Any recommendations of which digital aids best resemble analogue?

Discussion in 'Hearing Aids & Cochlear Implants' started by shantip, Jul 28, 2011.

  1. shantip

    shantip New Member

    Joined:
    Jul 4, 2011
    Messages:
    10
    Likes Received:
    0
    I have been wearing analogue Phonak hearing aids for nearly all my life (30 years). When it was time for me to get new aids I was frustrated when told they no longer make analogue aids any more and that I am going to have to switch to digital aids. As I am covered under the Australian Government Office of Hearing Services scheme for Pensioners I have been issued with 2 BTE Siemens’ Motion aids.
    Personally, I hate the digital aids. I find that loud sounds become louder, such as traffic sounds and clanking of cooking pots and soft sounds like birds have become softer. Furthermore, there is less clarity to the sounds, so speech is not so clear and I have to really concentrate when someone is talking to me to understand what they are saying (this was never much of an issue with analogue). The several audiologists I’ve been in contact with have fiddled with the settings to try and match them to my audio-gram and to address the issues I’ve had and all, but I’m still greatly dissatisfied. I am aware that there is an adjustment period to allow my brain to get used to hearing sounds differently, but with the new digital aids, I have felt more profoundly deaf, while all my life with analogue, I had only felt partially deaf.
    Has anyone else had similar issues of having to switch to digital hearing aids after having used analogue for so long and if anyone has any suggestions as to which digital aids resemble analogue the best? Also, does anyone know of any companies who may still make analogue?

    My Audio-gram:
    Freq..250..500..750..1k..1.5k..2k..3k..4k..6k..8k.
    L........40...45....50...70...75....75...75..55..55..60
    R........50...60...NA...70...80...80...75..60..55..60

    Thanks
    S.
     
  2. Sarfarigirl2011

    Sarfarigirl2011 Active Member

    Joined:
    Jun 24, 2010
    Messages:
    2,757
    Likes Received:
    8
    Location:
    Glastonbury, CT
    well you can try Phonak, Oticons and other brands
    I think digital is pretty cool since you can get all the neat stuff :)

    I also did kept an analog for backup which is dead, but it's still functional and it's also Siemens which I grew up with from 96-05 (I was a kid)
     
  3. Audiofuzzy

    Audiofuzzy Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jun 19, 2005
    Messages:
    4,697
    Likes Received:
    148
    Location:
    BC Canada
    Like you, at first I was severely frustrated with digital HAs and wanted only the analogue.
    But I had no choice, had to make a switch, like you I have Siemens
    only it's Nitro 700 SP.

    But what made all the difference and convinced me the digital can be as wonderful HA if not better than analogue,
    is the audiologist who was very patient, very calm and
    very accommodating to my needs,

    and who took endless hours and number of days days to find the right program suitable specifically
    for my type of hearing loss and frequencies I felt comfortable with.

    It took me 4 or 5 visits, each time about 3 hrs or more, adjusting the sounds.

    We both were extremely tired but at least I got the sound I wanted.
    If I wanted to, I can always make another appmnt and adjust my programs further.

    Think about it, maybe that's the key to you having the perfect pair of new
    digital HAs!

    Good luck!

    Fuzzy
     
    shantip likes this.
  4. djchur

    djchur New Member

    Joined:
    Nov 28, 2008
    Messages:
    473
    Likes Received:
    0
    Digital aids can be programmed to sound like analogue, just keep going back and tell them how you want them to sound. I used analogues from 1971 to 2008, at first digitals sounded quieter but after several visits to the audi and me adjusting to the new sound quality I wouldn't change back.
     
  5. shantip

    shantip New Member

    Joined:
    Jul 4, 2011
    Messages:
    10
    Likes Received:
    0
    Thanks Fuzzy

    That does offer me some consolation. With my current audiologist, they act like they don't want to spend the time and just twinkle here and there and then send me on my way. I'm going to have to shop around for a different fitter.
     
