Originally Posted by Chase

Okay, Kaitin, I struck out with 1. Texan 2. Athlete 3. Bracelet, but The Longhorns are a Texas football team that sells cowhide bracelets to fans. It wasn't completely crazy, ha ha ha.

Here I go again:

1. Kills dogs
2. The movie "Psycho"
3. Valentine's Day

Chocolate kills dogs, was used for blood in Hitchcock's Psycho, and is given to lovers on Valentine's Day. Is the answer chocolate?