Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing Announces 2010 Awa

That's why we need both. Different tools in different situations.

Right..I see learning oral skills as a tool to interact with hearing people and ASL to develop language, have full access in the educational setting, and a connection to a community if one cant find connection using spoken language or vice versa.
 
No one has ever died during a CI operation, ever. My daughter's surgeon has never had a single facial nerve issue, ever. My daughter has had her meningitis vaccine, and her inner ear is normal, so she has no greater risk than average. She had a tiny bit of pain, but after lunch and a nap, she was back to normal.

I have spoken to 4 different CI surgeons and all of them used those very words. "No one has ever died during a CI surgery".

no - it's the post-op surgery that is the killer. the infection. and the complication.

source
Reprinted with permission from the U. S. Food and Drug Administration
Center for Devices and Radiological Health
Originally issued July 24, 2002 - Updated: October 17, 2002

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has become aware of a possible association between cochlear implants and the occurrence of bacterial meningitis. Worldwide, we know of 91 reports of meningitis in patients implanted with the three FDA-approved cochlear implant devices: Advanced Bionics Corporation devices (56 cases), Cochlear Limited devices (33 cases) and MED-EL Corporation devices (1 case). A total of 17 deaths have resulted from these meningitis cases.

another source
 
And no, the risks are not higher for a healthy baby. The studies show that they are not at any greater risk of complications due to young age.

The risks of GA are greater with infants.......Forgive me if I chose to believe the FDA on this one.
 
The risks of GA are greater with infants.......Forgive me if I chose to believe the FDA on this one.

what's GA? Not a relay call? :lol:

Bad joke but what does it stand for? :ty:
 
from his post #46 - GA = General Anesthesia

oooh ok...I have to agree with TXGolfer on that one but I refrain from saying anything to any parent for making that decision. Not my place to interfere.
 
no - it's the post-op surgery that is the killer. the infection. and the complication.

source


another source

Yes, there have been deaths from meningitis. This was pre-vaccination and the implant with the higher risk has been recalled. BUT, I'm sure those improvements matter very little to those families.
 
Yes, there have been deaths from meningitis. This was pre-vaccination and the implant with the higher risk has been recalled. BUT, I'm sure those improvements matter very little to those families.

since these studies are only few years old... :ugh:
 
The risks of GA are greater with infants.......Forgive me if I chose to believe the FDA on this one.

Where does it say that the risks of GA in cochlear implant surgery are greater for infants? And at what age does it decrease? I want to read it. I had always heard that it was a "consideration" but if done by a peds team, it showed no greater rate of complication.
 
No one has ever died during a CI operation, ever. My daughter's surgeon has never had a single facial nerve issue, ever. My daughter has had her meningitis vaccine, and her inner ear is normal, so she has no greater risk than average. She had a tiny bit of pain, but after lunch and a nap, she was back to normal.

consider her a very fortunate girl. I have known a few babies or kids aren't fortunately. I suggest you to add a little sensitive for your own like you are relieve to know your girl turns out she's alright with ci after the surgery.

thank god for my hubby that he went through the same thing as your girl misskate. my hubby recovered from it for 3 weeks before he returned to work. drilling into the skull and make hole of it with extra careful. god.
 
Where does it say that the risks of GA in cochlear implant surgery are greater for infants? And at what age does it decrease? I want to read it. I had always heard that it was a "consideration" but if done by a peds team, it showed no greater rate of complication.

GA in general is more risky for infants and people over 70. Has nothing to do with CIs specifically......Why would it????? It's the risk of GA
 
oooh ok...I have to agree with TXGolfer on that one but I refrain from saying anything to any parent for making that decision. Not my place to interfere.

I agree.......I do not direct these comments at a specific parent. My problem is with the act in general.

My position is let the child decide.
 
GA in general is more risky for infants and people over 70. Has nothing to do with CIs specifically......Why would it????? It's the risk of GA

But is the risk higher because most infants who have surgery are already "high risk"? The vast majority of surgeries performed in infancy are not going to be elective, so that would skew the numbers. I would like to see some firm data about the risks of GA in infancy, in elective, non-emergency, surgery. (Especially at large children's hospital's, since most CI's are done there.)
 
I have spoken to 4 different CI surgeons and all of them used those very words. "No one has ever died during a CI surgery".

Wow! Hard to believe you met 4 Drs that are that irresponsible. If they tell a patient that, and that patient dies, and later it is proven that somewhere in the world someone did infact die from that surgery that Dr would lose his license. Not to mention open himself up to lawsuits.

Dr's are not famous for risking there license with specifics.....It's amazing you found 4 that would.
 
Children are not just "little adults." They have physiologic differences which change how anesthesia is delivered and how they tolerate it. First, a few definitions: Newborn is defined as the first 24 hours after birth, neonate is the first 30 days after birth, infant is 1 to 12 months of age, and child is 1 year of age to puberty.

Children use more oxygen than adults, nearly double in the case of neonates. Neonates also have about a 30-60% increase in cardiac output to meet their increased oxygen requirements, and both increased cardiac output and high hemoglobin level (about 17 g/dl) are needed to compensate for the diminished release of oxygen by fetal hemoglobin to tissues. Because of limited distensibility of the left ventricle, cardiac output in neonates is heart rate dependent. The oxyhemoglobin curve begins to approximate that of adults by four to six months of age.

Other physiological differences in neonates and infants include increased alveolar ventilation, increased proportion of extracellular fluid volume to body weight, more difficulty maintaining body temperature, and decreased ability to concentrate urine. Neonates and infants aren't able to compensate for extreme shifts in fluid balance as well as adults.

These physiological differences, along with differences in skeletal muscle mass, metabolic rate, and receptor maturity affect how neonates, infants, and children respond to anesthetics and other drugs
 
Wow! Hard to believe you met 4 Drs that are that irresponsible. If they tell a patient that, and that patient dies, and later it is proven that somewhere in the world someone did infact die from that surgery that Dr would lose his license. Not to mention open himself up to lawsuits.

Dr's are not famous for risking there license with specifics.....It's amazing you found 4 that would.

I think she meant that these drs are claiming that historically, that no one has died from a CI surgery. If they had said "No one WILL die from a CI surgery" then that would be a different story.
 
I think she meant that these drs are claiming that historically, that no one has died from a CI surgery. If they had said "No one WILL die from a CI surgery" then that would be a different story.

Yeah, that.
 
I think she meant that these drs are claiming that historically, that no one has died from a CI surgery. If they had said "No one WILL die from a CI surgery" then that would be a different story.

I understand, but it would be hard for a Dr to keep track of every CI surgery worldwide. I am saying no responsible Dr would make a statement like this on the remote possibility they might have missed a case in a journal somewhere.

Also "4 Dr's told me so" was a response to a request for supporting documents for FJ's declaration. It molds well with the "I was on the phone defense"
 
Just in to say -- PERSONALLY I've seen 4 failed implants out of 10.

Not a good risk assessment if i was to implant my own child.
 
Back
Top