  6. VamPyroX

    VamPyroX bloody phreak from hell

    Joined:
    Feb 27, 2003
    Messages:
    34,377
    Likes Received:
    7
    Location:
    40.18, 58.41
    I don't know exactly which hearing aids to recommend, but I do know that there are some digital hearing aids that can be programmed with "MTV" mode.

    MTV mode is "music television" mode. Yeah, I know you're probably thinking about the MTV channel, but the concept is basically where it disables anti-feedback.

    Why mention this? Analog hearing aids are simple and don't really drown out background noise, static, or high pitched sounds. You basically hear "everything" with it. Since hearing people can use selective hearing to focus their listening skills, they made digital hearing aids to function almost like that.

    Most digital hearing aids have anti-feedback to give you better sound and block out (or drown out) abnormal sounds in the background such as static, high pitch sounds, etc. This becomes a problem when you're listening to music or shows on television. Music can be seen as high pitched sounds (or club music) and can be drowned out. Television usually has music and sound effects, which is also drowned out.

    My digital hearing aid has 3 modes... regular, crowd, and MTV. Regular is as it says. I use it for everyday activities. Crowd is for noisy crowded places like at a restaurant, bar, club, etc. It attempts to drown out everything except for what's in front of you like a person you're talking to. MTV is what I've just explained above. I use MTV when I'm in the car listening to my DVDs or when I'm in the movie theaters.
     
  7. northernsydney

    northernsydney New Member

    Joined:
    Jun 23, 2011
    Messages:
    69
    Likes Received:
    0
    Digital signal processing is quite different from analog signal processing. Specifically, DSP alters a signal through complex software, while ASP alters a signal through the use of hardware. The internal implementation, such as compression, operate similarly in both strategies. As long as the sampling rate is high enough a digital amplifier will sound exactly the same to the human hearing system as an analog. Particularly with speech. For years audiophiles hobbyists have claimed they can tell a very high quality analog from a high sampling rate digital signal. But in actual scientifically controlled conditions no one can consistently tell which one they are hearing. Just my very experienced opinion.
     
  8. kirandoll123

    kirandoll123 New Member

    Joined:
    Oct 16, 2011
    Messages:
    3
    Likes Received:
    0
    programming

    hi , as technology changed we opted digital with clarity ,its only programming problem some times. but i suggest you to wear ALERA 961,761 OR 561, RIC MODELS,u can have remote in hand also,u can change programme ,adjust volume or its automatic change,keep trying
    ravi
     
  9. mizwytch

    mizwytch New Member

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2010
    Messages:
    307
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    Grayson Kentucky
    Hmmm...I am being fitted with digital hearing aids for the first time. I've never had hearing aids of any sort before. Not even sure if they will work. I go Nov. 8 to get them and have them adjusted or whatever they do. I don't even know what brand they are. I only hope that they work even a little bit and I can possibly hear music again. If the hearing aids don't work then my audiologist wants me to consider implants. My hubby and another friend listened to what the sound quality of cochlear implants sound like...and both think they sound horrid...like fingers nails across a blackboard or a static-y am radio station that can't pick up a station properly; and forget about music with them. I am leaning towards a big fat NO to the implants if it comes to that. I'm not convinced they would be an improvement.
     
  10. cdmeggers

    cdmeggers Active Member

    Joined:
    May 17, 2005
    Messages:
    3,067
    Likes Received:
    20
    Location:
    Wyoming
    From my understanding, the implants may sound terrible at first (computerized, robotic, Donald Duck-like, whatever), but over time, as your brain gets used to how the sounds are being processed through the implants (and with further MAPping sessions), everything starts to sound more "normal". This is what I've learned from multiple CI recipients. Just throwing this out there. The CI recipients I've spoken with online, they all say the computer audios of what the CIs sound like, the actual CI really does not sound like that.



