They often use Internet Relay (computer based) - with proxy servers, some free software, a bit of lying (where you live, etc) you can access the USA IP relay from anywhere in the world - then call anywhere in North America.

Crooks and scammers are "tricky" and "innovative" to get what they want.

Also - as we've mentioned before - Relay operators are NOT allowed to "screen called", or interfere with calls - EVEN if they KNOW it's a scammer calling.
Think of it from this perspective .... imagine what would happen if Relay operators suddenly were allowed and legally able to decide what calls Hoh/d/Deaf/SI callers could make ??? This is what you are purposing when you say that the relay operators should "know" and be able to do something about it ... Relay isn't there to "protect" TTY users they're simply there to provide Voice to Text, and Text to Voice translation WITHOUT getting involved. Period.


You asked why businesses don't readily know they're being scammed ... having worked at a business that actually got these calls, I can explain :)
Typically the scammers will call - they don't SAY they're calling from Nigeria (this is information that authorities have found out during investigations, it's not disclosed by the callers). They will call up, and place an order for large ticket items and have them delivered - to a location IN the country (ie in Canada or the USA) and use credit cards to pay for the purchase (fakes, stolen, identity theft etc).
Another scam we saw was the caller saying that they were flying in to buy various big ticket items (much cheaper in Canada/ISA than their country etc ... or they are buying an item to be shipped overseas (many types of businesses deal with international sales on a fairly regular basis - so it DOESN'T raise an immediate "red flags" - the product is either ordered and shipped (then the card is found to be stolen/created but valid etc.). Many times the caller/scammer will say something about how they are setting up a new program for "........." and they're calling because they found online that this was the best place for the prince and products they needed etc ... then they "purchase" $3000 -7000 worth of items (under the premise that they're "starting up a new program" ... the issue is that this exact thing DOES happen legitimately ALL the time - on a monthly bases REAL companies/charities/organizations etc are starting up new programs - so that's not a "Red flag" either...

There are MANY ways that these scammers manage to get products from companies/businesses leaving the businesses in the "lurch" because the card was "valid" when rung through (swiped) etc ... but when the "real card owner" gets the bill - they catch the fraud ... of course this is TONS of legal paperwork, hours and hours of manager/owners time to track everything down etc ... and because most of the time the products are immediately run out of the country, they can't "track them" unless the product is sold to a major store, or goes in for repairs to a major store that voluntarily participates in a program to record and watch for stolen/illegally obtained etc products (including musical instruments, cars, electronics, household items etc)

The problem for businesses is that "weeding out" the real customers from the scammers is often very very difficult. The "defining" telltale hint that it is a scam - unfortunately- is that 90% of these scammers use Relay Operators as a means to do their "dirty work". This is because it allows them to disguise their true location, true name/info, prevents the company from accessing a valid "call back" number, disguises any "spoken language accents" as well as creates an "excuse" for any broken/poor English that may give away a location etc if it was heard by the company.


THAT is why so many businesses are wary of Relay Calls and won't do business transactions via relay and why they may hang up... they've either been scammed themselves in the past, or they've heard from another local business owner about how they'd been scammed - The sad part is that the honest HOh/d/Deaf/SI clients who use Relay end up penalized as well because there's no way for a business employee to know if it's a scam or really a person making a valid request - who happens to be Hoh/d/Deaf or have a SI of some kind ... having witnessed it happen on the business side, I understand the frustration and trepidation that businesses would feel especially because even if directly ASKED, Relay Operators are PROHIBITED from saying if they know/think the TTY/IP caller is a scammer :(



I'm sure if you asked your friends at CHS they'd be able to explain this and other aspects of Relay/TTY/IP/IM relay use that you're not familiar with - and more importantly explain how it impacts you (and it does, even if you're currently, unaware that it does) ~ especially if you want to be able to make educated and informed posts on the topic of TTYs, Relay etc ...

Knowledge is Power
The ability to Listen & Learn, is far more important than the ability to Hear and Know.
 
Minor problem-why would anyone want to access the Relay service using a computer? Just send an Email. Too complicated?
My experience so far using this computer and my TTY.

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07
 
Minor problem-why would anyone want to access the Relay service using a computer? Just send an Email. Too complicated?
My experience so far using this computer and my TTY.

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07

For a quick response. For ease. Those who don't use VP for relay services use the Relay via internet.
 
Minor problem-why would anyone want to access the Relay service using a computer? Just send an Email. Too complicated?
My experience so far using this computer and my TTY.

Implanted Advanced Bionics-Harmony activated Aug/07

PLEASE PLEASE go back and read the posts I'd written to you explaining how IP relay works ...

You've said a number of times how you have no use for it - however it IS worth learning a bit about so that when people talk about it here, and in "real life" you'll know WHAT they're talking about !!

Internet and Instant message Relay Services allows people to use a website or IM program IN PLACE of a TTY. The only difference between TRS (Traditional TTY Relay Service) and Internet/IP or Instant Message Relay is that instead of needing a TTY to call relay, you can access the Relay Service online using the computer keyboard (instead of a TTY keyboard). This means that "TTY users" could place a call from a computer at their friends house, at university/school, at work, or at home - where they may not have a TTY. IM Relay allows you to "call relay" from your cell phone - WITHOUT having to plug in a portable TTY to the cell.

To learn more PLEASE PLEASE either Google "internet relay service" or go to:
www.ip-relay.com
relay.att.com
www.sprintip.com
www.i711.com


In Canada many people still use TTY based relay, but in the USA many many people use Internet based relay (IP or IM) or use VRS. Soon we'll have access to IP relay in Canada (in addition to the IM relay we just got, and then VRS ... as I mentioned - YOU may not want to use any of these alternate relay services, however because they are mentioned her frequently AND you're clearly not understanding how the systems work - leading you to make in inaccurate assumptions etc about how the service work ... it would STILL be good for you to learn about the services so you can actually understand what we're talking about
 
Back
Top