AllDeaf.com - View Single Post

Liebling:-))) · 04-18-2008, 09:33 AM

[quote]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reba

People (I use the term loosely) who kill for thrill and pleasure don't regret their killings. They relive them in their minds for pleasure. They love to describe the killing over, and over again. They impress their fellow inmates. They enjoy their life sentences. That's not punishment. A life sentence teaches nothing.

This is your opinion if you mean ALL murderers.

Yes, a life sentence teaches lesson.

You did not quote to answer my question.

Quote:

Liebling's post
Is it right to teach someone that killing is wrong by killing them? Can you explain how can we teach that killing is wrong by showing that kill as a punishment is right?

Quote:

Regret and sorrow for victims is for normal feeling people. Murderers are not normal. They don't have normal feelings of pity and remorse.

If you mean ALL murderers then is your opinion.

Quote:

Ask a victim's family. I have read many, many families say that the execution was a relief to them. Not a pleasure, not revenge but relief.

Yes I've read, too. They said this but it's really truth is never, never, never solve to satisfy them because they lost their loved one forever.

Quote:

The prisoners themselves say that. The criminal psychologists say that. When I get home later today I'll look up the sources. I'm surprised that you never read that before.

I am surprised either that you think "All" murderers which it is not all like this.

Quote:

So how does it punish the killer? It doesn't. They are thrilled to get all that attention. Why should the killer get pleasure? It's not fair to the victims.

They don't feel guilty. They enjoy killing.

Are you saying that all murderers?

Quote:

You've got to be kidding!

I'm surprise that you didn't know that.

Quote:

So the victims can become prisoners of fear while the killer runs around freely?

First you said "escaped" then change again and said "runs around freely"?

1. If the killer escaped out of prison then all victims and witnesses get protection as long as the killer get catch.

2. If the killer are out of prison after long years... Do you really think the victims and witnesses stay the same place where and how the killer kill their loved one? No, they would move out to other state for their safety.

Quote:

In your opinion. Ask the victims for their opinion.

You didn't quote to answer my question.

Repeat...

Quote:

Liebling"s post.
That's just we disagree that it's okay for government to kill human when they know killing is wrong but why is okay to kill as a punishment? I do not consider death penalty as a punishment but vengeance.

What would you consider if government kill innoncent... ? Murder? Would government also get death penalty as a "punishment" for kill wrong person to be fair?

If you think kill is okay then don't teach anyone that kill is not okay.