    As for digital hearing aids, it is an adjustment to get used to after being used to analogs. I've worn analogs until 9th grade, then I got my first digital. Took me a while to get used to, but not too long for me. I found that things sounded more clearer, and I liked that the digital HA would bring down the background noise a bit. I'm onto my 3rd digital now. With each new digital I get, I always think the new one is a big improvement over the previous digitals I've worn.
     
  11. mizwytch

    mizwytch New Member

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2010
    Messages:
    307
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    Grayson Kentucky
    Hmmmm...maybe since I have never had any sort of hearing aids before I will adjust quickly to the digital ones. I truly hope they do help. While the little buggers don't come cheap, they are still far less expensive than the implants. I have only just recently been granted SSI/Disability....and not sure if Medicaid/Medicare will even cover the cost of implants and "installation" fees if the hearing aids don't work.

    I would happily try stem cell therapy if that were offered as an option...not only is it far less expensive...but in the research I've done it has proven to be pretty effective in people fortunate enough to be able to get it.

    Ah well, I guess I will cross the implant bridge if I come to it. In any case...keep your fingers crossed that Nov. 8 will be a good day! :D
     
  12. cdmeggers

    cdmeggers Active Member

    Joined:
    May 17, 2005
    Messages:
    3,067
    Likes Received:
    20
    Location:
    Wyoming
    check with your state's medicaid program, they might be able to help cover the hearing aids for you. Medicaid paid for my new hearing aid and I didn't have to pay a cent. I was real glad Medicaid covered my hearing aid, I don't make much money and most of my money is spent on rent and bills. Hope the new hearing aids work out well for you!

    Just for info, Medicare does cover implants, 80% of the cost; so you would need secondary insurance will cover the remaining 20% (like Medicaid if your state's Medicaid covers the implants).
     
  13. Analogue

    Analogue New Member

    Joined:
    Nov 19, 2010
    Messages:
    3
    Likes Received:
    0
    I was told same thing one and half years ago when I went to get fitted for a new Hearing Aid. I had a phonak Superfront and it was on it's last legs and couldn't be repaired so I was told as they do not make Analog anymore.

    I was fitted with BTE Siemens Digital which I eventually had Tuned back to Analog. Two weeks ago I went back in for new moulds and was told I qualify for new HA's as well.

    I declined offer as the Siemens was/is working fine but my Audi asked wouldn't I like and prefer new Analog phonak Superfronts ? Eh ? I thought Analog weren't in production anymore, passed over for Digital !

    My Audi said Phonak are again making Analog Superfronts as to many people have complained of not being able to use Digital. I jumped at it and now a have new Analog Superfronts. Go to Australian Hearing and ask them about it, that's were I got mine. Cheers and good luck !
     
  14. shantip

    shantip New Member

    Joined:
    Jul 4, 2011
    Messages:
    10
    Likes Received:
    0
    Wow. Thank you Analogue.

    That made me feel better and has given me some hope.

    I had recently been fitted with another Siemens BTE Motion aid which was first tuned to resemble an analogue as close as possible. It was alright, but voices were still a bit too soft, and other sounds too loud. As my audio started to add digital features to address the first lot of issues, I started to get really bad feedback ring to most sudden sounds. Furthermore I was hearing a constant high frequency electrical humming/ringing sound when outside, near traffic or in shops. The sound I described as a high frequency cricket (the insect) sound. I felt as if I was picking up sounds that only dogs can hear! Then I was starting to get really bad tinnitus, and that constant high frequency cricket sound was present all the time, even with the aid out. I had persevered with this particular aid for 6 weeks, had 4 audio appointments in that time and got to the point I was exhausted from the whole process. I said to my Audi I need a break from it and will try again in the new year. So I'm back with my trusty 11 year old Phonak analogue aid and loving it!! They really don't make things the way they used to.

    But I will suggest to my Audi when I see her next about the Phonak Analog Superfronts. I'm already with Australian Hearing.
    Wish me luck.
     
