Quote:
Originally Posted by Liebling:-)))
 I do not see anything that my word is an insult but question. Please re-read my post carefully... Example: Would you do if a general tell you to shoot the innocent person?. Is "question an insult? No, if you accuse something wrongly then is an insult. I do not insult but ASK you QUESTION. You call Watada as a coward is an insult because you ACCUSED him, not QUESTION him. Get the difference?
I use the example to ASK you question because of your previous posts... You repeated to say that Watada broke the oath, contract, etc. and must obey the order, etc. and then call him coward for say no. I repeated you that Watada has the right to say no to the order when he felt it´s wrong. You denied and keep saying that Watada is wrong... coward, etc. That´s an exactly why I tried to tell you that we can say NO. |
Do you want me to ask you a theoretical question - would you ever molest your child? That is an insulting question, isn't it? He was being ordered to deploy to a location. How is that illegal? Is it illegal to order him to be deployed in North Korea? or Saudi Arabia? or Israel? The WHOLE issue with Watada is
the ORDER OF DEPLOYMENT, not an ORDER OF KILLING INNOCENT PEOPLE.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Liebling:-)))
|
I'm not sure what you're trying to tell me with that link. It proved what we're saying - Canadian Supreme Court said the soldiers' reason for desertion and refusal to obey the "illegal" order is irrelevant for refugee status. Same thing for Watada. His reason of disobeying the order of deployment based on the illegality of Iraq War is IRRELEVANT.