  15. green427

    green427 Active Member

    Joined:
    Oct 14, 2010
    Messages:
    1,882
    Likes Received:
    1
    Location:
    The First State
    FYI, you can still buy analogue hearing aids via the internet. My wife's old hearing aid died, and I looked on ebay for an exact replacement, but found some brand-new ones made in Hong Kong, ordered one for $200, got it in five days, and it has been working great for over a year now. She is very happy with it, sounds exactly like the old Oticon E28P.
     
  16. shantip

    shantip New Member

    Joined:
    Jul 4, 2011
    Messages:
    10
    Likes Received:
    0
    Another good suggestion, thanks green427. Some time ago I did conduct a search on the Internet if could buy analogue aids and saw many made in China. However, I believe part of the success of getting aids (digital and analogue) to better suit you is the adjustment to settings that your Audi does to the aids. But I'll do another search, perhaps on ebay as suggested.
     
  17. DeafBadger

    DeafBadger Ad Astra Per Aspera Premium Member

    Joined:
    Aug 25, 2011
    Messages:
    1,468
    Likes Received:
    0
    Location:
    Minneapolis metro
    I really wonder what the real costs of hearing aids are if you can buy them from Hong Kong for $200. It cost $6,000 USD for my pair.

    I miss the analog ones too. Apparently, my audiologist needs to set my digital ones up better.
     
  18. jillio

    jillio New Member

    Joined:
    Jun 14, 2006
    Messages:
    60,239
    Likes Received:
    6
    Good old American skyrocketing and unreasonable medical costs.:roll:
     
  19. deafskeptic

    deafskeptic Active Member Premium Member

    Joined:
    Sep 14, 2006
    Messages:
    14,495
    Likes Received:
    0
    now I wonder too. :shock:
     
  20. deafdrummer

    deafdrummer Active Member

    Joined:
    May 17, 2009
    Messages:
    1,226
    Likes Received:
    1
    Location:
    Floating around Texas
    Several problems here... One, the frequency range on the models I tried is nowhere near what I have on my analogs, so the bass notes in music sounds like motor noises, and I can't hear the alarms at work (Phonak, Oticon, Siemens - YOU BETTER BE READING THIS!). Two, the sound processing is simply not anything resembling analog in the result that comes out of the speaker. I couldn't understand people in front of me, I couldn't understand pages, never mind tell you if that was a man or a woman making the page. Excessive sound processing was cutting sounds in and out instead of allowing them to happen naturally, as in music.

    Here's a real-world test. Wear your analog HAs, listen to a singer or announcer's voice at a rock concert, and then take off your HAs and step right up to the Marshall stack (amplifiers) and listen to the voice again. It should be the same. I mean, how many people go to an opera to listen to a world-famous operatic singer sounding like a computer or singing through a vocoder?! That is what digital HAs sound like. I know because I have done this test myself.

    These HAs are sold to people who do not have a sufficiently developed hearing cortex to be able to tell that what the HA is putting out is not what is really happening out there in the air. The fact that your digitals don't sound right to you tells you that you need to trust your intuition - you are being sold something that was made for the sake of being made and training the engineers how to design and make circuit boards and for money. You ARE right when you sense that the hearing aids don't sound right. There's not an "adjustment" you have to make in your on hearing perception. The companies are relying on the fact that some people's hearing is so bad they can't tell the difference - I can tell the difference, with a 98% comprehension rating on the simple "Say the word" test. Again, how many people buy a PA system, and the sounds end up being nothing like the way the person sounds naturally, and you can hardly understand them, and then you say, "Awesome, great! We're ready to go for the presentation!" And nobody ends up understanding a single word that is being said. Questions are taken at the end of of the presentation, and the first question from the audience is, "Umm, I don't know what was the question you just asked us, but we have to say, 'What in the world were you talking about? I didn't understand a word you were saying the entire time!"

    The situation with the digitals is like the hand hitting the opposite shoulder twice with a stupid look on the face.
     

Share This Page

Looking to buy hearing aids online? Check out Hearex.com